Text Analysis Monitoring Key
Aggressive Monitoring Teacher Diagnostic & Circulation Guide
Text Analysis Monitoring Key
Target: Clause Structure & Main Idea
Laps 1–3 Circulation • In-Class CFU
1 Lap 1: Warmup & Clauses
Check subject/predicate. Spot-check FANBOYS vs. subordinators in Sentences 1–7.
Goal: 100% on #1, 2, 4
2 Lap 2: Strategy Annotations
Verify circled key terms, bracketed 1st/last sentences, and written 1-sentence gist.
Stamp: Gist + 2 POEs
3 Lap 3: Main Idea & POE
Catch "too narrow" traps. Confirm 2 distractors crossed out before bubbling answer.
Check: Text line cited
Part 1: Sentence Classification Diagnostic (Sentences 1–7)
Simple = 1 Ind | Compound = 2 Ind + Coord | Complex = 1 Dep + 1 Ind
| # |
Sentence Prompt |
Type |
Clause Breakdown & Teacher Look-Fors |
Common Misconception |
| 1 |
The cat meowed loudly. |
Simple |
1 Ind Clause [S: The cat |
V: meowed]. "loudly" is an adverb. |
| 2 |
She wanted to go to the park, but it started raining. |
Compound |
2 Ind Clauses connected by comma + but (FANBOYS coordinating conj). |
Confusing comma with dependent clause. |
| 3 |
Because it was getting late, he decided to leave the party early. |
Complex |
Dep Clause ([Because] it was getting late) + Ind Clause. Subordinating conj: Because. |
Misidentifying "because" clause as independent. |
| 4 |
The sun rises in the east. |
Simple |
1 Ind Clause [S: The sun |
V: rises]. "in the east" is a prepositional phrase. |
| 5 |
Although she studied hard, she couldn't pass the exam. |
Complex |
Dep Clause ([Although] she studied hard) + Ind Clause. Subordinating conj: Although. |
Viewing "Although" as coordinating like "but". |
| 6* |
Push: I wanted to go shopping, so I saved some money. |
Compound |
2 Ind Clauses joined by comma + so (FANBOYS). Both clauses stand alone. |
Confusing "so" with subordinate "so that". |
| 7* |
Push: Birds fly. |
Simple |
1 Ind Clause. Minimal complete sentence: Subject (Birds) + Predicate/Verb (fly). |
Assuming sentence is "too short" or a fragment. |
▶ Lap 1 Turnaround Prompts
- #3 / #5 Complex Test: "Read clause 1 out loud: 'Because it was getting late.' Can it stand alone? No = Dependent clause = Complex!"
- #7 Sentence Trap: "What is the subject? (Birds) What is the verb? (fly) Complete thought? Yes = Simple sentence!"
- FANBOYS Rule: "For, And, Nor, But, Or, Yet, So join two independent sentences = Compound."
▶ Reading Strategy Look-Fors
- Step 1 (Circle): Words repeated ≥3 times (e.g., farming, plants, barriers).
- Step 2 (Bracket): First and last sentence of every paragraph marked with `[ ]`.
- Step 3 (Margin Gist): 3–6 word gist summary written alongside each paragraph.
- Step 4 (POE): Two slash marks `[X]` through eliminated choices before answering.
Text Analysis Monitoring Key • Page 1 of 3 Lap 1 Calibration: Clause Identification & Sentence Rules
Diagnostic Key Passages 1 & 2 • Question Rationale & POE Guide
Main Idea & Text-Dependent Analysis
Laps 2 & 3 Execution
Stamp Criteria: Text Evidence + POE
Passage 1
Understanding our Environment (Agricultural Revolution)
Exemplar Margin Gist: "Farming let populations explode & changed food/plants."
Text Evidence Look-Fors: Underline: "An area of land can support up to 500 times as many people" & "changed the food we eat." Look for circled term: "farming"
Q1: Main Idea KEY: A
"when societies changed to farming, they were able to grow and create better domesticated plants and vegetables"
✓ A: Synthesizes both paragraphs (transition to farming + food/plant domestication).
✗ B: Subjective value judgment ("better"); unscientific.
✗ C: Factually contradicts text (farming supports 500x more per area).
✗ D: Overgeneralizes ("better for society"); ignores paragraph 2 (crops).
Lap 3 Stamp Check: Prompt students to check if their answer addresses both paragraphs, not just paragraph 1.
Q2: Why Farming Supports Big Pop. KEY: C
"because farming can produce more food in less space"
✗ A: Not stated anywhere in text; farming was arduous labor.
✗ B: Irrelevant distractor; economics/expense not mentioned.
✓ C: Matches direct line: "support up to 500 times as many people... in smaller areas."
✗ D: Direct opposite of the text (farming concentrates people in smaller areas).
Quick Unstick Prompt: "Go to sentence 4 of paragraph 1. What number do you see? What does that number prove?"
Passage 2
Congress Under the Articles of Confederation
Exemplar Margin Gist: "Distance & slow mail made governing huge nation hard."
Text Evidence Look-Fors: Underline: "several barriers to governing", "distance between each state", "letters... could take weeks." Look for circled terms: "barriers", "distance"
Q1: Main Idea KEY: A
"There were several barriers that made it difficult to govern under the Articles of Confederation"
✓ A: Umbrella sentence from paragraph 1 that covers both travel distance (para 2) and communication (para 3).
✗ B: Too narrow: only covers paragraph 3 (ignores travel barriers).
✗ C: Factually unsupported: passage never mentions a capital city.
✗ D: Irrelevant opinion: text calls horseback travel "arduous," not best.
Error Code 'N' (Too Narrow): If student picks B, ask: "Does B explain paragraph 2 about physical travel?"
Q2: Distance Impact on Congress KEY: C
"due to the long distances, Congressmen had a hard time communicating and traveling to the meeting locations"
✗ A: Distractor: capital location is never mentioned in text.
✗ B: False detail: text also lists carriage and foot travel.
✓ C: Directly combines the travel time (weeks/months) with the communication breakdown from distance.
✗ D: Incomplete: leaves out the physical travel barrier to meetings.
Key Line in Text: Paragraph 2, final sentence: "so Congress only met once or twice per year as a result."
Text Analysis Monitoring Key • Page 2 of 3 Laps 2 & 3 Focus: Distractor Elimination (POE) & Umbrella vs. Narrow Ideas
Roster & Push Analysis Passage 3 • Aggressive Monitoring Clipboard Tracker
Treaty of Paris & Student Observation Tracker
Show Call & Stamp Ready
Clipboard-Mounted Guide
Passage 3
The End of the American Revolution (Treaty of Paris, 1783)
Margin Gist: "Treaty ended war, made US independent, set Mississippi border."
Q1: Main Idea KEY: A
"the Treaty of Paris ended the American Revolution and settle the borders of the US territory"
✓ A: Captures dual core outcomes: ending war + setting Western border.
✗ B: Too broad; war duration is background context, not main idea of treaty.
✗ C: Factual error; treaty signed with Britain, not Canada.
✗ D: Factional contradiction; marked the end, not beginning.
Push Q2: Event Marking War End KEY: C
"The Treaty of Paris"
✗ A: Confederation: The government framework, not the ending peace treaty.
✗ B: Shays' Rebellion: 1786–87 domestic uprising, post-war economic conflict.
✓ C: Explicit text: "The Treaty of Paris officially ended the American Revolution."
✗ D: Lexington: 1775 opening shots ("shot heard 'round the world"); opposite pole.
Real-Time Student Circulation Tracker (Active Monitoring Clipboard Sheet)
✓ = Exemplar · = Minor Re-read N = Too Narrow F = Clause Trap
| Student Name |
Lap 1 (1–7) |
P1: Q1/Q2 |
P2: Q1/Q2 |
P3: Q1/Q2 |
Annotations |
Immediate Action / Push Cue |
Show Call |
| 1. |
___ / 7 |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
Gist / POE |
__________________________________________ |
|
| 2. |
___ / 7 |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
Gist / POE |
__________________________________________ |
|
| 3. |
___ / 7 |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
Gist / POE |
__________________________________________ |
|
| 4. |
___ / 7 |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
Gist / POE |
__________________________________________ |
|
| 5. |
___ / 7 |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
Gist / POE |
__________________________________________ |
|
| 6. |
___ / 7 |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
Gist / POE |
__________________________________________ |
|
| 7. |
___ / 7 |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
Gist / POE |
__________________________________________ |
|
| 8. |
___ / 7 |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
[ A ] [ C ] |
Gist / POE |
__________________________________________ |
|
Show Call Candidate 1 (Grammar)
Project a student who successfully bracketed clauses in #3 and labeled "Because" as a subordinator vs. #2 with FANBOYS "but".
Show Call Candidate 2 (Main Idea POE)
Project a student who explicitly wrote "Too Narrow - only covers mail" next to Option B on Passage 2 (AoC) Q1 before bubbling Option A.
Text Analysis Monitoring Key • Page 3 of 3 Synthesis: Aggressive Monitoring Pathway & Whole-Group Debrief