Flameless Heater Design Packet OpenSciEd 7.2 • Engineering Design
Thermal Energy Lab
Flameless Heater Design Packet
Name:
Date:
1
Define Problem
Criteria & constraints
2
Design & Model
Reactions & budget
3
Test & Analyze
Measure energy transfer
4
Improve & Reflect
Trade-offs & revisions
The Engineering Challenge
People in emergencies, remote areas, or outdoor expeditions often need a way to warm food or water without electricity, stoves, or open flames. Your team will use chemical reactions to design, test, and refine a portable flameless heater that safely transfers thermal energy to a sample of food or water.
Part 1: Defining the Problem
Phase 1
Before building, engineers define criteria (what a successful heater must do) and constraints (the limits on safety, cost, and materials). Complete the table below with your class targets.
Category
Target Goal or Limit
Why It Matters
Temperature Goal
Criterion
| | |
|
Safety
Constraint
| | |
|
Cost & Materials
Constraint
| | |
|
Size & Ease of Use
Criterion / Constraint
| | |
Priority Check: Which criterion or constraint will be hardest to meet, and why?
Phase 2 • Science & Modeling
Part 2: Chemical Reactions & Energy Transfer
How Flameless Heaters Work: When certain substances mix, a chemical reaction rearranges atoms to form new substances. In an exothermic reaction, energy is transferred from the reacting system to the surroundings (your food or water), raising its temperature.
Available Materials & Unit Costs
Material / Substance
Role in System
Unit Cost
Safety / Handling Note
Calcium chloride
Exothermic reactant
$0.15 / g
Irritant; wear goggles & wash hands
Water (room temp)
Reactant / activator
$0.00 / mL
Keep separate until activation
Aluminum foil
Heat-conducting barrier
$0.25 / sheet
Check for pinholes or tears
Resealable plastic bag
Reaction pouch / seal
$0.30 / bag
Seal tightly; monitor pressure
Foam cup or sleeve
Thermal insulator
$0.35 / cup
Reduces heat loss to air
Initial Heater System Model
Include: reactants, barrier/container, food/water, & energy arrows
Sketch how your heater will keep reactants separate from the food/water while allowing thermal energy to transfer efficiently.
Predicting Evidence: What observable signs will show that a chemical reaction is occurring inside your heater? (Think: temperature, gas, color, or new substances.)
Phase 2 • Blueprint & Budget
Part 3: Prototype 1 Design Plan
Bill of Materials & Cost
Budget Limit: $____________
Material / Reactant
Amount (g / mL)
Unit Cost
Subtotal
Purpose
Total Prototype 1 Cost:
Within budget? Y / N
Assembly & Activation Steps
Write clear, repeatable steps so another team could build and activate your heater safely.
1
2
3
4
Pre-Test Safety Check
Safety goggles on
Seal & leak check passed
Disposal plan ready
Biggest safety risk in our design & how we will prevent it:
Phase 3 • Test & Improve
Part 4: Testing Data & Redesign
Prototype 1 Test Log
Starting Temp: ______ °C • Target Temp: ______ °C
Time (min)
Water Temp (°C)
Temp Change (ΔT)
Observable Evidence of Reaction & Container Notes
0
1
2
3
4
5
What worked well? (Cite data)
What needs improvement? (Heat, safety, cost)
Prototype 2 Adjustments: What specific change(s) are you making and why?
Prototype 2 Test Log (Improved Design)
Updated Cost: $______ • Starting Temp: ______ °C
Time (min)
Water Temp (°C)
Temp Change (ΔT)
Observable Evidence of Reaction & Container Notes
0
1
2
3
4
5
Tip: Compare the maximum ΔT and safety performance of Prototype 1 vs. Prototype 2 before completing Part 5.
Phase 4 • Reflect & Justify
Part 5: Evidence, Trade-Offs & Final Design
1. Evidence of Chemical Reactions & Energy Transfer
Use your test data (ΔT and observations) to explain how you know a chemical reaction occurred and how thermal energy transferred to the water.
2. Evaluating Engineering Trade-Offs
Engineers rarely get everything they want without a compromise. Describe one trade-off your team made (for example: temperature vs. cost, speed vs. safety, or size vs. insulation) and why you chose that balance.
3. Revisions for a Final Design
If you had one more round of testing to finalize this product for real users, what specific revision would you make and what evidence supports that change?
Final Design Check
Met temperature goal Yes □ Partial □ No □
Stayed within budget Yes □ Partial □ No □
Safe & leak-free container Yes □ Partial □ No □
Revisions backed by data Yes □ Partial □ No □
Flameless Heater Teacher Rubric OpenSciEd 7.2 • Teacher Resource
Assessment Guide
Flameless Heater Teacher Rubric
Student / Team:
Total Score: / 20
Packet Component
4 • Exceeds
3 • Meets
2 • Developing
1 • Beginning
Part 1: Defining the Problem
Criteria & constraints
Score: ___ / 4
| Defines measurable criteria and constraints (temp, safety, cost, size) and clearly justifies why each matters and which is hardest to balance. | Identifies target goals/limits for all criteria and constraints and explains why most matter. | Lists criteria and constraints, but goals are vague or missing clear explanations of importance. | Table is incomplete or confuses criteria with constraints. |
|
Part 2: Reaction & Energy Model
System diagram & signs
Score: ___ / 4
| Model accurately labels reactants, barrier, food/water, and exothermic energy transfer arrows; predicts specific observable reaction evidence. | Model shows system parts and heat transfer direction; identifies at least two valid signs of a chemical reaction. | Model is missing key labels or energy arrows; reaction evidence prediction is general (e.g., “it gets hot”). | Model does not show how reactants are separated or how energy transfers. |
|
Part 3: Design, Budget & Safety
BOM & procedure
Score: ___ / 4
| Accurate budget within limit; clear, repeatable assembly steps; identifies a specific safety risk and a concrete prevention plan. | Budget math is accurate and within limit; steps are sequential; safety check and risk note are completed. | Minor budget errors or exceeds limit; steps lack detail for another team to follow; safety note is vague. | Missing cost calculations, incomplete procedure, or safety check not completed. |
|
Part 4: Testing & Redesign
Data logs & iteration
Score: ___ / 4
| Complete ΔT and reaction observations for both prototypes; Prototype 2 makes targeted, data-driven improvements. | Records temperatures and observations for both tests; identifies what worked and adjusts Prototype 2 logically. | Data logs have gaps or missing ΔT calculations; Prototype 2 changes are not clearly linked to Prototype 1 data. | Only one prototype tested or data logs are largely incomplete. |
|
Part 5: Evidence & Trade-Offs
Final reflection
Score: ___ / 4
| Cites specific ΔT and observation data to prove energy transfer; thoughtfully evaluates a real trade-off and proposes an evidence-backed final revision. | Connects test data to chemical reaction evidence; describes a clear trade-off and a reasonable final revision. | Claims are general with little specific data; trade-off or final revision lacks clear reasoning. | Reflections are incomplete or do not connect to chemical reactions or test data. |
Teacher Feedback & Next Steps NGSS Alignment: MS-PS1-6 • MS-ETS1-2 • MS-ETS1-3 • MS-ETS1-4
Flameless Heater Answer Key OpenSciEd 7.2 • Teacher Answer Key
Sample Exemplars
Flameless Heater Answer Key
Sample student responses and key look-fors. Exact numbers will vary based on class targets and test results.
Part 1 Defining the Problem (Sample Criteria & Constraints)
Category
Sample Target Goal / Limit
Why It Matters
Temperature Goal
Raise 50 mL water by at least +15°C in 5 min
Food/water must get noticeably warm quickly enough to use.
Safety
No leaks, no toxic fumes, temp < 65°C
Reactants cannot contaminate food or burn the user.
Cost & Materials
Total cost under $3.00 per heater
Keeps emergency/portable meal kits affordable.
Size & Ease of Use
Fits in one hand; activates in < 30 sec
Must be portable and simple to use outdoors.
Priority Check Sample: Meeting the temperature goal while staying under $3.00 is hardest because adding more calcium chloride produces more heat, but raises the cost quickly.
Part 2 Chemical Reactions & Energy Transfer (Look-Fors)
Initial System Model Must Include:
Reactants: Calcium chloride + water inside sealed bag.
Barrier: Aluminum foil separating reactants from food/water.
Insulation: Foam cup/sleeve around the outside.
Energy Arrows: Arrows pointing from the reaction pouch into the food/water.
Predicting Evidence (Sample):
We will observe a temperature increase on the thermometer, solid calcium chloride dissolving, and slight bubbling or steam/condensation inside the pouch, showing energy is being released to the surroundings.
Part 3 Prototype 1 Design Plan (Sample BOM & Safety)
Material
Amount
Subtotal
Purpose
Calcium chloride
10 g
$1.50
Exothermic reactant
Water (room temp)
30 mL
$0.00
Activates reaction
Aluminum foil + Plastic bag + Foam cup
1 each
$0.90
Conduction, seal, & insulation
Sample Total Cost:
$2.40
Within $3.00 budget (Y)
Safety Risk Sample: Calcium chloride solution could leak into the water or onto skin. Prevention: Double-check bag seal, wear goggles, and use a tear-free foil barrier.
Note: Accept any safe, repeatable 4-step procedure that keeps reactants separate from the water sample.
Teacher Answer Key • Page 2
Parts 4 & 5: Sample Data & Reflections
Part 4 Sample Testing Comparison (Prototype 1 vs. Prototype 2)
Prototype 1 Sample (10 g CaCl₂, $2.40)
0 min: 22°C → 5 min: 34°C (ΔT = +12°C)
Analysis: Safe and leak-free, but fell 3°C short of the +15°C goal. Some heat escaped through the top.
Prototype 2 Sample (12 g CaCl₂ + Lid, $2.70)
0 min: 22°C → 5 min: 41°C (ΔT = +19°C)
Adjustment: Added 2 g more CaCl₂ and wrapped foil tightly around the cup to speed conduction and trap heat.
Part 5 Exemplar Student Reflections
1. Evidence of Chemical Reactions & Energy Transfer (Exemplar)
In Prototype 2, the calcium chloride dissolved in water, produced slight fizzing/condensation, and raised the water temperature from 22°C to 41°C (ΔT = +19°C). This temperature increase is evidence that an exothermic chemical reaction occurred and transferred thermal energy from the reacting system through the aluminum foil into the water.
2. Evaluating Engineering Trade-Offs (Exemplar)
We had to balance heating performance vs. cost. Increasing calcium chloride from 10 g to 12 g raised our ΔT from +12°C to +19°C so we met the temperature goal, but it increased our unit cost from $2.40 to $2.70. We chose this balance because $2.70 still stayed under our $3.00 budget constraint.
3. Revisions for a Final Design (Exemplar)
For a final round, I would add a fitted foam lid over the top of the cup to reduce thermal energy escaping into the air. In Prototype 1 and 2, we noticed warm air rising from the open top; trapping that heat should keep the water warmer longer without adding expensive reactants.
Key Grading Look-For: Strong student responses explicitly connect particle/reaction evidence (dissolving, gas, temperature change) to energy transfer (system to surroundings) and cite specific ΔT or cost numbers from their own test logs.