Mass Data Detective Worksheet OpenSciEd 7.1 • Lesson 6 • Day 1
Mass Data Detective
Conservation of Matter
Name:
Date:
Investigation Focus: A class crushed a 15.0 g bath bomb and added it to 100.0 g of water inside two different setups: an open bottle (no cap) and a closed bottle (tightly capped). Use the mass data below to track where the matter went.
Part 1: Calculate the Change in Mass
Complete the table by calculating the Change in Mass (g) for each trial using \(\text{After} - \text{Before}\).
System Setup
Starting Mass (g)
Ending Mass (g)
Change in Mass (g)
Open Bottle — Trial 1
135.4 g
131.6 g
Open Bottle — Trial 2
135.8 g
131.9 g
Closed Bottle — Trial 1
138.2 g
138.2 g
Closed Bottle — Trial 2
138.5 g
138.4 g
Part 2: Quantitative Analysis
1. Calculate the average mass lost in the two Open Bottle trials. Show your work.
2. In Open Bottle Trial 1, what percentage of the 15.0 g bath bomb turned into gas that escaped? (Show your calculation.)
3. Why was the Closed Bottle's ending mass almost identical to its starting mass, even though bubbles still formed?
Mass Data Detective • Page 2 OpenSciEd 7.1 • Lesson 6
Part 3: Compare Mass Over Time
The table below shows the total mass of an open flask and a closed flask recorded every 30 seconds after dropping in a bath bomb.
Time (seconds)
0 s
30 s
60 s
90 s
120 s
Open Flask Mass (g)
150.0
148.2
146.9
146.3
146.3
Closed Flask Mass (g)
150.0
150.0
150.0
150.0
150.0
4. During which 30-second interval did the Open Flask lose mass the fastest? Calculate how many grams per second (g/s) it lost during that interval.
5. Between 90 s and 120 s, the Open Flask mass stayed at 146.3 g. What does this tell you about the reaction?
Part 4: Claim, Evidence & Reasoning
Question: Does matter disappear when a bath bomb fizzes in water? Write a complete scientific explanation using numerical evidence from your tables.
Claim (Answer the question clearly)
Evidence (Cite specific mass numbers from both open and closed systems)
Reasoning (Explain how gas & conservation of matter connect your evidence to your claim)
Mass Data Answer Key Teacher Resource • OpenSciEd 7.1 Lesson 6
Mass Data Answer Key
Day 1 Solutions
Part 1: Completed Mass Table
System Setup
Starting Mass
Ending Mass
Change in Mass (After − Before)
Open Bottle — Trial 1
135.4 g
131.6 g
−3.8 g (3.8 g lost)
Open Bottle — Trial 2
135.8 g
131.9 g
−3.9 g (3.9 g lost)
Closed Bottle — Trial 1
138.2 g
138.2 g
0.0 g
Closed Bottle — Trial 2
138.5 g
138.4 g
−0.1 g (within scale precision)
Part 2 & Part 3: Quantitative Analysis Solutions
1. Average mass lost (Open Bottle): \((3.8\text{ g} + 3.9\text{ g}) \div 2 = 3.85\text{ g}\).
2. Percentage of 15.0 g bath bomb that became escaped gas: \((3.8\text{ g} \div 15.0\text{ g}) \times 100\% \approx 25.3\%\).
3. Closed Bottle explanation: The cap trapped the gas (carbon dioxide) inside the bottle. Because gas particles have mass and could not escape into the room, the total mass stayed constant.
4. Fastest mass-loss interval & rate: From 0 s to 30 s , the open flask lost \(150.0 - 148.2 = 1.8\text{ g}\). Rate: \(1.8\text{ g} \div 30\text{ s} = 0.06\text{ g/s}\).
5. Plateau (90 s to 120 s): The mass stopped decreasing because the chemical reaction finished and no more gas was being produced or escaping.
Part 4: Sample CER Response
Claim: Matter does not disappear when a bath bomb fizzes in water; the total amount of matter stays conserved.
Evidence: In the open bottle trials, the mass decreased by an average of 3.85 g (and the open flask lost 3.7 g over 90 seconds). However, in the closed bottle trials, the mass stayed virtually constant (0.0 g change in Trial 1 and 150.0 g throughout the closed flask test).
Reasoning: When the bath bomb reacts with water, it produces a gas (carbon dioxide) that has mass. In an open container, those gas particles escape into the surrounding air, making the scale reading drop. In a closed container, the gas particles are trapped inside, proving that all the original matter is still present—just rearranged into new substances.
Particle Rearrangement Slides OpenSciEd 7.1 • Lesson 6 • Day 2
Where Do the New Particles Come From?
Connecting mass conservation and gas data to particle rearrangement in chemical reactions.
What Our Data Already Proved
1. Closed System Mass = Constant
150.0 g before the reaction equals 150.0 g after the reaction. No particles are created or destroyed.
2. A New Gas Formed
The trapped gas is denser than air (\(1.98\text{ g/L}\) vs. \(1.29\text{ g/L}\)) and extinguishes flames—it is carbon dioxide (\(\text{CO}_2\)).
How Chemical Reactions Make New Substances
In a chemical reaction, existing molecules break apart and their atoms rearrange into new combinations—forming substances with new properties.
Same Atoms
Every atom present at the start is still there at the end.
New Groups
Atoms bond in different arrangements to make new molecules.
Same Total Mass
Because atom counts do not change, total mass stays equal.
Zooming In: Baking Soda + Citric Acid
Before (Reactants)
• Baking Soda: \(\text{NaHCO}_3\) (solid)
• Citric Acid: \(\text{C}_6\text{H}_8\text{O}_7\) (solid)
• Water: \(\text{H}_2\text{O}\) (liquid medium)
After (Products)
• Carbon Dioxide: \(\text{CO}_2\) (gas bubbles!)
• Water: \(\text{H}_2\text{O}\) (liquid)
• Sodium Citrate: \(\text{Na}_3\text{C}_6\text{H}_5\text{O}_7\) (dissolved)
Math Check: Counting Atoms Before & After
Reaction: \(3\text{NaHCO}_3 + \text{C}_6\text{H}_8\text{O}_7 \rightarrow 3\text{CO}_2 + 3\text{H}_2\text{O} + \text{Na}_3\text{C}_6\text{H}_5\text{O}_7\)
Atom Type
Count Before (Reactants)
Count After (Products)
Conserved?
Sodium (Na)
3
3
Yes (3 = 3)
Carbon (C)
\(3 + 6 = 9\)
\(3 + 6 = 9\)
Yes (9 = 9)
Hydrogen (H)
\(3 + 8 = 11\)
\(6 + 5 = 11\)
Yes (11 = 11)
Oxygen (O)
\(9 + 7 = 16\)
\(6 + 3 + 7 = 16\)
Yes (16 = 16)
Turn & Talk
Explain the Mystery
If a closed jar starts with 200 atoms total before a reaction, how many atoms will be inside after the reaction? Why do the substances look and act differently?
Be ready to use the words atoms , rearrange , and mass in your answer.
Atom Accounting Exit Ticket OpenSciEd 7.1 • Lesson 6 • Day 2
Atom Accounting Exit Ticket
Particle Check
Name:
Date:
1. Atom Accounting Math
A sealed bag contains baking soda and vinegar . Count the atoms in the Reactants column, then predict the Products column using conservation of matter.
Atom Type
In Baking Soda
In Vinegar
Total Before
Total After
Carbon (C)
1
2
Hydrogen (H)
1
4
Oxygen (O)
3
2
Sodium (Na)
1
0
2. Draw a Particle Model (Closed System)
Draw 4 \(\bigcirc\) atoms and 4 \(\triangle\) atoms bonded in pairs before the reaction, then show how they could rearrange to form a new substance after the reaction.
Before Reaction (Reactants)
After Reaction (New Products)
3. Explain Conservation of Matter
Which statement best explains why a closed bottle keeps the exact same mass during a bath bomb reaction?
A. New atoms are created to replace the bath bomb atoms that dissolved.
B. The atoms rearrange into new gas and liquid molecules, and none can escape.
C. The water absorbs the mass of the gas bubbles so the scale cannot measure it.
D. Gas particles have zero mass as long as they stay inside a sealed bottle.
4. In your own words, explain how atom rearrangement creates a new substance without changing the total mass: