Fails the 3 steps • No revision made • Hurt feelings
⭐ Champion: Follows 3 Steps
1. Look at partner. 2. Say: “Okay, thanks for catching that.” 3. Stay calm and ask which line needs a transition.
Follows all 3 steps • Clear climax • Better writer
Class Question: How does saying “Okay” immediately stop an argument before it starts?
Case Study • Scenario 2
Collaboration
The Situation:
A teammate points to your poster and says: “Your math calculation on step 3 doesn’t match our team’s data table.”
❌ Traps: Complaining & Shutting Down
Cross arms, push the poster away, and pout: “Well you do it then! I’m done helping with this poster.”
Shuts down • Team project stalls • Calculation stays wrong
⭐ Champion: Follows 3 Steps
1. Look at teammate. 2. Say: “Okay, good eye.” 3. Stay calm and recalculate step 3 together.
Accurate data • Stronger team trust • Stress resolved
Key Reflection: Staying calm under feedback shows true leadership!
Personal Action Plan
Commitment
Which of the 3 traps is hardest for you to avoid when someone critiques you: Arguing, Complaining, or Shutting Down?
Share with your partner: “When I get feedback, I usually want to... but now I will...”
Whenever someone gives me feedback:
I will look at the person with calm eyes.
I will say “Okay” politely and without sarcasm.
I will stay calm (no arguing, complaining, or shutting down).
Great leaders don’t fear critique — they use it to level up!
Look • Say “Okay” • Stay Calm — That is how Feedback Masters grow!
Skill Framework Grades 2 – 5 Focus
Regulate the natural impulse to defend, argue, or shut down.
TRAPS: Arguing • Complaining • Shutting Down STEPS: Look • Say “Okay” • Stay Calm
Roleplay 3
Fishbowl Activity
Reviewer: “Your second paragraph gets confusing. You jump straight to the car ride without explaining who won the game, and you missed punctuation.”
Trap Response (Interrupt):
“You just read it wrong! That was a flashback! You always complain about my work!” → Arguing + Complaining
Master Response (3 Steps):
1. Look at partner • 2. “Okay. Thanks for catching that.” • 3. Stay calm and ask: “Where should I add the transition?”
Roleplay 4
Small Group Simulation
Teammate: “Wait, your math on step 3 doesn’t match our team data table. We can’t glue down the final poster until that is fixed.”
Trap Response (Shutting Down):
Pushes poster away, turns chair, looks down: “Fine. You do it then. I’m not doing math anymore.”
Master Response (3 Steps):
1. Look at teammate • 2. “Okay, good eye. Let me check.” • 3. Stay calm, grab scrap paper, recalculate together.
1. Looking: “Why does rolling your eyes immediately create defensiveness?”
2. Saying “Okay”: “How does saying ‘Okay’ protect you from blurting out excuses?”
3. Staying Calm: “What physical cue tells you you are starting to shut down?”
Teacher Observation & Mastery Rubric Record during natural classroom work
| Skill Step | Mastery | Needs Coaching (Trap Evident) |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Look at Person | Immediate eye contact; calm body facing speaker. | Eye-rolling, turning back, staring away. |
| 2. Say “Okay” | Clear, neutral acknowledgment (“Okay” / “Okay, thank you”). | Debate, sarcasm, muttering, or silent refusal. |
| 3. Stay Calm | Relaxed shoulders, regulated breath, applies fix. | Crossed arms, slumping, arguing, quitting. |
Weekly Goal: Catch students using the 3 steps during academic instruction and give immediate praise!
Page 2 of 2
