Data Engine Slides Day 1 • 35-Minute Close Read
Lesson 1 of 2
Technology & Our Community
Data Centers: The Hidden Engines of the Internet
Where does the internet really live? Today we explore the giant computer warehouses that power AI and learn why towns across the country are debating whether to let them move in.
Read & annotate the article
Master 6 essential civic terms
Compare benefits vs. problems
Where Does "The Cloud" Really Live?
5-Minute Warm-Up
Real, Physical Buildings
When you watch a video or ask an AI chatbot a question, a real computer somewhere does the work.
That computer is inside a data center: a building as big as a football field filled with thousands of servers running 24/7.
4,000+
Already in the U.S.
More than 4,000 data centers operate across America right now.
3,000+
More Planned Soon
Tech companies want thousands more to keep up with the boom in AI.
Partner Question: Why do you think AI needs so much more computer power than regular browsing? Think-Pair-Share
Words to Know from Our Article
Key Vocabulary
server
A powerful computer that stores info and runs programs for lots of users at once.
power grid
The network of power plants and wires that delivers electricity to homes and towns.
property tax
Money landowners pay to the town to fund public schools, parks, and roads.
tax break
A special discount or deal that lets a company pay less money in local taxes.
moratorium
An official pause or temporary stop on building something for a period of time.
ballot measure
A question that citizens vote on directly during an election.
You will see these six words on Page 1 and Page 2 of your Reading Guide!
Why Supporters Want Data Centers
The Good Side (Pros)
Tax Money for Towns
These companies pay property taxes that can help pay for local schools, teachers, fire trucks, and road repairs.
Text Section 2
Construction Jobs
Building these giant facilities creates jobs for electricians, builders, and construction workers.
Text Section 2
U.S. AI Leadership
Tech leaders say having more data centers helps the United States stay ahead of other countries in artificial intelligence.
Text Section 2
Discussion: Which of these three benefits would help your own town the most?
The Problems: Community & Environmental Costs
The Problem Side (Cons)
Huge Electricity Use
Data centers use massive amounts of power. People worry this will strain local power grids and raise family electric bills.
600 Billion Gallons of Water
Hot computers need water for cooling. One report says AI data centers could use up to 600 billion gallons of water by 2030.
Noise, Lights & Traffic
Giant cooling fans make a constant humming sound 24 hours a day. Bright security lights and trucks disturb quiet neighborhoods.
Lost Farmland and Trees
These campuses take up huge pieces of land, replacing open green fields, family farms, and wooded forests.
Notice how these issues affect both nature and everyday neighborhood life.
Communities Push Back Across the Country
Public Reaction
7 / 10
Americans Say No
A 2026 poll found that 7 out of 10 Americans do not want an AI data center built near their homes.
75+
Projects Delayed or Stopped
In early 2026 alone, neighbors worked together to delay or stop over 75 building plans.
Fort Worth, Texas
Neighbors spoke up at city hall, and leaders dropped a plan to give a company a tax break.
Important Fact: Critics point out that most jobs end after construction is finished, leaving few permanent local jobs.
Day 1 Wrap-Up: Getting Ready for Day 2
Tomorrow's Challenge
Tomorrow's CER Writing Prompt:
"Should your community allow a new data center to be built nearby? Make a claim, support it with at least two pieces of evidence from the article, and explain how your evidence supports your claim."
Complete your Day 1 Reading Guide now. Use the sentence stems on Page 2 to write complete answers!
Turn in your reading guide before leaving. Tomorrow we write our arguments! →
Data Center Reading Guide Data Centers: The Hidden Engines of the Internet
Name:
Date:
Period:
Key Vocabulary
Words to Know
server: a powerful computer that stores info and runs programs for many users
tax break: a deal that lets a company pay less money in taxes
power grid: the system of power plants and wires that delivers electricity
moratorium: an official pause on something for a period of time
property tax: money a landowner pays to local government to fund schools and roads
ballot measure: a question that voters decide directly in an election
What Is a Data Center?
When you watch a video or ask an AI chatbot a question, a computer does the work. That computer is likely inside a data center, a huge building full of powerful computers called servers. The U.S. has more than 4,000 data centers, and about 3,000 more are planned. Many new ones are for AI, which needs a lot of computer power.
Why Some People Want Data Centers
Supporters say data centers help towns. The companies pay property taxes that can fund schools and roads, and building them creates construction jobs. Tech companies also say the country needs more data centers to stay a leader in AI.
The Impact on Communities
Data centers use huge amounts of electricity. Some people worry this will raise families’ electric bills. Many also use water to cool their hot computers. One report says AI data centers could use up to 600 billion gallons by 2030, though some companies say newer buildings use much less. Neighbors also complain about noise, bright lights, traffic, and lost farmland or forests.
Communities Push Back
Pushback is growing. A 2026 Gallup poll found that 7 out of 10 Americans do not want an AI data center near them. In early 2026, opponents blocked or delayed at least 75 projects, and some towns voted to pause or ban new ones. In Fort Worth, Texas, neighbors raised concerns about noise, traffic, water, and energy at city meetings. Afterward, a council member dropped a plan to give the company a tax break. People with different political views push back, some over the environment and others over tax breaks.
What Comes Next?
The debate is mostly about where data centers should go and what rules they should follow. Supporters point to money and jobs. Critics say most jobs end after construction and towns pay a high price in water, power, and quiet.
Reading Tip: Circle benefits in green. Underline concerns in pencil. Page 1 of 2 • Turn to Page 2 for Questions →
Reading Check & Evidence Chart
Day 1 Comprehension & Analysis
Sentence Stems Included
1 Vocabulary Practice: Match each clue to the correct vocabulary word
A town puts a 6-month pause on building.
Word:
A company gets a deal to pay less money in taxes.
Word:
Citizens vote directly on a question on election day.
Word:
2 Text Questions (Use the provided sentence stems to write complete answers)
A. Why are tech companies planning about 3,000 new data centers in the United States?
[ A ] To store paper books and magazines
[ B ] To provide computer power for AI chatbots
[ C ] To build community parks and playgrounds
[ D ] To replace local electric power lines
B. What happens to jobs in a town after a data center is built?
Sentence Stem: Critics say that after construction ends, jobs in the town...
C. What did the Gallup poll show? What happened in Fort Worth, Texas?
Sentence Stem: The poll showed that 7 out of 10 Americans... . In Fort Worth, city leaders decided to...
3 Evidence Chart (Getting Ready for Tomorrow's CER Writing)
Supporters' Reasons (Pros)
Sentence Stem: "One benefit is that data centers..."
Fact 1:
Fact 2:
Critics' Concerns (Cons)
Sentence Stem: "One concern is that data centers..."
Fact 1:
Fact 2:
Civic & Tech Literacy • Day 1 Close Read Save this sheet for tomorrow's CER writing!
Engines Lesson Plan Teacher Instructional Guide • Day 1
Engines of the Internet: Lesson Plan
35-Minute Total Duration
Reading Comprehension & Civics
Learning Objectives
Define 6 civic and tech terms using student-friendly definitions.
Identify central ideas and details about data center benefits and problems.
Write text-dependent responses using sentence stems to form complete, clear answers.
Target Standards & Materials
Standards: CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RI.1 (Text evidence), RI.4 (Context vocabulary), W.2 (Informative writing).
Materials: Data Engine Slides, Student Reading Guide, Highlighters (green & yellow/pink).
35-Minute Bell-to-Bell Pacing Guide Fast, engaging instructional timing
00–05 min
(5 mins)
Hook & Mystery Question (Slides 1–2)
Display Slide 1 & 2. Ask: "Where does the cloud live?" Dispel the myth that the internet is invisible—it lives in physical server buildings.
05–12 min
(7 mins)
Vocabulary Deep Dive (Slide 3 & Guide)
Review key terms: property tax (revenue for schools/roads) vs. tax break (incentive discount). Explain how a moratorium halts construction while towns study impacts.
12–24 min
(12 mins)
Shared Reading & Dual Annotation (Slides 4–6)
Choral or partner read of the 5 text sections. Guide dual annotation: highlight economic benefits in green, environmental/quality of life costs in pink.
24–31 min
(7 mins)
Comprehension with Sentence Stems (Page 2)
Students complete Section 1 (Vocab) and Section 2 (Questions B & C). Direct students to trace and complete the printed sentence stems to write full, clear answers.
31–35 min
(4 mins)
Partner Evidence Matrix & Exit Debrief (Slide 7)
Students record 2 pros and 2 cons in Section 3 with their partner. Remind them to file their guide for tomorrow's CER writing lesson.
Common Misconception
The "Tech Jobs" Myth: Students often assume giant data centers employ hundreds of office workers. Clarify that while initial construction creates jobs, operating data centers are heavily automated and employ few permanent workers.
Sentence Stem Scaffolding
Oral Rehearsal: Have students read the sentence stem aloud with their partner before filling in the rest of the sentence. This supports oral language and builds writing stamina.
Lesson 1 Teacher Plan • Data Center Dilemma Page 1 of 2 • Turn for Complete Answer Key →
Teacher Reference & Solutions
Day 1 Answer Key & Sentence Stem Exemplars
Exemplar Guide
Part 1: Vocabulary Practice Key
A town puts a 6-month pause:
moratorium
Company pays lower taxes:
tax break
Voters choose directly on ballot:
ballot measure
Part 2: Comprehension Questions Key
A. Why are tech companies planning about 3,000 new data centers in the U.S.?
Correct: [ B ] To provide enough computer power for artificial intelligence (AI).
B. What happens to jobs in a town after a data center is built?
Student Response Using Sentence Stem:
Critics say that after construction ends, jobs in the town mostly disappear because operating the building requires very few permanent workers, leaving local residents with fewer ongoing jobs than expected.
C. What did the Gallup poll show, and what happened in Fort Worth, TX?
Student Response Using Sentence Stem:
The poll showed that 7 out of 10 Americans do not want an AI data center built near their homes, and in Fort Worth, city leaders decided to drop a planned tax break after neighbors raised concerns about noise, water, and traffic.
Part 3: Evidence Chart Solutions
Supporters' Reasons (Accept any 2):
Pay property taxes to fund schools and roads.
Create jobs for construction workers.
Keep the country a leader in AI technology.
Critics' Concerns (Accept any 2):
Use tons of electricity and may raise electric bills.
Could use up to 600 billion gallons of water by 2030.
Make loud humming noise and destroy trees or farms.
Civic & Tech Literacy • Teacher Guide Page 2 of 2 • Ready for Day 2 CER Writing
Reading Guide Answer Key Day 1 Reading Comprehension • Teacher Master TEACHER ANSWER KEY
Data Centers: The Hidden Engines of the Internet
Grade 6 Civics & Literacy • Close Read Key
Article Text Annotation Guide
Dual-Color Annotation Strategy
GREEN HIGHLIGHT = PROS (Benefits): Property tax revenue for public schools/roads, construction jobs, AI tech leadership.
ROSE/ORANGE HIGHLIGHT = CONS (Concerns): High electric bills, 600B gallons water, noise/traffic, lost farmland, few long-term jobs.
What Is a Data Center? Paragraph 1 • Setting the Context
When you watch a video or ask an AI chatbot a question, a computer does the work. That computer is likely inside a data center, a huge building full of powerful computers called servers. The U.S. has more than 4,000 data centers, and about 3,000 more are planned. Many new ones are for AI, which needs a lot of computer power.
Why Some People Want Data Centers [Pro Stance Evidence]
Supporters say data centers help towns. The companies pay property taxes that can fund schools and roads, and building them creates construction jobs. Tech companies also say the country needs more data centers to stay a leader in AI.
The Impact on Communities [Con Stance Evidence]
Data centers use huge amounts of electricity. Some people worry this will raise families’ electric bills. Many also use water to cool their hot computers. One report says AI data centers could use up to 600 billion gallons by 2030, though some companies say newer buildings use much less. Neighbors also complain about noise, bright lights, traffic, and lost farmland or forests.
Communities Push Back [Civic Action & Data]
Pushback is growing. A 2026 Gallup poll found that 7 out of 10 Americans do not want an AI data center near them. In early 2026, opponents blocked or delayed at least 75 projects, and some towns voted to pause or ban new ones. In Fort Worth, Texas, neighbors raised concerns at city meetings, and a council member dropped a plan to give the company a tax break.
What Comes Next?
The debate is mostly about where data centers should go and what rules they should follow. Supporters point to money and jobs. Critics say most jobs end after construction and towns pay a high price in water, power, and quiet.
Teacher Checkpoint: Ensure students highlight at least two green facts and two pink/rose facts before flipping to Page 2. Turn to Page 2 for Solutions & Stems →
Reading Check & Evidence Chart Key
Complete Solutions with Modeled Sentence Stems
Answer Key
1 Part 1: Vocabulary Practice Solutions (1 pt each / 3 pts total)
Matching Clues
A town puts a 6-month pause on building.
Word: moratorium
A company gets a deal to pay less money in taxes.
Word: tax break
Citizens vote directly on a question on election day.
Word: ballot measure
2 Part 2: Text Questions Key (4 pts total)
A. Why are tech companies planning about 3,000 new data centers in the U.S.? (1 pt)
✓ Correct Choice: [ B ] To provide computer power for AI chatbots. (Paragraph 1 explicitly links new growth to AI demand).
B. What happens to jobs in a town after a data center is built? (1.5 pts)
Sample Complete Student Response: Critics say that after construction ends, jobs in the town drop off dramatically because modern data centers are automated and only need a small staff to run them, meaning very few permanent local jobs remain.
C. What did the Gallup poll show? What happened in Fort Worth, Texas? (1.5 pts)
Sample Complete Student Response: The poll showed that 7 out of 10 Americans do not want a data center built near their homes. In Fort Worth, city leaders decided to drop a tax break deal after neighbors spoke out about noise, traffic, and high water and electricity usage.
3 Part 3: Evidence Chart Acceptable Responses (4 pts total / 1 pt per fact)
Supporters' Reasons (Accept any 2):
• Property Tax Revenue: Companies pay local taxes to help fund community schools and fix roads.
• Construction Jobs: Building large facilities creates immediate work for construction crews.
• AI Leadership: Expands digital infrastructure so our nation remains a leader in technology.
Critics' Concerns (Accept any 2):
• Electricity & Bills: Heavy power use strains the electric grid and may raise family energy bills.
• Huge Water Use: AI facilities could consume up to 600 billion gallons of cooling water by 2030.
• Quality of Life: Loud humming noise, bright lights, heavy traffic, and loss of green farmland/forests.
Grading Summary: Part 1 (3 pts) + Part 2 (4 pts) + Part 3 (4 pts) = 11 Points Total . Teacher Reference • Keep on file for Day 2 writing checks
Argument Builder Slides Day 2 • 35-Minute Writing Sprint
Lesson 2 of 2
Evidence-Based Argumentation
The Data Debate: Writing a Strong CER
Imagine you are on your town council. Today, you will use facts from yesterday's article to write a persuasive CER paragraph about whether a data center belongs in your town.
Claim: Pick your side
Evidence: Give 2 facts
Reasoning: Explain why
The Three Parts of a CER Paragraph
Our Writing Recipe
CLAIM [C]
Your Answer
One clear sentence telling whether our town should allow a new data center.
No "I think" — state it clearly!
EVIDENCE [E]
Facts from Article
Exact facts or numbers from the reading that prove your point.
Include at least 2 real facts
REASONING [R]
Your Explanation
Explain in your own words why these facts matter to families in your town.
Connect your facts to your claim
Without reasoning, evidence is just a random fact!
Understanding Today's Prompt
Choose Your Side
Our Prompt:
"Should your community allow a new data center to be built nearby? Make a claim, support it with at least two pieces of evidence from the article, and explain how your evidence supports your claim."
Side YES: Allow It
Focus on money for schools, road repairs, construction jobs, and keeping America a leader in AI technology.
Side NO: Reject It
Focus on higher electric bills, 600 billion gallons of water used, loud humming noise, and loss of open trees and farmland.
You can pick either side! Just be sure to back up your choice with evidence.
Picking Strong Evidence from the Article
Evidence Check
Too Vague (Not enough detail)
"Computers get really hot and data centers are loud."
Why it's weak: It has no numbers or specific facts from the article. Anyone could guess this.
Needs specific text facts
Strong Fact (Specific & Cited)
"According to the text, AI data centers could use up to 600 billion gallons of water by 2030."
Why it's strong: It uses the exact number (600 billion gallons) and names where it came from.
Clear, exact, and convincing!
Look at your Day 1 Evidence Chart to pick your two best facts!
Sentence Stems for Your Writing
Writing Helpers
1. Claim Stems
"Our community should allow a new data center because..."
"Our community should not allow a data center because..."
2. Evidence Stems
"According to the text, '...'"
"In addition, the author states that '...'"
3. Reasoning Stems
"This shows that our town would..."
"This is important because families..."
These exact sentence stems are printed on Page 2 of your worksheet!
17-Minute Writing Sprint
Silent Writing
1
Page 1: Plan (5 mins)
Write your claim and copy your 2 evidence facts and explanations into the organizer.
2
Page 2: Draft (10 mins)
Use the sentence stem helper strip on Page 2 to write your full 5–7 sentence paragraph.
3
Check Your Work (2 mins)
Complete the 4-box checklist at the bottom of Page 2 before time is up.
Remember: Claim + Evidence 1 + Reasoning 1 + Evidence 2 + Reasoning 2 + Conclusion! You've got this!
Wrap-Up & Check Your Paragraph
Finished!
Checklist Review:
I wrote a clear claim statement
I included at least 2 facts from the article
I used sentence stems to explain reasoning
I checked capital letters and periods
Turn in your completed CER Worksheet to your teacher. Awesome job writing like civic leaders!
Data Debate CER Worksheet Civic & Tech Literacy • Day 2 CER Argument Student Planning Sheet
The Data Debate: Writing Your Argument
Name:
Date:
Period:
Writing Prompt
"Should your community allow a new data center to be built nearby? Make a claim, support it with at least two pieces of evidence from the article, and explain how your evidence supports your claim."
1 Step 1: Pick Your Side & Write Your Claim
1 complete sentence
YES: Allow data center
NO: Reject data center
RULES: Allow with strict limits
YES Stem: "Our community should allow a new data center because..."
NO Stem: "Our community should not allow a new data center because..."
My Claim:
2 Step 2: Evidence & Reasoning Organizer (From the Article)
Evidence #1 (Fact from Text)
Sentence Stem: "According to the article, '...'"
Reasoning #1 (My Explanation)
Sentence Stem: "This shows that our town would..."
Evidence #2 (Second Fact from Text)
Sentence Stem: "In addition, the text states that '...'"
Reasoning #2 (My Explanation)
Sentence Stem: "This is important because families in our town..."
Great planning! Now combine your sentences into your final paragraph on Page 2. Page 1 of 2 • Turn to Page 2 to Write →
Final CER Argument Paragraph
Use the sentence stems below to write your paragraph
Goal: 5–7 complete sentences
Sentence Stems for Your Paragraph (Follow these in order):
[1. Claim]: "Our community [should / should not] allow a data center because..."
[2. Evidence 1]: "According to the text, '...'"
[3. Reasoning 1]: "This shows that our community would..."
[4. Evidence 2]: "In addition, the author writes that '...'"
[5. Reasoning 2]: "This matters because residents would..."
[6. Conclusion]: "For these reasons, our town leaders should..."
Writer's Quality Checklist (Check off each item before handing in)
Claim: I wrote a clear answer stating whether to allow or reject.
Evidence: I included at least 2 real facts or numbers from the text.
Reasoning: I explained HOW my facts affect families in our town.
Conventions: I used capital letters, periods, and sentence stems.
Civic & Tech Literacy • Day 2 Writing Assessment Turn this worksheet in when finished.
CER Rubric and Exemplars Teacher Facilitation Guide • Day 2
The Data Debate: Lesson Plan & Rubric
35-Minute Total Duration
Argumentative Writing (CER)
35-Minute Instructional Pacing Breakdown Day 2 Writing Sequence
00–05 min (5m)
CER Warm-Up
Display Slides 1–2. Review Claim, Evidence, and Reasoning definitions.
05–13 min (8m)
Prompt & Model
Display Slides 3–5. Contrast strong facts with guesses. Model sentence stems.
13–30 min (17m)
Writing Sprint
Students plan on Page 1 and draft on Page 2. Teacher conducts quick 1-minute desk check-ins.
30–35 min (5m)
Self-Check & Exit
Students complete the 4-point checklist on Page 2 and hand in their completed work.
Analytic CER Scoring Rubric (16 Points Total)
Trait
Exceeds (4)
Meets (3)
Developing (2)
Emerging (1)
Claim [C]
States clear, nuanced stance directly answering prompt.
States clear position (allow or reject).
Position is somewhat unclear or incomplete.
Missing claim or fails to answer prompt.
Evidence [E]
Cites 2+ specific, data-rich facts from the reading.
Includes 2 accurate facts from the text.
Only gives 1 fact, or fact is too vague.
No text facts cited; only personal opinion.
Reasoning [R]
Clearly explains HOW each fact affects people in town.
Explains why the evidence connects to the claim.
Repeats the fact without explaining impact.
Missing explanation or confusing logic.
Conventions
Polished transitions, varied sentences, no major errors.
Clear transitions, minor errors do not hinder meaning.
Frequent sentence boundary or punctuation errors.
Severe mechanical errors impair comprehension.
Real-Time Conferencing Moves During 17-Minute Writing Sprint
Need a Claim?
Say: "Use Stem 1 on Page 2: 'Our community should [allow / not allow] a data center because...'"
Need Numbers?
Say: "Check your Day 1 chart! Can you quote '600 billion gallons' or 'pay property taxes'?"
Stuck on Reasoning?
Say: "Finish this sentence: 'This matters to families in our town because...' What happens next?"
Lesson 2 Teacher Guide • Data Center Dilemma Page 1 of 2 • Turn for Annotated Exemplars →
Exemplars & Sentence Stem Models
Student Writing Exemplars (Using Sentence Stems)
Exemplar Models
Exemplar A: Pro-Data Center Paragraph (Full Score: 16/16) Score: 4/4/4/4
[Claim] Our community should allow a new data center because it will bring money to our town and help fund our public schools. [Evidence 1] According to the text, data center companies pay property taxes that can fund schools and roads, and building them creates construction jobs. [Reasoning 1] This shows that our town would have extra money to fix roads and buy school supplies without raising taxes on families. [Evidence 2] In addition, the author states that tech companies say the country needs more data centers to stay a leader in AI. [Reasoning 2] This matters because our town can help support modern technology while creating new jobs for local workers. [Conclusion] For these reasons, our town leaders should allow a new data center to be built.
Exemplar B: Anti-Data Center Paragraph (Full Score: 16/16) Score: 4/4/4/4
[Claim] Our community should not allow a new data center because it uses too much electricity and harms our local environment. [Evidence 1] According to the text, AI data centers could use up to 600 billion gallons of water by 2030 to cool computers, and they use huge amounts of electricity. [Reasoning 1] This shows that our community could face water shortages, and family electric bills might increase. [Evidence 2] In addition, the author writes that neighbors complain about noise, traffic, and lost farmland, and critics say most jobs end after construction. [Reasoning 2] This matters because residents would lose quiet neighborhoods and farmland for very few long-term jobs. [Conclusion] For these reasons, our town leaders should vote against building a new data center.
Striving Writers / Language Scaffolds
Have students trace the printed sentence stems directly onto Page 2 before adding their own words. Pair students to orally rehearse each sentence stem before drafting.
Advanced Extension (Counterclaim)
Challenge advanced students to add a counterargument starter: "Even though supporters say data centers bring tax money, this does not make up for using 600 billion gallons of water."
Civic Writing Assessment • Teacher Guide Page 2 of 2 • Evaluation Ready
Data Debate Highlighted Exemplar Writing Model • Anchor Reference Handout Color-Coded CER Exemplar
Data Debate Highlighted Exemplar
Name:
Period:
CER Color Key: Notice how every color plays a specific role
BLUE = CLAIM [C] Direct answer to the prompt
YELLOW = EVIDENCE [E] Facts & data from the text
GREEN = REASONING [R] Explains community impact
PURPLE = CONCLUSION Civic call to action
Model A
YES Stance: Welcoming Data Centers to Our Community
Scored Exemplar • Full Credit
Our community should allow a new data center because it will bring valuable money to our town and help fund our public schools. According to the text, data center companies pay property taxes that can fund schools and roads, and building them creates construction jobs. This shows that our town would have extra funding to repair neighborhood streets and buy modern school supplies without raising taxes on families. In addition, the author states that tech companies say the country needs more data centers to stay a leader in AI. This matters because our town can help support important new technology while creating good local construction jobs for workers. For these reasons, our town leaders should vote to allow a new data center to be built.
Why Claim [C] Works:
Directly answers the prompt using the sentence stem. Clearly states the "allow" stance.
Why Evidence [E] Works:
Cites two verified facts from Section 2 (property taxes funding schools & construction jobs).
Why Reasoning [R] Works:
Explains HOW the tax money helps townspeople (better roads without higher family taxes).
Quick Reader Check:
Underline the transition phrases used in Model A to introduce evidence and reasoning:
"According to the text..."
"This shows that..."
"In addition..."
Unit: Data Center Dilemma • CER Writing Anchor Turn to Page 2 for the Model B (NO Stance) Exemplar →
Model B: Anti-Data Center Exemplar
Opposing Viewpoint Model • Color-Coded Breakdown
NO Stance Model
Model B
NO Stance: Protecting Our Hometown Resources
Scored Exemplar • Full Credit
Our community should not allow a new data center because it uses too much electricity and harms our local environment. According to the text, AI data centers could use up to 600 billion gallons of water by 2030 to cool computers, and they consume huge amounts of power. This shows that our community could face water shortages, and families' monthly electric bills could go up. In addition, the author writes that neighbors complain about constant noise, traffic, and lost farmland, and critics say most jobs end after construction. This matters because residents would lose quiet neighborhoods and farmland for very few permanent jobs. For these reasons, our town leaders should vote against building a new data center.
Why Claim [C] Works:
States a firm rejection without using weak filler like "I think" or "Maybe."
Why Evidence [E] Works:
Cites powerful quantitative data: 600 billion gallons of water by 2030.
Why Reasoning [R] Works:
Explains that short-term construction jobs don't justify permanent noise and lost land.
Exemplar Analysis: What makes both models successful?
1. Structure Check:
Both paragraphs follow the exact 6-part order: Claim → Evidence 1 → Reasoning 1 → Evidence 2 → Reasoning 2 → Conclusion .
2. Stance Neutrality:
Notice that either stance (YES or NO) can earn a 100% score. What matters is having real text facts and clear reasoning !
Your Turn Reflection: Which piece of evidence from either model do you find most convincing for your town, and why?
Civic & Tech Literacy • Exemplar Anchor Sheet Keep this beside your CER Worksheet while drafting today!