Decision Lab Slides 2-Day Career & Life Skills Lesson
Critical Thinking &
Problem-Solving
How to analyze facts objectively, make confident decisions, and solve complex problems in school, work, and everyday life.
Day 1: Core Skills & Distinctions Day 2: Frameworks & Real-World Application
Day 1 Lesson Objectives
After completing this lesson, you will be able to:
Define critical thinking, decision-making, and problem-solving—and explain how they differ.
Discuss practical ways to improve your critical thinking and decision-making skills.
Explain the fundamental steps for analyzing and finding solutions to a problem.
Warm-Up Quick Check
Which of the following is the best definition of critical thinking?
A
Finding the possible options to make a decision
B
Working in a team environment to solve specific issues
C
Identifying problems that arise in the workplace
D
Determining the best solution after reviewing all options
Warm-Up Answer
Correct Answer: D
Determining the best solution after reviewing all options
Why?
Critical thinking is a process where someone looks at a situation or problem objectively by reviewing all possible solutions before making any decisions.
Three Connected—but Different—Skills
They work together in careers and daily life, yet each plays a distinct role.
Critical Thinking
An integral part of decision-making. Focuses on gathering facts objectively and resisting hearsay or bias.
Decision-Making
An action (a step inside problem-solving). Compares options to choose the best course of action.
Problem-Solving
An ongoing, analytical process that identifies possible solutions with the goal of reaching a decision.
Skill 1 of 3
Critical Thinking
The Goal
Determine the best outcome for any situation at any time by gathering facts and viewing them objectively.
Watch Out For Groupthink
Simply agreeing with a group or a superior is not critical thinking. Uncover all sides of the situation.
Key Habits of a Critical Thinker
Recognize your own biases • Stay skeptical • Examine facts closely • Challenge poor assumptions to uncover errors and inconsistencies
Skill 2 of 3
Problem-Solving
A complex, analytical process that identifies possible solutions in order to make a decision.
1. Define the problem
Clarify what actually needs to be solved.
2. Brainstorm alternatives
Uncover all possible solutions.
3. Choose the best strategy
Weigh options and make a decision.
4. Implement the solution
Put the chosen plan into action.
Workplace Reality — Compromise: Working with multiple people and personalities often requires balancing stakeholders' preferences.
Skill 3 of 3
Decision-Making
What It Is
The process of determining the best course of action for an important situation—whether individually or in a business/group setting.
Process vs. Action
Problem-solving is an ongoing process; decision-making is an action within that process. One decision can reveal a new problem, starting the cycle again.
Confidence Builds Trust
When you feel confident in your decision-making abilities, others trust your rationale and judgment.
Day 1 Check-In Apply the Definitions
Case Check: Hank's Software Choice
Hank is trying to figure out which computer software is best for his company. He looks at each option to determine the best solution. This shows him using critical-thinking skills. To do this well, he must be skeptical by avoiding preconceived notions about the products.
Quick Question:
Which skill is an ongoing process rather than a single action?
→ Problem-solving (decision-making is an action inside it)
Day 2 Applying the Skills
Critical Thinking in Everyday Life
Imagine scrolling social media and seeing a post claiming a food item boosts immunity—with a link to buy it. Do you order right away, or stop and question the claim?
Questions to Evaluate Any Claim:
Source: Where did this article or post originally come from?
Intentions & Bias: Does the author have a vested interest (like selling a product)?
Reliability: Are the author's supporting sources credible and verifiable?
3 Ways to Improve Critical Thinking
Tip 1
Know Yourself
Build self-awareness to uncover personal feelings, biases, and ingrained thought habits so you can separate emotion from objective fact.
Tip 2
Understand Others
Practice active listening to uncover people's real intentions and develop foresight into how they may react to different outcomes.
Tip 3
Become More Skeptical
Ask more questions when processing information and examine existing evidence closely to gain insight and predict future outcomes.
Objective Approach to Decision-Making
Use this 4-step framework—like when comparing two job candidates—to make stronger decisions.
Step 1
Identify Criteria
Choose measurable, objective attributes (e.g., top five criteria for a role).
Step 2
Rank & Weigh
Use simple math to grade and rank options—measurable attributes are easier to compare.
Step 3
Check Instincts
Pause and ask: Are there any red flags or missing information?
Step 4
Commit
Stand behind your choice with confidence so others commit to it too.
5 Steps for Problem-Solving
Case Study: A hospital imaging department needs to replace outdated X-ray machines.
Step 1
Identify the problem: Assess how many machines need replacing and the budget.
Step 2
Gather information: Explore updates, 2-year phase-in, or lower-cost vendors.
Step 3
Evaluate alternatives: Weigh pros/cons and short- vs. long-term goals; cut nonviable options.
Step 4
Make a choice: Select buying new X-ray machines from a reasonably priced vendor.
Step 5
Implement the solution: Negotiate terms, get management approval, and process invoices.
Lesson Summary
Key Takeaways
Critical Thinking: Determining the best outcome by gathering facts objectively, questioning assumptions, and checking your own biases.
Decision-Making: The action of choosing the best course of action—strengthened by measurable criteria, ranking, red-flag checks, and commitment.
Problem-Solving: An ongoing analytical process (Identify → Gather → Evaluate → Choose → Implement) powered by critical thinking and decision-making.
Decision Lab Guided Notes Day 1 Guided Notes
Name: ________________________ Date: ____________
Critical Thinking & Problem-Solving
Warm-Up Check
Critical thinking is a process where someone looks at a situation or problem _____________________ by reviewing all possible _____________________ before making any decisions.
1. Three Connected—but Different—Skills
Critical Thinking
• Goal: Determine the _________________ outcome for any situation at any time.
• Requires gathering _________________ objectively—not just agreeing with a group or superior.
• Recognize your own _________________, stay _________________, and challenge assumptions to uncover errors or inconsistencies.
Problem-Solving
• An _________________ process that identifies possible solutions to reach a decision.
• Four core actions: (1) _________________ the problem, (2) _________________ all alternative solutions, (3) choose the best _________________, and (4) _________________ the solution.
• Workplace key: The ability to _________________ between multiple stakeholders' preferences.
Decision-Making
• Determining the best _________________ of _________________ for an important situation.
• Occurs in both _________________ settings and business/group settings.
• Confidence in your decisions helps others trust your _________________ and judgment.
2. Process vs. Action
• Problem-solving is an ongoing _________________, while decision-making is an _________________ (a step inside problem-solving).
• Critical thinking is an integral part of _________________, helping you resist hearsay or preconceived assumptions.
Case Check (Hank): Hank compares computer software options for his company. He is using _____________________ skills, which require him to be _________________ by avoiding preconceived notions.
Day 1 Quick Reflection: Describe one decision you made this week and how you compared your options.
Day 2 Guided Notes
Name: ________________________ Date: ____________
Applying & Improving the Skills
3. Evaluating Everyday Claims (e.g., Social Media)
Before trusting a claim or buying a promoted product, ask: (1) What is the _________________ of the article? (2) Does the author have a _________________ interest? (3) Are the author's sources _________________?
4. Three Ways to Improve Critical Thinking
Tip 1 — _________________ Yourself: Uncover personal feelings, biases, and ingrained thought processes to separate emotion from objective _________________.
Tip 2 — _________________ Others: Use active _________________ to understand others' real intentions and anticipate how they will react.
Tip 3 — Become More _________________: Ask more questions and examine existing _________________ to gain foresight and predict outcomes.
5. Objective Approach to Decision-Making (4 Steps)
Step 1: Identify measurable, objective _________________.
Step 2: _________________ and weigh those attributes using simple math.
Step 3: Check instincts for _________________ flags or missing info.
Step 4: _________________ to the decision with confidence.
6. Five Steps for Problem-Solving (Hospital X-Ray Case Study)
Step
What Happens (Hospital Example)
1. Identify the ____________
Assess how many X-ray machines need replacing & check the ____________.
2. Gather _______________
Explore updates, 2-year phase-in, or finding a lower-price ____________.
3. Evaluate _____________
List pros/cons, check short- vs. ____________-term goals, cut nonviable options.
4. Make a _______________
Select the best viable option: buy new machines at a reasonable price.
5. ____________ the solution
Negotiate terms, get management approval, and handle invoices/receipts.
Decision Lab Notes Key Day 1 Teacher Answer Key
Decision Lab Guided Notes
Critical Thinking & Problem-Solving
Warm-Up Check
Critical thinking is a process where someone looks at a situation or problem objectively by reviewing all possible solutions before making any decisions.
1. Three Connected—but Different—Skills
Critical Thinking
• Goal: Determine the best outcome for any situation at any time.
• Requires gathering facts objectively—not just agreeing with a group or superior.
• Recognize your own biases, stay skeptical, and challenge assumptions to uncover errors or inconsistencies.
Problem-Solving
• An analytical process that identifies possible solutions to reach a decision.
• Four core actions: (1) define the problem, (2) brainstorm all alternative solutions, (3) choose the best strategy, and (4) implement the solution.
• Workplace key: The ability to compromise between multiple stakeholders' preferences.
Decision-Making
• Determining the best course of action for an important situation.
• Occurs in both individual settings and business/group settings.
• Confidence in your decisions helps others trust your rationale and judgment.
2. Process vs. Action
• Problem-solving is an ongoing process, while decision-making is an action (a step inside problem-solving).
• Critical thinking is an integral part of decision-making, helping you resist hearsay or preconceived assumptions.
Case Check (Hank): Hank compares computer software options for his company. He is using critical-thinking skills, which require him to be skeptical by avoiding preconceived notions.
Day 1 Quick Reflection (Sample Student Response):
Answers will vary. Look for students identifying a real choice (e.g., choosing a club, job shift, or purchase) and explaining how they compared pros/cons or facts objectively.
Day 2 Teacher Answer Key
Decision Lab Guided Notes
Applying & Improving the Skills
3. Evaluating Everyday Claims (e.g., Social Media)
Before trusting a claim or buying a promoted product, ask: (1) What is the source of the article? (2) Does the author have a vested interest? (3) Are the author's sources reliable?
4. Three Ways to Improve Critical Thinking
Tip 1 — Know Yourself: Uncover personal feelings, biases, and ingrained thought processes to separate emotion from objective fact (or truth).
Tip 2 — Understand Others: Use active listening to understand others' real intentions and anticipate how they will react.
Tip 3 — Become More Skeptical: Ask more questions and examine existing evidence to gain foresight and predict outcomes.
5. Objective Approach to Decision-Making (4 Steps)
Step 1: Identify measurable, objective criteria.
Step 2: Rank and weigh those attributes using simple math.
Step 3: Check instincts for red flags or missing info.
Step 4: Commit to the decision with confidence.
6. Five Steps for Problem-Solving (Hospital X-Ray Case Study)
Step
What Happens (Hospital Example)
1. Identify the problem
Assess how many X-ray machines need replacing & check the budget.
2. Gather information
Explore updates, 2-year phase-in, or finding a lower-price vendor.
3. Evaluate alternatives
List pros/cons, check short- vs. long-term goals, cut nonviable options.
4. Make a choice
Select the best viable option: buy new machines at a reasonable price.
5. Implement the solution
Negotiate terms, get management approval, and handle invoices/receipts.
Critical Choices Worksheet Practice Worksheet
Name: ________________________ Date: ____________
Critical Choices in Action
Part A: Skill Spotter
Read each scenario. Write whether it primarily demonstrates Critical Thinking , Decision-Making , or Problem-Solving , then explain why.
1. Maya's team is split on which marketing vendor to hire. She reviews each vendor's past data, checks for hidden fees, and questions the sales pitch before forming an opinion.
Skill & Why:
2. After comparing scores on a rubric, Devon selects Candidate B as the new shift supervisor and announces the choice to the team with confidence.
Skill & Why:
3. Delivery orders at a bakery keep arriving late. The manager defines the bottleneck, brainstorms route changes with drivers, picks a new schedule, and rolls it out.
Skill & Why:
Part B: Evaluate a Claim
Scenario: You see a viral post from a fitness influencer claiming: "This 3-ingredient morning drink boosts immunity by 300% in 7 days—click my link to buy a 30-day supply!"
1. Source & Reliability: How would you check if the claim's sources are reliable?
2. Vested Interest: What vested interest might the influencer have in making this claim?
3. Skepticism: Write one question you would ask before deciding whether to buy or share this post.
Critical Choices in Action (continued)
Page 2
Part C: 4-Step Objective Decision-Making
Scenario: You are choosing between two part-time summer jobs: Job A (15 min away, $15/hr, fixed schedule) and Job B (35 min away, $17/hr, flexible hours). Walk through the 4 steps below.
Step 1: Identify Measurable Criteria (list 3)
Step 2: Rank & Weigh Your Options
Step 3: Check Instincts / Red Flags
Step 4: Commit to Your Choice
Part D: 5-Step Problem-Solving Plan
Scenario: Your school's media club has two outdated laptops that crash during video editing, and a limited club budget. Map out how you would solve this using all 5 steps.
Problem-Solving Step
Your Action Plan
1. Identify the problem
2. Gather information
|
| 3. Evaluate alternatives |
|
| 4. Make a choice |
|
| 5. Implement the solution |
|
Skill Check Quiz Mastery Quiz
Name: ________________________ Date: ____________
Critical Thinking & Problem-Solving Quiz
Part 1: Multiple Choice — Circle the best answer for each question.
1. Which of the following is the best definition of critical thinking?
A. Finding the possible options to make a decision
B. Working in a team environment to solve specific issues
C. Identifying problems that arise in the workplace
D. Determining the best solution after reviewing all options
2. Which of the following is an ongoing process rather than a single action?
A. Problem-solving
B. Decision-making
C. Critical thinking
D. Analyzing
3. Which action is NOT consistent with critical thinking?
A. Challenging assumptions to uncover inconsistencies
B. Agreeing with a group or superior without examining the facts
C. Recognizing your own personal biases
D. Gathering facts and viewing them objectively
4. In the objective approach to decision-making, which step comes right after ranking and weighing measurable attributes?
A. Identifying red flags or missing information
B. Gathering information
C. Understanding others
D. Becoming skeptical
5. Why does the objective decision-making model emphasize measurable attributes?
A. They eliminate the need to ever commit to a decision
B. They allow you to ignore red flags and instincts
C. They are easier to grade, rank, and compare fairly
D. They guarantee everyone in the group will agree
6. In the 5-step problem-solving process, what happens during Step 3 (Evaluate the alternatives)?
A. Negotiating delivery terms and handling purchase invoices
B. Assessing how many items need replacing and checking the budget
C. Weighing pros and cons against short- and long-term goals and cutting nonviable options
D. Committing to the final vendor without checking other choices
Critical Thinking & Problem-Solving Quiz (continued)
Page 2
Part 2: Concept Completion — Use the word bank to complete each item.
Word Bank: knowing yourself critical-thinking being skeptical skeptical compromise
7. Hank is figuring out which computer software is best for his company by examining each option objectively. He is using __________________________ skills, which require him to be __________________________ by avoiding preconceived notions.
8. To improve critical-thinking skills, work on __________________________, which can uncover your ingrained thought process and biases. Also work on __________________________, which involves asking questions and carefully examining evidence.
Part 3: Short Answer — Respond in complete sentences.
9. Explain why compromise is an important part of workplace problem-solving. Give a brief example.
10. You see a social media post claiming a new energy snack cures fatigue, with a "Buy Now" link. List two critical-thinking questions you should ask before trusting the claim.
11. Put the 5 steps of problem-solving in order from 1 to 5: Evaluate alternatives, Identify the problem, Implement the solution, Gather information, Make a choice.
Skill Check Quiz Key Teacher Answer Key Skill Check Quiz
Critical Thinking & Problem-Solving Quiz Key
Part 1: Multiple Choice — Answers & Rationales
1. Correct Answer: D. Determining the best solution after reviewing all options
Rationale: Critical thinking is an objective process of reviewing all possible solutions before making a decision.
2. Correct Answer: A. Problem-solving
Rationale: Problem-solving is an ongoing analytical process, whereas decision-making is an action within that process.
3. Correct Answer: B. Agreeing with a group or superior without examining the facts
Rationale: Critical thinking requires independence, skepticism, and checking biases rather than simply going along with a group or superior.
4. Correct Answer: A. Identifying red flags or missing information
Rationale: Step 3 of the objective decision-making approach is pausing after ranking/weighing criteria to check instincts for red flags or missing info.
5. Correct Answer: C. They are easier to grade, rank, and compare fairly
Rationale: Objective, measurable attributes let you use simple arithmetic to compare options consistently.
6. Correct Answer: C. Weighing pros and cons against short- and long-term goals and cutting nonviable options
Rationale: Step 3 evaluates alternatives for short- and long-term viability before selecting a final choice in Step 4.
Quiz Key (continued)
Page 2
Part 2: Concept Completion
7. Hank is using critical-thinking skills, which require him to be skeptical by avoiding preconceived notions.
8. To improve critical-thinking skills, work on knowing yourself, which can uncover your ingrained thought process and biases. Also work on being skeptical, which involves asking questions and carefully examining evidence.
Part 3: Short Answer — Sample Responses & Criteria
9. Importance of Compromise in Workplace Problem-Solving
Sample Answer: Workplace situations often involve multiple people, personalities, and stakeholders with different preferences. Compromise helps the team reach a workable solution that balances competing needs. (Example: Two departments want different software features, so they agree on a mid-tier plan that meets both teams' core needs within budget.)
10. Two Critical-Thinking Questions for a Social Media Claim
Look for any two of the following:
• What is the original source of the claim?
• Does the author/influencer have a vested financial interest (e.g., earning money from the "Buy Now" link)?
• Are the supporting sources or studies reliable and verifiable?
11. Correct Order of the 5 Problem-Solving Steps
1. Identify the problem → 2. Gather information → 3. Evaluate alternatives → 4. Make a choice → 5. Implement the solution