Deliberation Timeline Worksheet
Case #4132-B
Deliberation Timeline
12 Angry Men: Act III Sequencing
Juror Name:
Date:
Instructions
The heat is rising and the tension is at a breaking point. Below are seven key events from Act III, listed out of order. Number the events **1 through 7** in the boxes provided to show the correct chronological sequence.
Juror 10 goes on a bigoted rant about "those people." One by one, the other jurors stand up and turn their backs to him in silence.
The jury notices deep marks on the bridge of Juror 4's nose, leading them to realize the female witness wore glasses and likely wasn't wearing them in bed.
The act begins with a tie vote of 6-6. Outside, it begins to rain heavily as the jurors discuss the evidence by the window.
Juror 3 stands alone as the final "Guilty" vote. After a final emotional outburst, he breaks down, tears up a photo of his son, and changes his vote.
Juror 5, who grew up in the slums, explains that an experienced knife fighter would never stab downward with a switchblade.
Juror 7 changes his vote to "Not Guilty" simply because he is tired of talking and wants to go to his baseball game.
Juror 3 demonstrates how the murder might have happened by lunging at Juror 8 with the knife, terrifying the other jurors.
Critical Reflection
Which of the events above do you think was the most important "turning point" that convinced the final group of jurors? Explain your reasoning below.
Deliberation Timeline Answer Key
Answer Key
Teacher Ref
Deliberation Timeline
Internal Document: Answer Key
The following sequence represents the canonical flow of Act III in Reginald Rose's 12 Angry Men.
1
The act begins with a tie vote of 6-6. Outside, it begins to rain heavily as the jurors discuss the evidence by the window.
2
Juror 3 demonstrates how the murder might have happened by lunging at Juror 8 with the knife, terrifying the other jurors.
3
Juror 5, who grew up in the slums, explains that an experienced knife fighter would never stab downward with a switchblade.
4
Juror 7 changes his vote to "Not Guilty" simply because he is tired of talking and wants to go to his baseball game.
5
Juror 10 goes on a bigoted rant about "those people." One by one, the other jurors stand up and turn their backs to him in silence.
6
The jury notices deep marks on the bridge of Juror 4's nose, leading them to realize the female witness wore glasses.
7
Juror 3 stands alone as the final "Guilty" vote. After a final emotional outburst, he breaks down, tears up a photo of his son, and changes his vote.
Teacher Note: Reflection Turning Points
While student answers may vary, most will point to either **Event 5** (the knife angle) as the logical turning point, or **Event 6** (the glasses) as the moment that breaks the last piece of strong evidence. **Event 7** is the emotional turning point where Juror 3's personal bias is finally exposed.
