ECE Assessment Review Sheet
ECE Research Project Partner Evaluation Protocol
Assessment in ECE Peer Review
Aligned with the 60-Point Project Rubric • Mrs. Levy
Project Value
60 Total Pts
Author:
Reviewer:
Date:
Assessed Forms: Anecdotal Checklist Rating Scale Participation Chart Portfolio
Part 1 & 2: Detailed Rubric Criteria Check verify evidence for each requirement
| Project Section & Rubric Requirements | Status | Reviewer Verification & Suggestions |
|---|
| | |
| 1. Research & Form Descriptions 15 Pts | | |
- At least 2 distinct ECE assessment methods chosen
- Clear physical description: visual layout & structure
- Explains specifically how each is implemented in class
- Identifies exact data/developmental info collected
|
Strong Partial Missing
|
|
|
2. Observation Practice 15 Pts
- Mock observation completed for both selected forms
- Form applied correctly according to research rules
- Realistic, objective child behavior documented
- Clear context (case study, video clip, or role-play noted)
|
Strong Partial Missing
|
|
|
3. Analysis & Reflection Report 20 Pts
- Specific advantages analyzed for both assessment forms
- Key disadvantages & limitations thoroughly explained
- Defends which tool is most effective in ECE settings
- Conclusions fully supported by classroom observations
|
Strong Partial Missing
|
|
|
4. Presentation & Works Cited 10 Pts
- Follows Mrs. Levy's research paper template format (5 pts)
- Typed, professional voice, free of grammar/spelling errors
- Dedicated Works Cited page placed at the very end (5 pts)
- Includes at least 2 credible references properly formatted
|
Strong Partial Missing
|
|
Glow: Strongest Insight or Section
Where is the analysis most compelling or the mock observation most realistic?
Grow: Priority Revision for Mrs. Levy
What specific detail, rubric requirement, or citation needs attention?
Pre-flight: Template used 2 References listed Mock forms attached
Est. Score: / 60
Reviewer Sig: