Moon Evidence Lesson Plan Argumentative Writing • Day 1 of 2 30 Minutes
Moon Evidence Lesson Plan
Reading "Should Humans Build a Base on the Moon?", Key Words & Sorting Reasons
Lesson Goals
Learn and use 6 key space words from the article.
Find and sort YES and NO reasons from paragraphs 2–7 with paragraph numbers.
Pick a side and explain why using a sentence stem.
Materials & Prep
Student Packet: Should Humans Build a Base on the Moon? (Pages 1–2)
Day 1 Classroom Slides (Moon Evidence Slides )
Pencils or highlighters to mark YES/NO reasons and star top picks
30-Minute Pacing & Teaching Guide
Time
Lesson Part
What the Teacher & Students Do
0:00–0:05
(5 min)
Warm-Up & Key Words
Slides 1–2 • Page 1
Share the big question. Preview the 6 key words on Page 1 (astronaut, explore, invention, dangerous, radiation, benefit ). Read each word out loud together and underline the clue in each example sentence.
0:05–0:13
(8 min)
Read Together
Slide 3 • Page 1
Read paragraphs 1–8 aloud together. Have students circle the 6 key words as they hear them, put a + next to YES paragraphs (¶2–4), and put a − next to NO paragraphs (¶5–7).
0:13–0:16
(3 min)
Model Step 1 (Chart A)
Slide 4 • Page 2
Read the Writing Prompt on Page 2. Point to the Chart A example from Paragraph 2: "A human can explore in ways a robot cannot." Show students how to write a short reason in their own words and add the paragraph number.
0:16–0:24
(8 min)
Partner Reason Sort
Slide 5 • Page 2
In pairs, students reread paragraphs 2–7 to fill in Chart A (YES, ¶3–4) and Chart B (NO, ¶5–7) using the sentence stems on Slide 5. Walk around to make sure they include paragraph numbers and keep reasons short.
0:24–0:30
(6 min)
Steps 2–4 & Wrap-Up
Slide 6 • Page 2
Students work alone to star their best reasons (Step 2), check one side (Step 3), and finish the Step 4 sentence stem: "I chose this side because..." Check Page 2 so every student is ready for Day 2.
Day 2 Link: Keep student packets in class or in writing folders. Tomorrow's 30-minute lesson starts right from their starred reasons on Page 2 to fill out the Page 3 planner.
Teaching Tips & Sample Answers (Day 1)
Teacher Key
Sentence Stems for Written Responses
Chart A (YES): "One reason humans should build a Moon base is..."
Chart B (NO): "One reason humans should not build a Moon base is..."
Step 4: "I chose this side because the article says..."
Reading Tips & Quick Checks
Pause After ¶4: Ask, "What good things could a Moon base bring?" before reading ¶5–7.
¶1 and ¶8: Remind students that ¶1 and ¶8 introduce and wrap up the topic; reasons are in ¶2–7.
Step 1 Sample Answers — Chart A: YES (Humans SHOULD build a base on the Moon)
Reason (Short Summary)
Para. #
Example: A human can explore in ways a robot cannot. (Also: ice can be melted for drinking water.)
2
One reason humans should build a Moon base is space research makes helpful new inventions like memory foam and better water filters.
3
One reason humans should build a Moon base is astronauts can practice living in space before going to Mars, and it inspires students.
4
Step 1 Sample Answers — Chart B: NO (Humans should NOT build a base on the Moon)
Reason (Short Summary)
Para. #
One reason humans should not build a Moon base is it is too dangerous (no air, extreme heat/cold, radiation, and sharp dust).
5
One reason humans should not build a Moon base is it costs billions of dollars that could help fix hunger, schools, and hospitals on Earth.
6
One reason humans should not build a Moon base is we should take care of Earth first because Earth already has air, water, and food.
7
Steps 3 & 4 Sample Answers
If YES ("should build"):
"I chose this side because the article says a Moon base can lead to new inventions and help astronauts practice for Mars."
If NO ("should not build"):
"I chose this side because the article says living on the Moon is too dangerous and costs billions of dollars needed on Earth."
Moon Evidence Slides Argumentative Writing • Day 1 30-Minute Mission
Should Humans Build a Base on the Moon?
Today's Goal: Read the article, learn 6 key words, and sort YES and NO reasons to pick your side.
Packet Pages 1–2 Pencil or Highlighter
Key Words (Packet Page 1)
5 Minutes
astronaut
a person who travels into space
The astronaut flew to the space station.
explore
to travel and look around to learn new things
We will explore the cave.
invention
something new that a person makes
The phone was an important invention .
dangerous
likely to hurt someone
Crossing a busy street is dangerous .
radiation
invisible energy in space that can hurt the body
Spacesuits help block radiation .
benefit
something good that helps you
One benefit of exercise is a healthy heart.
Direction: Follow along on Page 1 and underline the clue in each example sentence.
Read & Mark the Text (Paragraphs 1–8)
8 Minutes
1. Circle Key Words
As we read out loud, circle the 6 bold key words in the article.
2. Put a + for YES Reasons
Put a + next to reasons why humans should build a Moon base.
3. Put a − for NO Reasons
Put a − next to reasons why humans should not build a Moon base.
Look at Paragraph 1 on Page 1 to begin!
Model: Step 1 Reason Chart (Page 2)
Watch & Listen
Directions: Reread paragraphs 2–7. Write one reason from each paragraph and write the paragraph number.
Chart A: YES — Humans SHOULD build a base on the Moon
Reason
Para. #
Example: A human can explore in ways a robot cannot.
2
Sentence Stem: "One reason humans should build a Moon base is ____________."
Partner Work: Fill In Charts A & B
8 Minutes
Chart A: YES (¶ 3 & 4)
Write 1 reason from ¶3 and 1 reason from ¶4.
Sentence Stem:
"One reason humans should build a Moon base is ____________."
Chart B: NO (¶ 5, 6, & 7)
Write 1 reason each from ¶5, ¶6, and ¶7.
Sentence Stem:
"One reason humans should not build a Moon base is ____________."
Remember: Write the paragraph number (Para. #) for every reason!
Your Turn: Steps 2, 3, & 4 (Page 2)
6 Minutes
Step 2
Circle or star the best reasons on the side you agree with.
Step 3
Pick your side. Check one box:
☐ I believe humans should build a base on the Moon.
☐ I believe humans should not build a base on the Moon.
Step 4
Use this sentence stem: "I chose this side because the article says ____________."
Keep your packet safe—tomorrow we write your essay!
Moon Base Student Packet Name: ____________________________________ Date: ___________________
Argumentative Writing Activity • Day 1 & Day 2
Should Humans Build a Base on the Moon?
Key Words to Know
Word
What It Means
Example Sentence
astronaut
a person who travels into space
The astronaut flew to the space station.
explore
to travel and look around to learn new things
We will explore the cave.
invention
something new that a person makes
The phone was an important invention.
dangerous
likely to hurt someone
Crossing a busy street is dangerous.
radiation
invisible energy in space that can hurt the body
Spacesuits help block radiation.
benefit
something good that helps you
One benefit of exercise is a healthy heart.
Article: Should Humans Build a Base on the Moon?
Mark + for YES | Mark − for NO
(1) The Moon is Earth's closest neighbor in space. It is gray, dusty, and has no air. Astronauts first walked on the Moon in 1969, and the last visit was in 1972. Now space agencies are planning to send astronauts back. Some want to build a base where people could live and work. But many people disagree. Should humans build a base on the Moon?
(2) People who say "yes" believe the Moon can teach us a lot. Scientists have found ice hidden in dark craters near the Moon's south pole. Ice can be melted into water for drinking. Robots can study the Moon, but a robot can only do what it is told. A human scientist can look around, ask new questions, and explore in ways a robot cannot.
(3) Space programs also create new inventions . Many things we use every day came from space research. Memory foam pillows, scratch-resistant glasses, and better water filters were all helped by space science. Supporters say a Moon base would lead to even more inventions that help people on Earth.
(4) Some people think the Moon could be a stepping stone to other planets. The Moon is only about three days away from Earth by rocket. Astronauts could practice living in space before taking longer trips, like a trip to Mars. A Moon base could also inspire students to study science and math. Supporters say big goals make people work hard and dream big.
(5) People who say "no" believe living on the Moon is too dangerous . The Moon has no air to breathe. In the sunlight it can get hotter than boiling water, and in the dark it gets colder than 200 degrees below zero. With no air to protect them, astronauts are hit by radiation , which can harm the body and cause cancer. Moon dust is also sharp, like tiny pieces of glass. It can hurt people's lungs and break machines.
(6) A Moon base would also cost a huge amount of money. Experts say it could cost many billions of dollars. People who disagree say that money should be used to fix problems on Earth first. They point to hunger, pollution, schools, and hospitals that need help right now.
(7) Others say we should take care of the planet we already have. Earth has air, water, and food. The Moon has none of these things ready for people. They believe it makes more sense to protect Earth than to try to live somewhere so harsh.
(8) Building a base on the Moon would be one of the biggest adventures in human history. It would also be one of the riskiest and most expensive. Leaders will have to decide if the benefits are worth the risks and the cost.
Your Writing Mission
Write an essay telling whether humans should or should not build a base on the Moon. Use facts from the article to support your side.
Remember to include:
● Your side (claim) ● What the other side thinks & why you disagree ● 1 fact from the article (with Para. #) ● Correct spelling, capitals, and periods ● Why your fact proves your side (reasoning)
Step 1: Sort the Reasons (Paragraphs 2–7)
Reread each paragraph and write one short reason in the chart. Use the sentence stem to help you.
Chart A: YES — Humans SHOULD build a base on the Moon (Stem: "One reason humans should build a Moon base is...")
Reason
Para. #
Example: A human can explore in ways a robot cannot.
2
3
4
Chart B: NO — Humans should NOT build a base on the Moon (Stem: "One reason humans should not build a Moon base is...")
Step 2: Circle or star (★) the 2 strongest reasons on the side you agree with.
Step 3: Pick your side. Check one box:
☐ I believe humans should build a base on the Moon. ☐ I believe humans should not build a base on the Moon.
Step 4: Finish the sentence stem to explain your choice:
I chose this side because the article says _________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________________.
Step 5: Plan Your Essay
Use your starred reasons from Page 2 and the sentence stems below to plan each part.
Part
Sentence Stem
My Writing
C — Claim
(My side)
Humans should / should not build a base on the Moon because ______ and ______.
E — Evidence
(Fact + Para. #)
In paragraph ____, the article states that ______.
R — Reasoning
(Why it matters)
This shows that ______. This matters because ______.
Counterclaim
(Other side)
Some people believe ______ because ______.
Rebuttal
(Answer back)
However, ______.
Helpful Transition Words
To add a fact:
also, in addition, another reason
To explain:
this shows, this means, because, so
To answer the other side:
however, but, even though
Step 6: Write Your Essay
Copy your planner into the 4 paragraph frames below. Put ideas in your own words when you can.
Paragraph 1 — Introduction & Claim
The Moon is Earth's closest neighbor in space, and astronauts last visited it in 1972. Some people think we should build a base on the Moon, and others think we should not. I believe humans ________________ build a base on the Moon because _______________________________________________________________ and _________________________________________________________________________.
Paragraph 2 — Reason 1 (Evidence & Reasoning)
One reason is _______________________________________________________________________. In paragraph ____, the article states that _____________________________________________________________________________________________________. This shows that ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________.
Paragraph 3 — Other Side & Answer Back
Some people believe ____________________________________________________________ because ____________________________________________________________________. However, _____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________.
Paragraph 4 — Conclusion
In conclusion, humans ________________ build a base on the Moon. ____________________________________________________ and ____________________________________________________ show that this is the right choice.
Step 7: Self-Check Before You Turn It In
☐ My claim clearly says "should" or "should not." ☐ I explained how my fact supports my claim. ☐ I used 1 good fact from the article. ☐ I told what the other side thinks and used "However." ☐ I named the paragraph number for my fact. ☐ I checked my capital letters, periods, and spelling.
Moon Base Packet Exemplar Name: Jordan Rivera Student Exemplar (YES Side) Date: 11/17/2026
Argumentative Writing Activity • Day 1 & Day 2
Should Humans Build a Base on the Moon?
Key Words to Know (Sample underlined clues)
Word
What It Means
Example Sentence
astronaut
a person who travels into space
The astronaut flew to the space station.
explore
to travel and look around to learn new things
We will explore the cave.
invention
something new that a person makes
The phone was an important invention.
dangerous
likely to hurt someone
Crossing a busy street is dangerous.
radiation
invisible energy in space that can hurt the body
Spacesuits help block radiation.
benefit
something good that helps you
One benefit of exercise is a healthy heart.
Article: Should Humans Build a Base on the Moon?
Sample Marks: + (YES) | − (NO) | Word
(1) The Moon is Earth's closest neighbor in space. It is gray, dusty, and has no air. Astronauts first walked on the Moon in 1969, and the last visit was in 1972. Now space agencies are planning to send astronauts back. Some want to build a base where people could live and work. But many people disagree. Should humans build a base on the Moon?
[+] (2) People who say "yes" believe the Moon can teach us a lot. Scientists have found ice hidden in dark craters near the Moon's south pole. Ice can be melted into water for drinking. Robots can study the Moon, but a robot can only do what it is told. A human scientist can look around, ask new questions, and explore in ways a robot cannot.
[+] (3) Space programs also create new inventions. Many things we use every day came from space research. Memory foam pillows, scratch-resistant glasses, and better water filters were all helped by space science. Supporters say a Moon base would lead to even more inventions that help people on Earth.
[+] (4) Some people think the Moon could be a stepping stone to other planets. The Moon is only about three days away from Earth by rocket. Astronauts could practice living in space before taking longer trips, like a trip to Mars. A Moon base could also inspire students to study science and math. Supporters say big goals make people work hard and dream big.
[−] (5) People who say "no" believe living on the Moon is too dangerous. The Moon has no air to breathe. In the sunlight it can get hotter than boiling water, and in the dark it gets colder than 200 degrees below zero. With no air to protect them, astronauts are hit by radiation, which can harm the body and cause cancer. Moon dust is also sharp, like tiny pieces of glass. It can hurt people's lungs and break machines.
[−] (6) A Moon base would also cost a huge amount of money. Experts say it could cost many billions of dollars. People who disagree say that money should be used to fix problems on Earth first. They point to hunger, pollution, schools, and hospitals that need help right now.
[−] (7) Others say we should take care of the planet we already have. Earth has air, water, and food. The Moon has none of these things ready for people. They believe it makes more sense to protect Earth than to try to live somewhere so harsh.
(8) Building a base on the Moon would be one of the biggest adventures in human history. It would also be one of the riskiest and most expensive. Leaders will have to decide if the benefits are worth the risks and the cost.
Your Writing Mission
Exemplar
Write an essay telling whether humans should or should not build a base on the Moon. Use facts from the article to support your side.
Step 1: Sort the Reasons (Paragraphs 2–7)
Reread each paragraph and write one short reason in the chart. Use the sentence stem to help you.
Chart A: YES — Humans SHOULD build a base on the Moon
Reason
Para. #
Example: A human can explore in ways a robot cannot.
2
★ One reason humans should build a Moon base is space programs make helpful new inventions like memory foam and better water filters.
3
★ One reason humans should build a Moon base is astronauts can practice living in space before going to Mars.
4
Chart B: NO — Humans should NOT build a base on the Moon
Reason
Para. #
One reason humans should not build a Moon base is it is too dangerous because of radiation, extreme temperatures, and sharp dust.
5
One reason humans should not build a Moon base is it costs billions of dollars that could help fix hunger and schools on Earth.
6
One reason humans should not build a Moon base is Earth already has air, water, and food, so we should protect Earth first.
7
Step 2: Circle or star (★) the 2 strongest reasons on the side you agree with. (Starred ¶3 and ¶4 above)
Step 3: Pick your side. Check one box:
☑ I believe humans should build a base on the Moon. ☐ I believe humans should not build a base on the Moon.
Step 4: Finish the sentence stem to explain your choice:
I chose this side because the article says a Moon base can lead to new inventions that help people on Earth and help astronauts practice for Mars.
Step 5: Plan Your Essay
Completed planner using starred reasons from Page 2.
Exemplar
Part
Sentence Stem
My Writing
C — Claim
(My side)
Humans should / should not build a base on the Moon because ______ and ______.
Humans should build a base on the Moon because it makes new inventions and helps astronauts prepare for Mars.
E — Evidence
(Fact + Para. #)
In paragraph ____, the article states that ______.
In paragraph 3 , the article states that space science helped create memory foam pillows, scratch-resistant glasses, and better water filters.
R — Reasoning
(Why it matters)
This shows that ______. This matters because ______.
This shows that space programs help everyday life on Earth. This matters because a Moon base could bring even more helpful tools to people.
Counterclaim
(Other side)
Some people believe ______ because ______.
Some people believe we should not build a Moon base because it would cost many billions of dollars.
Rebuttal
(Answer back)
However, ______.
However, the new inventions and science discoveries from a Moon base can help solve problems on Earth too.
Helpful Transition Words
To add a fact:
also, in addition, another reason
To explain:
this shows, this means, because, so
To answer the other side:
however, but, even though
Step 6: Write Your Essay
Completed 4-paragraph essay using the Page 3 planner.
Exemplar
Paragraph 1 — Introduction & Claim
The Moon is Earth's closest neighbor in space, and astronauts last visited it in 1972. Some people think we should build a base on the Moon, and others think we should not. I believe humans should build a base on the Moon because it makes new inventions and helps astronauts prepare for Mars.
Paragraph 2 — Reason 1 (Evidence & Reasoning)
One reason is space programs create helpful tools for people on Earth. In paragraph 3, the article states that space science helped make memory foam pillows, scratch-resistant glasses, and better water filters. This shows that building a Moon base can lead to even more useful inventions for our daily lives.
Paragraph 3 — Other Side & Answer Back
Some people believe we should not build a Moon base because it would cost many billions of dollars. However, the new inventions and discoveries from a Moon base can help solve problems on Earth too.
Paragraph 4 — Conclusion
In conclusion, humans should build a base on the Moon. Helpful new inventions and practice for future Mars trips show that this is the right choice.
Step 7: Self-Check Before You Turn It In
☑ My claim clearly says "should" or "should not." ☑ I explained how my fact supports my claim. ☑ I used 1 good fact from the article. ☑ I told what the other side thinks and used "However." ☑ I named the paragraph number for my fact. ☑ I checked my capital letters, periods, and spelling.
Moon Base NO Exemplar Name: Maya Patel Student Exemplar (NO Side) Date: 11/17/2026
Argumentative Writing Activity • Day 1 & Day 2
Should Humans Build a Base on the Moon?
Key Words to Know (Sample underlined clues)
Word
What It Means
Example Sentence
astronaut
a person who travels into space
The astronaut flew to the space station.
explore
to travel and look around to learn new things
We will explore the cave.
invention
something new that a person makes
The phone was an important invention.
dangerous
likely to hurt someone
Crossing a busy street is dangerous.
radiation
invisible energy in space that can hurt the body
Spacesuits help block radiation.
benefit
something good that helps you
One benefit of exercise is a healthy heart.
Article: Should Humans Build a Base on the Moon?
Sample Marks: + (YES) | − (NO) | Word
(1) The Moon is Earth's closest neighbor in space. It is gray, dusty, and has no air. Astronauts first walked on the Moon in 1969, and the last visit was in 1972. Now space agencies are planning to send astronauts back. Some want to build a base where people could live and work. But many people disagree. Should humans build a base on the Moon?
[+] (2) People who say "yes" believe the Moon can teach us a lot. Scientists have found ice hidden in dark craters near the Moon's south pole. Ice can be melted into water for drinking. Robots can study the Moon, but a robot can only do what it is told. A human scientist can look around, ask new questions, and explore in ways a robot cannot.
[+] (3) Space programs also create new inventions. Many things we use every day came from space research. Memory foam pillows, scratch-resistant glasses, and better water filters were all helped by space science. Supporters say a Moon base would lead to even more inventions that help people on Earth.
[+] (4) Some people think the Moon could be a stepping stone to other planets. The Moon is only about three days away from Earth by rocket. Astronauts could practice living in space before taking longer trips, like a trip to Mars. A Moon base could also inspire students to study science and math. Supporters say big goals make people work hard and dream big.
[−] (5) People who say "no" believe living on the Moon is too dangerous. The Moon has no air to breathe. In the sunlight it can get hotter than boiling water, and in the dark it gets colder than 200 degrees below zero. With no air to protect them, astronauts are hit by radiation, which can harm the body and cause cancer. Moon dust is also sharp, like tiny pieces of glass. It can hurt people's lungs and break machines.
[−] (6) A Moon base would also cost a huge amount of money. Experts say it could cost many billions of dollars. People who disagree say that money should be used to fix problems on Earth first. They point to hunger, pollution, schools, and hospitals that need help right now.
[−] (7) Others say we should take care of the planet we already have. Earth has air, water, and food. The Moon has none of these things ready for people. They believe it makes more sense to protect Earth than to try to live somewhere so harsh.
(8) Building a base on the Moon would be one of the biggest adventures in human history. It would also be one of the riskiest and most expensive. Leaders will have to decide if the benefits are worth the risks and the cost.
Your Writing Mission
Exemplar (NO Side)
Write an essay telling whether humans should or should not build a base on the Moon. Use facts from the article to support your side.
Step 1: Sort the Reasons (Paragraphs 2–7)
Reread each paragraph and write one short reason in the chart. Use the sentence stem to help you.
Chart A: YES — Humans SHOULD build a base on the Moon
Reason
Para. #
Example: A human can explore in ways a robot cannot.
2
One reason humans should build a Moon base is space programs make helpful new inventions like memory foam and better water filters.
3
One reason humans should build a Moon base is astronauts can practice living in space before going to Mars.
4
Chart B: NO — Humans should NOT build a base on the Moon
Reason
Para. #
★ One reason humans should not build a Moon base is it is too dangerous because of radiation, extreme heat and cold, and sharp dust.
5
★ One reason humans should not build a Moon base is it costs billions of dollars that could help fix hunger and schools on Earth.
6
One reason humans should not build a Moon base is Earth already has air, water, and food, so we should protect Earth first.
7
Step 2: Circle or star (★) the 2 strongest reasons on the side you agree with. (Starred ¶5 and ¶6 above)
Step 3: Pick your side. Check one box:
☐ I believe humans should build a base on the Moon. ☑ I believe humans should not build a base on the Moon.
Step 4: Finish the sentence stem to explain your choice:
I chose this side because the article says living on the Moon is too dangerous for astronauts and costs billions of dollars needed to solve problems on Earth.
Step 5: Plan Your Essay
Completed planner using starred reasons from Page 2.
Exemplar (NO Side)
Part
Sentence Stem
My Writing
C — Claim
(My side)
Humans should / should not build a base on the Moon because ______ and ______.
Humans should not build a base on the Moon because it is too dangerous and costs too much money.
E — Evidence
(Fact + Para. #)
In paragraph ____, the article states that ______.
In paragraph 5 , the article states that the Moon has no air, extreme heat and cold, harmful radiation, and sharp Moon dust.
R — Reasoning
(Why it matters)
This shows that ______. This matters because ______.
This shows that the Moon is a harsh place for people. This matters because astronauts' lungs and bodies could be badly hurt.
Counterclaim
(Other side)
Some people believe ______ because ______.
Some people believe we should build a Moon base because humans can explore better than robots.
Rebuttal
(Answer back)
However, ______.
However, we should spend money to fix hunger, schools, and hospitals on Earth first before risking people's lives.
Helpful Transition Words
To add a fact:
also, in addition, another reason
To explain:
this shows, this means, because, so
To answer the other side:
however, but, even though
Step 6: Write Your Essay
Completed 4-paragraph essay using the Page 3 planner.
Exemplar (NO Side)
Paragraph 1 — Introduction & Claim
The Moon is Earth's closest neighbor in space, and astronauts last visited it in 1972. Some people think we should build a base on the Moon, and others think we should not. I believe humans should not build a base on the Moon because it is too dangerous and costs too much money.
Paragraph 2 — Reason 1 (Evidence & Reasoning)
One reason is living on the Moon can hurt astronauts. In paragraph 5, the article states that the Moon has no air, extreme heat and cold, harmful radiation, and sharp Moon dust. This shows that a Moon base puts people's lungs and health at serious risk.
Paragraph 3 — Other Side & Answer Back
Some people believe we should build a Moon base because humans can explore better than robots. However, we should spend money to fix hunger, schools, and hospitals on Earth first before risking people's lives.
Paragraph 4 — Conclusion
In conclusion, humans should not build a base on the Moon. The dangers to astronauts and the huge cost show that this is the right choice.
Step 7: Self-Check Before You Turn It In
☑ My claim clearly says "should" or "should not." ☑ I explained how my fact supports my claim. ☑ I used 1 good fact from the article. ☑ I told what the other side thinks and used "However." ☑ I named the paragraph number for my fact. ☑ I checked my capital letters, periods, and spelling.
Lunar Argument Lesson Plan Argumentative Writing • Day 2 of 2 30 Minutes
Lunar Argument Lesson Plan
Step 5 Planner (Page 3), Step 6 Essay Frames & Step 7 Self-Check (Page 4)
Lesson Goals
Plan a claim, text fact (with paragraph #), explanation, other side, and answer back.
Write a 4-paragraph essay using sentence stems and paragraph frames.
Check your work with the 6-item Self-Check list.
Materials & Prep
Student Packet Pages 1–2 (completed Day 1) + Pages 3–4
Day 2 Classroom Slides (Lunar Argument Slides )
Pencils (no extra lined paper needed—Page 4 has built-in space)
30-Minute Pacing & Teaching Guide
Time
Lesson Part
What the Teacher & Students Do
0:00–0:03
(3 min)
Review & Goals
Slides 1–2 • Page 2
Have students look at their starred reasons and checked box on Page 2. Remind them: "You already did the hard thinking yesterday—today we just put your ideas into an essay!" Review the 5 mission items on Slide 2.
0:03–0:10
(7 min)
Model Step 5 Planner
Slides 3–4 • Page 3
Use Slide 3 to model C (Claim), E (Evidence with Para. #), and R (Reasoning). Then use Slide 4 to model Counterclaim (from the opposite chart on Page 2) and Rebuttal starting with "However," . Show the Helpful Words box at the bottom of Page 3.
0:10–0:17
(7 min)
Step 5: Fill In Planner
Slide 5 • Page 3
Students fill in all 5 rows of the Page 3 planner using the sentence stems (short notes or full sentences are both fine!). Walk around to check that Reasoning explains why the fact matters, and Counterclaim shows the other side.
0:17–0:26
(9 min)
Step 6: Write Essay
Slide 6 • Page 4
Students copy their planner ideas into the 4 paragraph frames on Page 4. Remind struggling writers they only need to fill in the blanks—their sentences are already started for them!
0:26–0:30
(4 min)
Step 7: Self-Check
Slide 7 • Page 4
Read the 6-box Self-Check Before You Turn It In list on Page 4 together. Have students point to each part in their essay before checking each box, then celebrate finishing a 4-paragraph essay!
Support for Struggling Writers: On Page 3, let students write short phrases in the "My Writing" column instead of full sentences so they have plenty of time to finish all 4 paragraphs on Page 4 within 30 minutes.
Teaching Tips & Sample Answers (Day 2)
Teacher Key
Common Mistakes to Watch For
Reasoning repeats Evidence: Students often write "This shows space makes inventions." Ask: "So what? Why does that help people?"
Counterclaim agrees with Claim: Remind students that "Some people believe..." must come from the other chart (Chart B if YES; Chart A if NO).
Sample Planner Answers (Page 3 — Step 5)
Part
YES Sample (Should Build)
NO Sample (Should Not Build)
C — Claim
Humans should build a base on the Moon because it makes new inventions and prepares us for Mars.
Humans should not build a base on the Moon because it is too dangerous and costs too much money.
E — Evidence
In paragraph 3 , the article states that space research helped make memory foam, scratch-resistant glasses, and better water filters.
In paragraph 5 , the article states that astronauts face harmful radiation, extreme heat and cold, and sharp Moon dust.
R — Reasoning
This shows that space work helps everyday life. This matters because a Moon base could bring even more useful tools to Earth.
This shows that the Moon is a harsh place for people. This matters because astronauts' lungs and bodies could be badly hurt.
Counterclaim
Some people believe we should not build a base because it would cost many billions of dollars.
Some people believe we should build a base because astronauts could practice living in space before going to Mars.
Rebuttal
However, the new inventions and discoveries from a Moon base can help solve problems on Earth too.
However, it makes more sense to protect Earth and fix hunger and schools first before risking lives on the Moon.
Sample Essay — YES (Page 4 — Step 6)
The Moon is Earth's closest neighbor in space, and astronauts last visited it in 1972. Some people think we should build a base on the Moon, and others think we should not. I believe humans should build a base on the Moon because it makes new inventions and prepares us for Mars .
One reason is space programs help people on Earth . In paragraph 3 , the article states that space research led to memory foam, scratch-resistant glasses, and better water filters . This shows that exploring space brings useful tools to our daily lives .
Some people believe a Moon base costs too much because it takes billions of dollars . However, the inventions we gain help everyone on Earth .
In conclusion, humans should build a base on the Moon. New inventions and Mars practice show that this is the right choice.
Sample Essay — NO (Page 4 — Step 6)
The Moon is Earth's closest neighbor in space, and astronauts last visited it in 1972. Some people think we should build a base on the Moon, and others think we should not. I believe humans should not build a base on the Moon because it is too dangerous and costs too much money .
One reason is living on the Moon can hurt astronauts . In paragraph 5 , the article states that there is no air, extreme heat and cold, radiation, and sharp Moon dust . This shows that a Moon base puts people's health at serious risk .
Some people believe we should build a base because humans can explore better than robots . However, we should fix hunger and protect Earth first .
In conclusion, humans should not build a base on the Moon. The dangers to astronauts and the huge cost show that this is the right choice.
Lunar Argument Slides Argumentative Writing • Day 2 30-Minute Mission
Plan & Write Your Moon Base Essay
You already did the hard thinking on Page 2! Today, plug your starred reasons into Page 3 and Page 4 to write a full 4-paragraph essay.
Packet Pages 2–4 You've Got This!
Your Writing Mission (Page 2)
3 Minutes
Write an essay telling whether humans should or should not build a base on the Moon, using facts from the article.
Your Essay Needs 5 Things:
Your side (your claim ).
1 good fact from the article (with paragraph #).
Why your fact proves your side (reasoning ).
What the other side thinks, and why you still disagree.
Correct spelling, capital letters, and periods.
Should We Build It?
Model: Step 5 Planner — C, E, R (Page 3)
Watch & Listen
C — Claim (My Side)
Humans should build a base on the Moon because it makes new inventions and helps us prepare for Mars.
E — Evidence (Fact from the Article)
In paragraph 3 , the article states that space work helped make memory foam, scratch-resistant glasses, and better water filters.
R — Reasoning (Why It Matters)
This shows that space work helps people on Earth. This matters because a Moon base could bring even more useful tools.
Tip: You can write short notes in your planner to save time!
Model: Other Side & Answer Back (Page 3)
Watch & Listen
Counterclaim (What the other side thinks)
Some people believe we should not build a Moon base because it would cost many billions of dollars.
Rebuttal (Why I still disagree)
However, the new inventions from a Moon base can help solve problems on Earth too.
Other Side
vs. Answer Back
Helpful Words: Add a fact: also, in addition | Explain: this shows, because, so | Answer back: however, but
Work Time: Step 5 Planner (Page 3)
7 Minutes
Use the sentence stems on Page 3 to fill in all 5 boxes:
C: "Humans should / should not build a base on the Moon because ____ and ____."
E: "In paragraph ____, the article states that ____."
R: "This shows that ____. This matters because ____."
Counterclaim: "Some people believe ____ because ____."
Rebuttal: "However, ____."
C E R CC REB
5-Part Launch
Short notes are fine—just get your ideas down!
Work Time: Step 6 Write Your Essay (Page 4)
9 Minutes
Paragraph 1 — Intro & Claim
"I believe humans ____ build a base on the Moon because ____ and ____."
Paragraph 2 — Reason 1
"One reason is ____. In paragraph __, the article states that ____. This shows that ____."
Paragraph 3 — Other Side
"Some people believe ____ because ____. However, ____."
Paragraph 4 — Conclusion
"In conclusion, humans ____ build a base on the Moon. ____ and ____ show this is right."
Direction: Fill in the blanks on Page 4 using your Page 3 planner!
Step 7: Self-Check (Page 4)
4 Minutes
☐ My claim clearly says "should" or "should not."
☐ I used 1 good fact from the article.
☐ I named the paragraph number for my fact.
☐ I explained how my fact supports my claim.
☐ I told what the other side thinks and used "However."
☐ I checked my capital letters, periods, and spelling.
Mission Complete!
Point to each part in your essay before checking the box—great job!