Tea and Tyranny: Extended Investigation Page 1 of 3 Turn over for Part 2 →
Extended Historical Inquiry • Grade 8 History
Part 2 of 3
3
When the merchant ship Dartmouth arrived in Boston in late November 1773, followed soon by the Eleanor and Beaver, customs law triggered a strict 20-day countdown: cargo had to be cleared and duty paid by midnight on December 16, or royal customs officers would seize the vessels by force. Royal Governor Thomas Hutchinson refused to sign permission for the ships to turn back to England without paying duties.
On December 16, over 5,000 citizens from Boston and surrounding farming hamlets packed into the Old South Meeting House. When shipowner Francis Rotch returned at dusk to report the Governor’s final refusal to let the ships leave, Patriot leader Samuel Adams reportedly stood and announced: “This meeting can do nothing more to save the country!”
4
War whoops sounded outside the meetinghouse doors. An organized contingent of over 100 men marched to Griffin's Wharf in three groups. To disguise their identities from royal informants, they rubbed soot on their faces and wrapped themselves in blankets, adopting the disguise of Mohawk warriors—a symbolic gesture affirming they were free Americans, not submissive British subjects.
Under the watch of British warships anchored nearby, the men boarded the three ships in complete silence. In three hours, they hoisted 342 heavy cedar chests from the holds, chopped them open with tomahawks, and hurled over 90,000 pounds of tea into the saltwater. The raid was remarkably disciplined: no crew members were harmed, nothing was stolen, and the men swept the ship decks clean before disembarking. The financial damage was immense—nearly £9,659 (roughly $1.7 million in today's currency).
Patriot Triumph: John Adams
“This is the most magnificent Movement of all... This Destruction of the Tea is so bold, so daring, so firm, intrepid and inflexible... that I cannot but consider it as an Epoch in History.”
— Diary of John Adams, Dec. 17, 1773
Moderate Alarm: Benjamin Franklin
In London, Benjamin Franklin was shocked by the destruction of private property. He urged Massachusetts to immediately reimburse the East India Company, offering to pay for the tea out of his own funds to avert military retaliation.
— Historical Commentary & Letters
Historical Perspective Analysis (Page 2) Synthesize both viewpoints.
1. Why did the Sons of Liberty maintain strict discipline during the raid?
2. Contrast John Adams' reaction with Benjamin Franklin's reaction.
Tea and Tyranny: Extended Investigation Page 2 of 3 Turn over for Part 3 →
Extended Historical Inquiry • Grade 8 History
Part 3 of 3
In Britain, Parliament united in outrage. Former Prime Minister William Pitt called the action “criminal,” and King George III declared that Boston was in open insurrection. In the spring of 1774, Parliament passed five punitive statutes designed to isolate Massachusetts, crush its democratic traditions, and compel unconditional obedience.
1. Boston Port Act Closed Boston Harbor completely to commerce until the destroyed tea was paid for in full. Royal Navy warships blockaded the harbor, paralyzing the city's maritime economy.
2. Massachusetts Government Act Revoked the colonial charter of 1691. Banned unauthorized town meetings, made the governor's council appointive rather than elective, and replaced the civilian governor with General Thomas Gage.
3. Administration of Justice Act Permitted royal officials and soldiers accused of capital offenses to have their trials transferred to Great Britain, denying colonials the right to hold soldiers accountable before local juries.
4. Quartering Act of 1774 Authorized royal military commanders to requisition unoccupied private buildings, barns, and warehouses to billet British redcoats inside populated civilian centers.
The 5th Measure: The Quebec Act & The Backfire
Passed alongside the Coercive Acts, the Quebec Act expanded the borders of French Catholic Quebec southward to the Ohio River, blocking colonial land claims. Rather than trembling, the thirteen colonies felt a shared threat. George Washington noted, “The cause of Boston now is and ever will be the cause of America.” In September 1774, the First Continental Congress convened in Philadelphia, creating the Continental Association to enforce a total trade boycott and advising towns to mobilize local militias.
Historical Synthesis & Evaluation Support your thesis with concrete historical details.
1. Cause & Effect: Why did Parliament’s attempt to punish one colony backfire and produce unified intercolonial resistance?
2. Historical Debate: Was the destruction of the tea justified in defense of colonial rights, or did it constitute mob vandalism? Argue one side using evidence from the text.
Tea and Tyranny: Extended Investigation Page 3 of 3 Completed Resource • American History
“The cause of Boston is the cause of all America; we must send relief supplies and stand as one body.”
4
Parliament passes Tea Act to rescue East India Co.
Sons of Liberty dump 342 chests into harbor.
King George & Parliament enact Coercive Acts.
Colonies unite at First Continental Congress.
Tea and Tyranny • Formative Check Universal Objective Assessment Grade 8 Social Studies
