Paycheck Showdown Rules Handout Personal Finance Simulation
Paycheck Showdown
Can you survive 30 days of real-world bills, choices, and surprise roadblocks?
Time
1 Month
(4 Rounds)
Your Mission
Manage your starting cash and monthly paycheck across four weeks of real-life expenses. Finish the month with a positive balance and at least $200 in savings —without going into debt!
What You Need
• 1 Monthly Ledger Worksheet
• 1 Career Card (drawn at random)
• Access to Expense & Roadblock Cards
• A pencil and calculator (optional)
How to Play: 4 Rounds of Real Life
1
Draw Your Career & Starting Cash
Pick one Career Card face-down. Record your Job Title , Starting Cash , and Monthly Net Pay (take-home pay after taxes) at the top of your ledger. Add Starting Cash + Monthly Net Pay to get your Total Starting Funds .
2
Lock In Your Fixed Monthly Bills
Before anything fun happens, pay for the basics. Choose 1 Housing option, 1 Transportation option, and 1 Food & Phone plan from the Fixed Expense Menu on your ledger. Subtract those—plus any student loan on your card—from your balance.
3
Survive 3 Roadblock & Life Event Rounds
Your teacher will announce Week 2 , Week 3 , and Week 4 . Each week, draw 1 Roadblock Card and 1 Lifestyle & Choice Card . Record every cost—or surprise bonus!—in your running ledger and update your balance.
4
End-of-Month Reckoning & Reflection
Calculate your final balance. Did you stay above $0? Did you hit the $200 savings target? Complete the reflection questions at the bottom of your worksheet to analyze what worked—and what caught you off guard.
What If You Hit $0?
If your balance drops below $0, you are in Overdraft / Debt . Keep playing! Record negative numbers clearly (e.g., −$140) and add a $35 overdraft fee for each new expense while negative.
Survival Tiers
$500+ left: Budget Boss
$200–$499 left: Financially Stable
$1–$199 left: Paycheck-to-Paycheck
$0 or negative: In the Red (Needs Adjustment)
Paycheck Showdown • Student Rules Tip: Always check your running balance before saying "yes" to optional spending!
Monthly Ledger Worksheet Paycheck Showdown
Monthly Budget Ledger
Name:
Date:
Round 1: Career & Starting Funds
Career Title
Starting Cash (+)
$
Monthly Net Pay (+)
$
Total Starting Funds (Starting Cash + Monthly Net Pay): $
Round 2: Fixed Monthly Bills (Choose 1 per Category)
Check one box in each column
Housing
Roommates ($750)
Shared 2BR apt + utilities
Studio Apt ($1,150)
Solo living + utilities
1BR Luxury ($1,550)
In-unit laundry & gym
Transportation
Transit Pass ($95)
Bus & rail unlimited
Used Car ($340)
Insurance + gas + upkeep
Car Loan ($560)
Payment + full coverage + gas
Food & Phone
Meal Prep ($280)
Groceries + basic phone plan
Balanced ($420)
Groceries + 4x takeout + phone
Foodie ($600)
Delivery + dining + unlimited
Running Transaction Ledger
Round / Week
Item / Card Description
Income (+)
Expense (−)
Balance ($)
Round 1
Total Starting Funds
—
Round 2
Housing Choice
—
Round 2
Transportation Choice
—
Round 2
Food & Phone Choice
—
Round 2
Student Loan / Training (if on card)
—
Continue to Page 2 for Weeks 2–4 Roadblocks & Reflection →
Round 3: Roadblocks & Life Events (Weeks 2–4)
Add $35 overdraft fee if balance is below $0
Round / Week
Card Title / Event
Income (+)
Expense (−)
Balance ($)
Wk 2 Roadblock
Wk 2 Choice
Wk 3 Roadblock
Wk 3 Choice
Wk 4 Roadblock
Wk 4 Choice
Extra / Fee
Round 4: End-of-Month Summary
Final Balance ($)
Total Roadblock Costs ($)
Survival Tier Achieved
Post-Game Reflection
1. Which fixed bill or roadblock had the biggest impact on your budget, and why?
2. If you replayed this month with the same career, what one spending choice would you change?
3. Why is having an emergency fund (starting savings) important even when you have a steady paycheck?
Paycheck Showdown • Monthly Budget Ledger
Career Cards Cutouts Paycheck Showdown • Cut Along Dashed Lines
Career & Starting Cash Cards (Set A)
4 Cards / Page
Career Card #1
HVAC Apprentice
You completed a paid apprenticeship right out of high school and earned your EPA certification with zero college debt.
Starting Cash: $650
Monthly Net Pay: $2,650
Student Loan / Training: $0 / mo
Career Card #2
Shift Lead Barista
You work 35 hours/week at a busy neighborhood café while taking community college classes online. Tips help!
Starting Cash: $400
Monthly Net Pay: $1,950
Student Loan / Training: $0 / mo
Career Card #3
Registered Nurse (BSN)
You landed a full-time hospital role after earning your 4-year nursing degree. Great pay, steady hours, and a loan bill.
Starting Cash: $500
Monthly Net Pay: $3,750
Student Loan / Training: −$320 / mo
Career Card #4
IT Help Desk Tech
You earned a CompTIA A+ certificate and work remote/hybrid troubleshooting tech issues for a regional school district.
Starting Cash: $750
Monthly Net Pay: $2,800
Student Loan / Training: −$85 / mo
Print & cut into individual cards • Distribute 1 per student
Paycheck Showdown • Cut Along Dashed Lines
Career & Starting Cash Cards (Set B)
4 Cards / Page
Career Card #5
Logistics Coordinator
You manage shipping schedules at a fulfillment center. Fast-paced work with solid benefits and overtime potential.
Starting Cash: $550
Monthly Net Pay: $2,450
Student Loan / Training: $0 / mo
Career Card #6
Junior Graphic Designer
You graduated with an associate degree in digital media and design social graphics for a local marketing agency.
Starting Cash: $350
Monthly Net Pay: $2,300
Student Loan / Training: −$160 / mo
Career Card #7
Staff Accountant
With a bachelor's in accounting, you handle payroll and audits for small businesses. High starting pay, hefty loans.
Starting Cash: $450
Monthly Net Pay: $3,400
Student Loan / Training: −$290 / mo
Career Card #8
Licensed Cosmetologist
You finished beauty school in 12 months and rent a chair at a busy salon. Your income blends base pay and tips.
Starting Cash: $800
Monthly Net Pay: $2,200
Student Loan / Training: −$110 / mo
Print & cut into individual cards • Distribute 1 per student
Expense & Roadblock Cards Paycheck Showdown • Cut Along Dashed Lines
Budget Roadblock Cards (Mandatory Events)
6 Cards / Page
Roadblock #1
Flat Tire & Alignment
You hit a nasty pothole on your morning commute and need a replacement tire plus an alignment.
Cost: −$185
Exception: If you chose Transit Pass, pay $0!
Roadblock #2
Urgent Care Copay
A sudden fever sends you to urgent care for a rapid test and prescription antibiotics.
Cost: −$120
Covers clinic copay + pharmacy pickup.
Roadblock #3
Cracked Phone Screen
Your phone slipped onto concrete and the screen won't respond to touch. You need it for work.
Cost: −$140
Same-day screen repair + protective case.
Roadblock #4
Utility Rate Spike
A brutal heat wave forced the A/C to run nonstop, pushing your electric bill higher than planned.
Cost: −$75
Exception: If you have Roommates, pay only $40!
Lucky Break #5
Weekend Overtime Shift
A coworker needed coverage and your manager offered time-and-a-half pay for Saturday.
Bonus: +$150
Add this directly to your running balance!
Roadblock #6
Speeding Camera Ticket
You were running late and caught a photo-enforced speed zone on the way to work.
Cost: −$160
Exception: If you chose Transit Pass, pay $0!
Print & cut into individual cards • Draw 1 per week (Weeks 2–4)
Paycheck Showdown • Cut Along Dashed Lines
Lifestyle & Choice Cards (Pick Option A or B)
6 Cards / Page
Choice #1
Touring Concert Weekend
Your favorite artist is in town Friday night and your group chat is buying tickets right now.
Option A: Buy ticket + merch (−$110)
Option B: Host a watch party at home (−$10)
Choice #2
Best Friend's Birthday
Everyone is meeting at a sit-down restaurant to celebrate your friend's 19th birthday.
Option A: Full dinner + gift card (−$55)
Option B: Appetizer only + handmade gift (−$20)
Choice #3
Subscription Creep
Your 3 streaming apps, music plan, and cloud storage all renew on the same day.
Option A: Keep every subscription (−$50)
Option B: Cancel 3, keep 1 favorite (−$15)
Choice #4
40% Off Flash Sale
A brand you love is running a 24-hour sale on shoes and jackets you've been eyeing.
Option A: Grab the deal now (−$125)
Option B: Close the tab & wait ($0)
Choice #5
Mid-Week Convenience
You're exhausted on Wednesday and tempted to order delivery and iced coffee for 3 days straight.
Option A: Delivery & coffee runs (−$75)
Option B: Make pasta & brew at home (−$12)
Choice #6
Fitness & Wellness
You want to stay active this month—either join a boutique fitness studio or use free local options.
Option A: Boutique gym membership (−$65)
Option B: Outdoor runs & free videos ($0)
Print & cut into individual cards • Draw 1 per week (Weeks 2–4)
Paycheck Showdown Teacher Guide Teacher Facilitation Guide
Paycheck Showdown (45–60 Min)
Grades 9–12
Personal Finance / Econ
Prep Checklist (Class of 30)
• Rules Handout: 15 copies (1 per pair) or project on board.
• Monthly Ledger: 30 copies (1 double-sided per student).
• Career Cards: Print 4 sets (32 cards), cut & shuffle face-down.
• Expense & Roadblock Cards: Print 1 set per table group (4–5 students) and cut into two decks: Roadblocks & Choices.
Learning Objectives
• Distinguish between net pay , fixed bills , and variable/unexpected expenses .
• Practice maintaining a running balance and avoiding overdraft fees.
• Evaluate trade-offs between wants, needs, and emergency savings.
45–60 Minute Pacing Plan
Time
Phase
Teacher Moves & Student Actions
0–5 min
Launch & Rules
Introduce the survival goal ($200+ left at month's end). Distribute Ledgers and review the 4-round structure.
5–15 min
Rounds 1 & 2: Career & Fixed Bills
Students draw 1 Career Card, calculate Total Starting Funds, select Housing/Transit/Food, and subtract Fixed Bills + Student Loans.
15–35 min
Round 3: Weeks 2–4 Roadblocks
Call out each week (~6 min/week). At table groups, each student draws 1 Roadblock + 1 Choice Card, updates their ledger, and checks math with a partner.
35–43 min
Round 4: Summary & Reflection
Students calculate Final Balance, identify their Survival Tier, and complete the 3 reflection prompts on Page 2.
43–50 min
Whole-Class Debrief
Poll Survival Tiers by show of hands. Discuss how Housing/Transit choices affected Roadblock resilience.
Differentiation & Tips
• Support: Pair students as "accountant buddies" to double-check subtraction after Round 2. Allow calculators.
• Extension: Challenge early finishers to calculate what percentage of their net pay went to Housing (compare to the 30% rule).
• Short on Time? Run only Weeks 2 and 3 in Round 3, saving 6–7 minutes.
Debrief Discussion Prompts
1. "Who had a high salary but still struggled? Why?" (Connects to lifestyle creep & loans.)
2. "How did choosing the Transit Pass or Roommates protect you during Roadblocks?"
3. "What is one real-life habit you can start before graduation to build an emergency buffer?"
Paycheck Showdown • Teacher Guide No-prep digital option: Project Roadblock/Choice cards on screen for the whole class to draw together.