Prompt Detective Slides Day 1 of 4 7th Grade Expository Writing
Prompt Detective Lab
Unpacking Expository Prompts & Building Your Point with the PEEL Blueprint
Analyze the Prompt
Annotate the Text
Draft Your Point
Today's Mission
What Is an ECR & the PEEL Blueprint?
Extended Constructed Response (ECR): A well-organized essay response that answers a prompt using evidence and analysis from an expository text.
P
Point
Your clear, direct answer to the prompt.
E
Evidence
Facts or quotes from the text that prove it.
E
Explanation
Your own words showing how the evidence works.
L
Link
Connects back to your Point and wraps up.
Step 1: Prompt Analysis
Use the DO – WHAT Strategy
DO (Action Verbs)
Circle the command verbs telling you how to write.
Examples: Explain, Analyze, Describe, Compare, Trace
WHAT (Key Topic)
Underline the exact topic or question you must answer.
Ask: "What specific idea from the passage is it asking about?"
Watch Out: Never start reading the passage until you know what you are hunting for!
Step 2: Active Reading
Annotate Your Expository Text
★
Star Central Ideas
Mark the main point of each section or paragraph in the margin.
E
Bracket Evidence
Put [brackets] around facts, data, or examples that answer the prompt.
?
Note Connections
Jot a 3–5 word margin note explaining why a detail matters.
Apply these 3 marks as you read today's teacher-provided expository passage.
Step 3: Building "P" in PEEL
Anatomy of a Strong Point
Formula: Restate Prompt + Direct Answer + Because/How
A strong Point is clear, specific, and provable using facts from the text—never just "I think" or "Yes, it does."
Too Vague (Needs Work)
"The article talks about how sleep is important for middle schoolers."
Blueprint-Ready Point
"Adequate sleep is essential for adolescents because it strengthens memory retention and regulates daily mood."
Lab Work Time
Your Day 1 Checklist
1
Copy today's prompt onto your worksheet and complete the DO – WHAT chart.
2
Read and annotate the expository passage using ★, [ ], and margin notes.
3
Draft your Point (P) statement and test it with a partner.
Keep your annotated passage safe—you will mine it for Evidence tomorrow!
Prompt Detective Worksheet Day 1 • PEEL Power Builders
Prompt Detective & Annotation Log
Name: _______________________ Date: ____________
STEP 1 Copy & Dissect the ECR Prompt
Write the prompt for today's expository passage. Circle the DO (action verbs) and underline WHAT you must explain.
DO (Action Verbs)
WHAT (Topic & Focus)
STEP 2 Expository Passage Annotation Log
As you read the teacher-provided passage, record the central idea and key details you marked with ★ and [brackets].
Passage Title: ______________________________________________________________________
Section / Para #
Key Idea or Fact Found
How It Connects to the Prompt
Tip: Look for cause-and-effect, problem-solution, or comparison clues in expository text. Page 1 of 2
Day 1 • Building the "P" in PEEL
Point (Thesis) Drafting Lab
Name: _______________________
The Point Blueprint Formula
Restate the Prompt + Clear Answer + Main Reason(s)
Avoid "I think," "In my opinion," or "This essay will be about."
Draft 1: Working Point Statement
Write your first attempt at a clear, one-to-two sentence Point that directly answers the prompt.
Point Quality Check (Check each box before revising)
Directly answers the prompt's WHAT
Uses formal, third-person tone
Can be proven with text evidence
Specific (not vague or too broad)
Partner Glow & Grow
Trade papers. Write one strength (Glow) and one suggestion to make your partner's Point sharper (Grow).
Glow:
Grow:
Final Locked-In Point (P)
Revise your Point based on your check and partner feedback.
Save this sheet—you will transfer your Point to your PEEL Blueprint on Day 3. Page 2 of 2
Day 1 Teacher Guide 4-Day Expository ECR Unit • 7th Grade ELA
Day 1: Prompt Detective Lab — Teacher Guide
40–45 Min
4-Day PEEL Sequence Overview
Day 1: Prompt & Point (P)
Day 2: Evidence Hunt (E)
Day 3: Explain, Link & Draft
Day 4: Peer Review & Polish
Teacher Prep
Print/share your chosen expository passage and ECR prompt.
Copy Prompt Detective Worksheet (2 pages).
Queue Prompt Detective Slides .
Learning Objective
Students will dissect an expository ECR prompt using DO-WHAT, annotate a teacher-provided text, and draft a defensible Point (thesis) statement.
Day 1 Instructional Pacing (40-Min Core + 5-Min Flex)
Time
Phase
Teacher Moves & Key Prompts
0–6 min
Hook & PEEL Intro
Slides 1–2
Introduce the 4-day goal: building a rock-solid ECR using PEEL. Briefly preview each letter so students see how today's Point anchors the whole essay.
6–14 min
DO–WHAT Modeling
Slide 3 • Step 1
Display your ECR prompt. Think aloud as you circle action verbs (DO) and underline the focus (WHAT). Have students record this on Page 1.
14–27 min
Guided Annotation
Slide 4 • Step 2
Model annotating paragraph 1 of your expository text (★ central idea, [ ] evidence, ? connection). Students finish reading & logging 3 key details.
27–40 min
(+5 flex)
Drafting the Point
Slides 5–6 • Page 2
Review the Point formula. Students write Draft 1, run the 4-box self-check, and complete Partner Glow & Grow before locking in their Final Point.
Watch-For Misconception
Students often summarize the whole article instead of answering the prompt. Redirect with: "Does your Point directly answer the WHAT?"
Differentiation
Support: Provide a sentence frame: "In [Title], [topic] impacts ___ by ___."
Extend: Challenge students to include two distinct reasons in their Point.
Check for Understanding: Collect or spot-check students' Final Locked-In Point before Day 2. Day 1 Teacher Guide
Skyscraper Farms Passage Expository Anchor Text • 7th Grade ELA
Skyscraper Farms: Growing Up Instead of Out
Name: _______________________ Date: ____________
Extended Constructed Response (ECR) Prompt
Explain how vertical farming solves key challenges of traditional agriculture and why it is becoming an important part of future food production. Write a well-organized response using specific evidence from the passage to support your explanation.
Expository Passage
Annotation Margin (★ [ ] ?)
[1] For thousands of years, human civilizations have relied on flat, open fields to grow food. However, feeding a growing global population on limited farmland has become increasingly difficult. According to the United Nations, the world will need to produce nearly 70 percent more food by 2050, even as droughts, urban expansion, and soil erosion shrink the amount of healthy land available for crops. In response to this challenge, agricultural engineers are looking skyward by designing vertical farms—indoor facilities where crops grow in stacked layers inside warehouses, shipping containers, or multi-story city buildings.
[2] One of the most dramatic advantages of vertical farming is how little water it requires. Traditional outdoor farms lose massive amounts of water to evaporation and runoff into nearby soil. By contrast, vertical farms use closed-loop systems such as hydroponics, in which plant roots rest in nutrient-rich water, or aeroponics, which mists roots with water and minerals. Because unused water is captured, filtered, and recirculated, vertical farms use up to 95 percent less water than conventional field farming to grow the same amount of leafy greens.
Annotation Key: ★ = Central Idea | [ ] = Strong Evidence | ? = Margin Note Page 1 of 2
Expository Anchor Text • Continued
Skyscraper Farms: Growing Up Instead of Out
Name: _______________________
Expository Passage (Continued)
Annotation Margin (★ [ ] ?)
[3] Indoor farming also protects harvests from unpredictable weather and destructive pests. Outdoor farmers risk losing an entire season's income to a single late frost, hailstorm, or insect outbreak. Inside a vertical farm, computers precisely control temperature, humidity, and LED light wavelengths every hour of the day. Because sealed indoor rooms keep insects and plant diseases out, growers do not need to spray chemical pesticides, and they can harvest fresh produce 365 days a year regardless of blizzards or heat waves outside.
[4] Placing farms directly inside cities also shrinks the distance food must travel from harvest to dinner plate. In the United States, fresh produce travels an average of 1,500 miles in refrigerated trucks before reaching grocery shelves, burning fossil fuels and causing nutrients to fade along the way. Vertical farms located in urban neighborhoods can deliver crisp lettuce, herbs, and berries to local stores within hours of picking, cutting transportation emissions while giving communities fresher, longer-lasting food.
[5] Still, vertical farming is not a complete replacement for traditional agriculture. Running thousands of grow lights and climate-control fans demands significant electricity, which makes indoor produce more expensive to grow—especially calorie-heavy staple crops like wheat, corn, and rice. Even with these energy hurdles, engineers are pairing indoor farms with solar panels and smarter LEDs to lower costs. As cities continue to grow, vertical farms offer a practical, water-saving partner to outdoor farms that helps build a more reliable food supply.
Key Academic Vocabulary
Soil erosion: the wearing away of topsoil by wind or water.
Hydroponics: growing plants in nutrient-rich water instead of soil.
Conventional: traditional or standard practice.
Emissions: gases released into the air, such as truck exhaust.
Keep this annotated passage for Days 1–4 as you build and revise your PEEL ECR. Page 2 of 2
Evidence Hunters Slides Day 2 of 4 7th Grade Expository Writing
Evidence Hunters
Finding, Testing & Embedding Evidence from Expository Text
Hunt for Proof
Test Relevance
Weave & Cite
Building "E" in PEEL
What Makes Expository Evidence Strong?
1. Directly Proves
It backs up your exact Point—not just a random fun fact from the article.
2. Concrete & Specific
Includes data, expert findings, real examples, or clear cause-and-effect details.
3. Trimmed & Focused
Uses only the sharpest 1–2 sentences or phrases—never a giant block copy.
Goal: Gather 2–3 strong pieces of evidence from your teacher-provided passage.
The Relevance Test
Strong Proof vs. Weak Filler
Sample Point: Urban trees cool down city neighborhoods and improve air quality.
Weak Evidence (Off-Target)
"Many city parks have oak and maple trees planted along walking trails."
Why it fails: Names tree types, but does not prove cooling or air quality.
Strong Evidence (On-Target)
"Shaded streets can measure up to 11 degrees cooler than treeless pavement, while leaves filter airborne pollutants."
Why it works: Gives measurable proof of both cooling and cleaner air.
Two Ways to Cite
Direct Quote vs. Paraphrase
Direct Quote
Copy the author's exact words inside "quotation marks."
Best when: The author's exact phrasing, statistic, or expert quote packs a punch.
Paraphrase
Put a specific fact or example into your own words.
Best when: You want to condense a long explanation into a crisp, clear detail.
Both require you to credit the text or paragraph!
Smooth Integration
Never Drop a "Quote Bomb"
Quote Bomb: Dropping a full quote into a paragraph with zero introduction. Always attach a lead-in stem!
Expository Lead-In Stems
• According to the passage, "..."
• In paragraph ___, the author notes that...
• Research highlighted in the text shows...
• For example, the article explains that...
Weave It Together:
According to paragraph 3, "shaded streets can measure up to 11 degrees cooler than treeless pavement."
Lab Work Time
Your Day 2 Checklist
1
Re-read your Final Point from Day 1 so you know what you must prove.
2
Mine the expository text for 3 candidate details and log them in your Evidence Vault.
3
Select your top 2 pieces of evidence and write smooth lead-in sentences.
Tomorrow we fire up the Explanation & Drafting Studio to build your full ECR!
Evidence Vault Worksheet Day 2 • PEEL Power Builders
The Evidence Vault
Name: _______________________ Date: ____________
My Locked-In Point (copy from Day 1 so your hunt stays on target):
STEP 1 Hunt for 3 Candidate Pieces of Evidence
Find 3 quotes or specific facts from the teacher-provided expository passage. Then rate how strongly each one proves your Point.
EVIDENCE #1 • Paragraph #: ______ Strength Rating: [ ] Strong [ ] Okay [ ] Weak
Why does it prove my Point? ____________________________________________________________________
EVIDENCE #2 • Paragraph #: ______ Strength Rating: [ ] Strong [ ] Okay [ ] Weak
Why does it prove my Point? ____________________________________________________________________
EVIDENCE #3 • Paragraph #: ______ Strength Rating: [ ] Strong [ ] Okay [ ] Weak
Why does it prove my Point? ____________________________________________________________________
Tip: If a quote is longer than 2 sentences, trim it to the sharpest words. Page 1 of 2
Day 2 • Building the First "E" in PEEL
Quote-Weaving Practice
Name: _______________________
Lead-In Stem Bank (No Quote Bombs!)
• According to the text, "..."
• In paragraph ___, the author explains...
• Research in the article shows that...
• For instance, the passage states, "..."
Top Evidence #1 (Embedded with Lead-In)
Mode: [ ] Direct Quote [ ] Paraphrase
Combine a lead-in stem with your strongest piece of evidence. Check quotation marks and paragraph citation.
Top Evidence #2 (Embedded with Lead-In)
Mode: [ ] Direct Quote [ ] Paraphrase
Choose your second strongest detail from the Evidence Vault and weave it smoothly into a complete sentence.
Evidence Hunter Final Check
Both details directly prove my Point
Zero dropped "quote bombs"
Exact words are in quotation marks
Paragraph or source is cited
Keep this sheet with Day 1's work for tomorrow's Explanation Engine! Page 2 of 2
Day 2 Teacher Guide 4-Day Expository ECR Unit • 7th Grade ELA
Day 2: Evidence Hunters — Teacher Guide
40–45 Min
Teacher Prep
Students need their annotated expository passage and Day 1 Point.
Copy Evidence Vault Worksheet (2 pages).
Queue Evidence Hunters Slides .
Learning Objective
Students will evaluate textual details for relevance and embed 2 strong pieces of expository evidence using lead-in stems.
Day 2 Instructional Pacing (40-Min Core + 5-Min Flex)
Time
Phase
Teacher Moves & Key Prompts
0–8 min
Strong vs. Weak
Slides 1–3
Review the 3 criteria for strong expository evidence. Walk through the urban trees example and ask students why the weak quote fails the Relevance Test.
8–21 min
Evidence Vault Hunt
Worksheet Page 1
Students copy their Day 1 Point, then mine the teacher-provided text for 3 candidate details. Require them to rate each detail and justify its connection.
21–28 min
Quote-Weaving Mini-Lesson
Slides 4–5
Model turning a raw quote from your passage into an embedded sentence using a lead-in stem. Contrast direct quoting vs. paraphrasing.
28–40 min
(+5 flex)
Weave & Cite
Slide 6 • Page 2
Students select their top 2 details and write embedded evidence sentences on Page 2, then run the 4-box Evidence Hunter Final Check.
Watch-For Misconceptions
Quote-Bombing: Starting a sentence with quotation marks and no lead-in.
Over-Quoting: Copying 4–5 lines when 1 sharp phrase works better.
Differentiation
Support: Pre-highlight 2–3 key paragraphs in the passage for students to search.
Extend: Require 1 direct quote and 1 paraphrase to build stylistic variety.
Exit Check: Spot-check Top Evidence #1 on Page 2 for a lead-in stem and direct link to the Point. Day 2 Teacher Guide
Explain and Draft Slides Day 3 of 4 7th Grade Expository Writing
Explain & Draft Studio
Turning Evidence into Explanation, Adding a Link & Drafting Your Full ECR
Analyze, Don't Summarize
Bridge Back to Point
Draft Flowing Paragraphs
Building the Second "E" in PEEL
Summary vs. Explanation
Summary (Weak)
Just repeats what the quote already said in slightly different words.
"This quote shows that shaded streets are 11 degrees cooler than pavement."
Explanation (Strong)
Unpacks how and why the evidence proves your Point.
"By blocking direct sunlight, tree canopies prevent asphalt from trapping heat, which lowers neighborhood temperatures and reduces dangerous heat waves."
Analysis Strategy
Run Evidence Through the Engine
1. SAY
Your embedded quote or fact from the expository text.
(Day 2 Evidence)
2. MEAN
What does this fact actually show about cause, effect, or impact?
"This demonstrates that..."
3. MATTER
Why is this important to your overall Point and the prompt?
"As a result, ..."
Rule of Thumb: Write at least 2 sentences of Explanation for every 1 piece of Evidence!
Writer's Toolkit
Power Stems for Explanation
To Unpack Meaning
• This evidence reveals that...
• In other words, this process causes...
• Because of this, ...
To Show Why It Matters
• This is significant because...
• Consequently, [topic] leads to...
• Without this factor, ...
Avoid repeating "This quote proves my point"—show the logic instead!
Building "L" in PEEL
Lock It In with a Strong Link
The Link (L) is your closing sentence that ties your Evidence and Explanation back to your original Point—without sounding repetitive.
Link Sentence Starters
• Ultimately, ...
• Therefore, it is clear that...
• Through [reason 1] and [reason 2], ...
Example Link:
"Ultimately, expanding urban tree canopies is a practical, measurable way for cities to protect residents from extreme heat and pollution."
Drafting Studio
From PEEL Parts to Flowing Paragraphs
1. Intro + Point
Name the passage title, give 1 sentence of context, and end with your Point.
2. Body Paragraphs
Open with a transition, weave Evidence, and write 2+ sentences of Explanation.
3. Link & Formal Tone
Close with your Link. Use 3rd-person academic voice—no "I think" or "you."
Transition Toolkit: First, Furthermore, In addition, Consequently, As a result, Ultimately
Silent Drafting Studio
Your Day 3 Checklist
1
Keep your Day 1 Point and Day 2 Evidence Vault open beside your Drafting Pages.
2
Draft your full ECR with 2+ Explanation sentences per quote and a strong Link.
3
Check off the PEEL Tracker and whisper-read your draft to catch missing words.
Tomorrow on Day 4, we Polish and Publish with Peer Review and our PEEL Rubric!
ECR Drafting Pages Day 3 • PEEL Power Builders
ECR Drafting Studio
Name: _______________________ Date: ____________
PEEL Tracker
P: Intro + Point
E1: Embedded
E1: 2+ Explain
E2: Embedded
E2: 2+ Explain
L: Link
Transitions
Adding:
Furthermore, In addition, Additionally
Cause/Effect:
Consequently, As a result, Therefore
Contrast:
However, In contrast
Closing:
Ultimately, Overall
Tone Check
No "I think," "you," or casual slang. Indent every new paragraph!
Continue onto Page 2 if you need more drafting space. Page 1 of 2
Day 3 • PEEL Power Builders
ECR Drafting Studio (Continued)
Name: _______________________
Bring your completed draft to Day 4 for Peer Review and Polishing! Page 2 of 2
Skyscraper Farms Mentor ECR Annotated Exemplar • 4/4 Master Builder
Mentor ECR: Skyscraper Farms
Teacher & Student Model
P = Point E = Evidence E = Explanation L = Link Underlined = Transitions
In the expository passage "Skyscraper Farms: Growing Up Instead of Out," the author examines how modern indoor agriculture responds to shrinking farmland and rising global food demand. [P] Vertical farming solves major challenges of traditional agriculture by conserving massive amounts of water and protecting crops from unpredictable weather, making it an essential partner for feeding growing cities.
First, vertical farms dramatically reduce water waste compared to conventional outdoor fields. [E1] According to paragraph 2, closed-loop systems such as hydroponics and aeroponics capture and recirculate unused moisture so that "vertical farms use up to 95 percent less water than conventional field farming to grow the same amount of leafy greens." [Explanation 1] This evidence reveals that indoor farming eliminates the evaporation and soil runoff that drain outdoor farms. Consequently, communities facing severe droughts can still produce fresh vegetables without exhausting local water supplies.
Furthermore, indoor facilities shield harvests from climate extremes and pests that regularly destroy outdoor crops. [E2] As the author notes in paragraph 3, computer-controlled rooms regulate light and temperature so growers can avoid chemical pesticides and "harvest fresh produce 365 days a year regardless of blizzards or heat waves outside." [Explanation 2] Because weather disasters cannot wipe out an indoor harvest, food production becomes far more reliable and predictable. In addition, placing these farms inside cities cuts the 1,500-mile truck trips described in paragraph 4, delivering fresher food with fewer emissions.
[L] Ultimately, although high electricity costs prevent vertical farms from replacing staple grain fields, their water-saving technology and year-round reliability make them a vital solution for future urban food production.
Why This Mentor ECR Scores 4/4
Point: Answers both parts of the prompt ("how it solves challenges" + "why it matters") in a formal third-person thesis.
Evidence: Smoothly embeds specific data (95% less water, 365 days, 1,500 miles) with paragraph citations and zero quote bombs.
Explanation: Goes beyond summary by explaining how closed-loop systems help drought areas and why year-round harvests matter.
Link & Craft: Uses purposeful transitions (First, Consequently, Furthermore, Ultimately ) and acknowledges paragraph 5's nuance.
Use on Day 3 for modeling paragraph flow or Day 4 for rubric calibration. Mentor ECR Exemplar
Day 3 Teacher Guide 4-Day Expository ECR Unit • 7th Grade ELA
Day 3: Explain & Draft Studio — Teacher Guide
40–45 Min
Teacher Prep
Students need Day 1 Point & Day 2 Evidence Vault.
Copy ECR Drafting Pages (2 pages) & display/share Mentor ECR .
Queue Explain and Draft Slides .
Learning Objective
Students will write analytical Explanation (Say–Mean–Matter) and a cohesive Link, drafting a complete, well-transitioned expository ECR.
Day 3 Instructional Pacing (40-Min Core + 5-Min Flex)
Time
Phase
Teacher Moves & Key Prompts
0–8 min
Summary vs. Analysis
Slides 1–4
Contrast the Summary example with Explanation. Introduce the Say–Mean–Matter engine and the 2:1 Explanation-to-Evidence ratio.
8–14 min
Link & Mentor Model
Slides 5–6 • Mentor ECR
Model how a Link echoes the Point ("Ultimately..."). Briefly walk through the color-coded Mentor ECR to show transitions and formal 3rd-person tone.
14–36 min
(+5 flex)
Silent Drafting Studio
Slide 7 • Drafting Pages
Students draft their full ECR directly from their Day 1 Point and Day 2 Evidence Vault, adding 2+ Explanation sentences per quote and checking off the PEEL Tracker.
36–40 min
Whisper Read-Back
Closure
Students whisper-read their draft to catch missing words and underline 3 transitions before storing drafts for Day 4 Peer Review.
1-Minute Conference Prompts
"If I didn't read the article, what would I still need explained here?"
"How does this detail prove the 'because' part of your Point?"
Differentiation
Support: Provide an intro starter ("In '[Title],' the author examines..." ) and have students highlight the key noun in their quote to explain.
Extend: Split E1 and E2 into two distinct, well-developed body paragraphs.
Check for Understanding: Verify every student has a completed rough draft ready for Day 4 Peer Review. Day 3 Teacher Guide
Polish and Publish Slides Day 4 of 4 7th Grade Expository Writing
Polish and Publish
Peer Review, Rubric Inspection & Finalizing Your PEEL ECR
Peer Inspect
Score with Rubric
Revise & Submit
Final Inspection
Two Passes: Revise First, Edit Second
1. Revise (Big Ideas)
• Is the Point sharp and on-prompt?
• Is Evidence embedded (no quote bombs)?
• Does Explanation analyze, not summarize?
• Does the Link wrap up smoothly?
2. Edit (CUPS)
• Capitalization (titles, starts of sentences)
• Usage (formal tone, verb tense)
• Punctuation (quotation marks & commas)
• Spelling (key terms from the passage)
Partner Protocol
Color-Code & Score with Care
P
Underline your partner's Point.
E
Put [brackets] around their Evidence.
E
Star ★ their strongest Explanation.
L
Circle their closing Link.
If you cannot find a part to mark, tell your partner kindly so they can add it before turning in!
Rubric Target
Aiming for "Master Builder" (4/4)
Clear Focus & Structure
Point directly answers the prompt; paragraphs flow smoothly with purposeful transitions.
Strong Textual Evidence
At least 2 specific, relevant details from the passage, smoothly embedded and cited.
Insightful Explanation
Deeply unpacks how/why the evidence proves the Point—never just repeating the quote.
Conventions & Tone
Formal third-person voice with accurate punctuation, quotation marks, and spelling.
Upgrade Your Draft
Quick Fixes Based on Your Score
Spotted a Quote Bomb?
Insert a lead-in stem like "According to paragraph 2," right before the quotation marks.
Explanation Too Short?
Add a sentence starting with "This is significant because..." to show why it matters.
Choppy Transitions?
Add "Furthermore," "Consequently," or "Ultimately" at paragraph seams.
Final Step
Your Day 4 Checklist
1
Complete Peer Review and score the draft on the 4-point PEEL Rubric.
2
Make at least 2 targeted revisions and edit for CUPS.
3
Complete your Final Reflection Exit Ticket and submit your ECR!
Congratulations—you built a complete expository ECR from blueprint to publish!
PEEL Rubric and Review Day 4 • PEEL Power Builders
7th-Grade PEEL ECR Rubric & Peer Review
Author: _________________ Reviewer: _________________
Step 1 (Mark the Draft): Underline P [Bracket] E vidence Star ★ E xplanation Circle L ink
PEEL Element
4 — Master Builder
3 — Solid Frame
2 — Developing
1 — Needs Blueprint
P — Point
Score: ___/4
Sharp, specific claim that directly answers the prompt in formal tone.
Clear claim that answers the prompt; minor wording polish needed.
Vague or partial answer; may use "I think."
Missing Point or off-topic from the prompt.
E — Evidence
Score: ___/4
2+ specific, relevant details smoothly embedded with stems & citations.
2 relevant details included; minor lead-in or citation gaps.
Only 1 detail, weak relevance, or dropped quote bomb.
No accurate textual evidence from the passage.
E — Explanation
Score: ___/4
Deeply analyzes how/why evidence proves the Point (2+ sentences each).
Explains connection clearly, though one part leans toward summary.
Mostly summarizes or repeats the quote without analysis.
Missing Explanation after evidence.
L — Link & Craft
Score: ___/4
Strong closing Link, smooth transitions, and accurate CUPS conventions.
Clear Link and transitions; few minor convention errors.
Abrupt ending or repetitive Link; noticeable CUPS errors.
No Link; frequent errors block readability.
Step 2: Peer Review Feedback (Total Score: _____ / 16)
1. Strongest PEEL Move (Glow):
2. Top Priority to Upgrade (Grow):
Return this rubric to the author so they can complete Page 2's Revision Action Plan. Page 1 of 2
Day 4 • Final Polish & Reflection
Revision Action Plan & Exit Ticket
Name: _______________________
Part 1: My 2 Targeted Revisions
Based on your rubric scores and peer feedback, write out two specific upgrades you are making to your draft.
REVISION #1 (Circle focus: Point / Evidence / Explanation / Link / Transitions)
REVISION #2 (Circle focus: Point / Evidence / Explanation / Link / Transitions)
Part 2: CUPS Final Edit Check
C: Passage title & sentence starts capitalized
U: Formal 3rd-person tone throughout
P: Quotation marks & commas checked
S: Key vocabulary spelled accurately
Part 3: Final Unit Exit Ticket
Which part of PEEL (Point, Evidence, Explanation, or Link) improved the most for you over these 4 days, and why?
Staple your final ECR draft behind this sheet before turning it in! Page 2 of 2
Day 4 Teacher Guide 4-Day Expository ECR Unit • 7th Grade ELA
Day 4: Polish and Publish — Teacher Guide
40–45 Min
Teacher Prep
Students need their Day 3 ECR Rough Draft .
Copy PEEL Rubric and Review (2 pages).
Queue Polish and Publish Slides .
Learning Objective
Students will evaluate an expository ECR against a 4-point PEEL rubric, execute two targeted revisions, edit for conventions, and reflect on growth.
Day 4 Instructional Pacing (40-Min Core + 5-Min Flex)
Time
Phase
Teacher Moves & Key Prompts
0–6 min
Revise vs. Edit
Slides 1–4
Clarify the difference between revising PEEL ideas and editing CUPS. Walk through the color-coding peer review protocol and 4/4 Master Builder target.
6–19 min
Partner Peer Review
Rubric Page 1
Pair students. Partners mark P, E, E, L on the draft, score each row of the rubric (out of 16), and write specific Glow & Grow feedback.
19–34 min
(+5 flex)
Targeted Revision
Slide 5 • Page 2
Authors reclaim drafts, write 2 targeted revisions on Page 2, apply changes to their draft (or write a clean final copy if preferred), and run the CUPS check.
34–40 min
Exit Ticket & Submit
Slide 6 • Page 2
Students complete the Part 3 Exit Ticket reflection and staple their final ECR draft behind the rubric packet for submission.
Grading Calibration Tip
Use the same 16-point PEEL rubric on Page 1 to score final drafts quickly—highlight the descriptors and compare your score with the peer/self score.
Differentiation & Extension
Support: Allow students to revise directly on their Day 3 draft using colored pen or sticky notes.
Extend: Host a 5-minute "Author's Chair" where 2–3 volunteers read their strongest Explanation aloud.
Unit Complete: Collect ECR Packets (Rubric + Final Draft) for summative assessment. Day 4 Teacher Guide