Island Scar Answer Key
Teacher Answer Key & Scoring Guide
Lord of the Flies: Chapter 1 Setting Analysis
Suggested Total
40 Points
Grading Note: Student responses in Part 2 should show close reading of both excerpts and cite specific sensory details. Accept valid alternative wording and textual examples that accurately address each prompt.
Part 2: Analysis Questions (Exemplar Responses)
20 pts (5 pts each)
Q1
Several times throughout the chapter, the narrator refers to “the scar” that was “smashed into the jungle.” What is “the scar”? Why do you think William Golding chose to use this phrase?
What “the scar” is: The long, torn path of broken trees, crushed creepers, and cleared undergrowth left behind by the crashing airplane before it was washed out to sea.
Why Golding chose this phrase: Calling the wreckage path a “scar” personifies the island as a living body that has been wounded. Paired with the violent verb “smashed,” it signals that human civilization arrived as a destructive force and foreshadows the harm and loss of innocence to come.
Q2
What is the tone of the jungle description? What is the tone of the beach description? How does Golding’s word choice create two different impressions of the island?
Jungle Tone
Oppressive, chaotic, and hostile. Phrases like “bath of heat,” “clambering heavily,” “witch-like cry,” and “scratched by thorns” make it feel suffocating and threatening.
Beach Tone
Expansive, serene, and dazzling (with subtle unease). Details like “green feathers,” “shimmering water,” and “still as a mountain lake” evoke calm beauty.
Contrast in Impressions: Harsh, physical verbs in the jungle portray nature as a trap or obstacle, while graceful imagery and vivid colors on the beach create an illusion of paradise—even as “decaying coconuts” and relentless heat hint at underlying danger.
Part 2: Analysis Questions (Continued)
Questions 3 & 4
Q3
Identify THREE powerful phrases/details that help the reader visualize the setting. Explain what each detail helps you picture.
Sample strong responses below. Accept any three accurate quotes from either excerpt paired with a clear visual explanation.
1. “a bird, a vision of red and yellow, flashed upwards with a witch-like cry”
Helps the reader picture a sudden, vivid streak of bright tropical color bursting out of the dark green undergrowth, paired with a sharp, eerie sound.
2. “their green feathers were a hundred feet up in the air”
Compares the palm fronds to giant bird feathers towering above the shore, helping the reader visualize the immense height and gentle sway of the palms.
3. “blue of all shades and shadowy green and purple”
Creates a rich, painterly image of the lagoon’s varying depths—shifting from bright shallow blues to deep, mysterious greens and purples inside the reef.
Additional Acceptable Quotes Students May Choose
“creepers and broken trunks” • “a multitude of raindrops fell pattering” • “stood or leaned or reclined against the light” • “white surf flinked on a coral reef” • “perspectives of palm and beach and water drew to a point at infinity”
Q4
Does Golding portray the island as entirely beautiful and inviting? Explain your answer using at least TWO details from the passage.
Exemplar Answer: No, Golding does not portray the island as entirely beautiful or inviting. Although the lagoon and palm-lined beach look stunning at first glance, he repeatedly pairs that beauty with images of violence, physical discomfort, and decay.
Acceptable Supporting Details (Need at least 2)
- “the long scar smashed into the jungle was a bath of heat” — emphasizes violent destruction and suffocating, inescapable heat.
- “caught and scratched by thorns” / “witch-like cry” — shows the jungle is physically painful, unwelcoming, and eerie.
- “torn everywhere by the upheavals of fallen trees, scattered with decaying coconuts” — introduces rot and ruin even on the beach terrace.
- “coarse grass” / “always, almost visible, was the heat” — reinforces that the environment is harsh and relentless rather than comfortable.
Part 3: Setting Illustration Key & Rubric
20 Points Total
Required Geographical Features
- Perspective: Drawn from Ralph’s viewpoint (e.g., leaning against a grey palm trunk, looking out over the beach/lagoon or back toward the scar).
- Jungle & Scar: Dense, dark forest behind the beach with the open, torn path of “the scar” smashed through broken trunks.
- Palm Terrace: Leaning palm trees, coarse grass, fallen trees, and decaying coconuts.
- Shore & Water: Thin strip of beach, calm multi-colored lagoon, irregular arc of coral reef with white surf, and dark blue open sea beyond.
Sample Textual Labels (Need 5+)
- “the open space of the scar” (torn path)
- “creepers and broken trunks” (jungle floor)
- “a vision of red and yellow” (tropical bird)
- “darkness of the forest proper” (deep jungle)
- “green feathers... a hundred feet up” (palm tops)
- “one hand against a grey trunk” (Ralph’s spot)
- “bank covered with coarse grass” (terrace)
- “scattered with decaying coconuts” (shore bank)
- “the beach... was thin stick” (narrow sand)
- “blue of all shades and shadowy green and purple” (lagoon)
- “white surf flinked on a coral reef” (outer reef)
- “the open sea was dark blue” (horizon)
Color Check: Illustrations must use deliberate color—not pencil-only sketches. Look for dark greens/browns in the jungle, a burst of red/yellow for the bird, grey palm trunks, varied blues/greens/purples in the lagoon, white surf, and dark blue open ocean.
Part 3 Grading Rubric
Score: _____ / 20 pts
| Criteria (Points) |
Exemplary |
Proficient |
Developing |
| Textual Accuracy & Geography (8 pts max) |
7–8 pts Accurately depicts all major features from the chosen excerpt(s) from Ralph’s perspective; clearly not a generic island. |
5–6 pts Depicts most key features from the text with minor omissions in perspective or layout. |
1–4 pts Resembles a generic tropical island; missing several key geographical details from Golding’s text. |
| Required Labels (5+ Quotes) (6 pts max) |
5–6 pts Includes 5 or more accurate, neatly placed labels quoting specific phrases from the excerpts. |
3–4 pts Includes 4–5 labels, though some may paraphrase rather than quote the text directly. |
1–2 pts Fewer than 4 labels, or labels are vague and disconnected from Golding’s wording. |
| Color, Detail & Effort (6 pts max) |
5–6 pts Richly detailed, thoughtfully colored to match Golding’s palette, and easy to interpret. |
3–4 pts Colored and neat, though some areas lack fine detail or specific text-matched hues. |
1–2 pts Minimal or no color, rushed sketching, or difficult to interpret. |