Five Star ECR Worksheet
Five-Star ECR Practice
Elementary Reading • Evidence-Based Writing
Name:
Date:
How to Earn All 5 Stars
★ 1. Claim
Answer the prompt clearly in your own words.
★ 2. Evidence 1
Share a specific detail or quote from the text.
★ 3. Explain 1
Tell how your first detail proves your claim.
★ 4. Evidence 2
Add a second text detail and explain it.
★ 5. Polish
Wrap up and check capitals, spelling, and periods.
Passage 1: The Rooftop Sprouts
Fiction
When Maya moved into Apartment 4B, the building's flat rooftop looked like a gray parking lot in the sky. She missed the backyard oak tree at her old house. Every afternoon, Maya leaned against the brick railing and sighed.
One Saturday, her neighbor Mr. Alvarez carried up three wooden crates filled with dark soil. "Care to help?" he asked, handing Maya a small trowel. At first, Maya shrugged and poked at the dirt. Planting seeds in old crates did not seem like a real garden. Still, she pressed tiny basil and marigold seeds into the soil and watered them carefully.
Two weeks later, bright green stems peeked through the dirt. Soon, yellow marigolds bloomed beside tall tomato vines. Neighbors began bringing up watering cans and folding chairs. By July, bees hummed around the crates, and Maya had her own corner bench under a leafy trellis. "It's even better than I imagined," Maya smiled, handing Mr. Alvarez a ripe cherry tomato.
Prompt 1: How do Maya's feelings about the rooftop change from the beginning of the story to the end? Use details from the story to support your answer.
Self-Check: Shade in each star you earned!
☆☆☆☆☆
Five-Star ECR Practice • Page 2
Informational Text
Passage 2: Nature's Busy Builders
Science
Beavers are some of the hardest-working animals in North America. Using their strong, orange front teeth, beavers chew through tree trunks and branches. Then they drag the logs into a stream and pack them together with mud and stones to build a dam.
A beaver dam slows down rushing water and creates a calm, deep pond. That new pond quickly becomes a busy neighborhood for other wildlife. Frogs and salamanders lay their eggs in the still water. Ducks swim across the surface, while hungry herons wade near the muddy shore to catch small fish.
Beaver ponds even help the land during dry summers. Because the pond holds extra water, nearby plants and trees stay green longer. Even after beavers move away, the rich mud they leave behind helps wildflowers and grasses grow.
Prompt 2: How do beavers help other living things in their habitat? Use evidence from the passage to support your answer.
Quick Plan Before You Write
My Claim:
Text Evidence 1:
Text Evidence 2:
Self-Check: Shade in each star you earned!
☆☆☆☆☆