Summary Writing Rubric
Grade 6 ELA Assessment • Connecticut Core & CELP Aligned
Summary Writing Rubric
4-Point Scale
Name:
Date:
Text/Topic:
| Criteria & Standards |
4 — Exceeds Standard |
3 — Meets Standard |
2 — Approaching |
1 — Beginning |
|
|
|
|
|
| Central Idea & Key Details |
|
|
|
|
CT: RL.6.2 / RI.6.2
CELP: 6-8.1, 6-8.3
| Clearly and accurately states the central idea or theme and synthesizes the most essential supporting details from across the entire text without unnecessary minor facts. | Accurately states the central idea or theme and includes key supporting details that convey the text’s overall meaning, with minimal minor details. | Identifies a main topic or partial central idea; includes some key details, though several minor details may be included or important points omitted. | Does not clearly identify the central idea or theme; relies on a few isolated details, retells events out of context, or shows misunderstanding of the text. |
|
Objectivity & Tone
CT: RL.6.2, RI.6.2, W.6.2e
CELP: 6-8.7
| Completely objective and distinct from personal opinions or judgments; maintains a consistently formal, academic style and tone appropriate to the task and audience. | Remains objective and free of personal opinions or judgments; maintains an appropriate formal style and tone throughout most of the summary. | Mostly objective, though a personal opinion, judgment, or informal phrase appears; shows developing control of academic style and tone. | Includes personal opinions, reactions, or judgments (e.g., “I liked...”); style and tone are overly conversational or inconsistent with summary writing. |
|
Organization & Transitions
CT: W.6.2a, c, f; W.6.4
CELP: 6-8.9
| Introduces the text and central idea smoothly; ideas are logically sequenced using varied transitional words/phrases to show relationships, ending with a strong concluding statement. | Introduces the text and topic clearly; organizes key ideas in a logical order using appropriate transitions and provides a clear concluding statement. | Attempts to introduce the topic; sequence is somewhat uneven or list-like, relying on basic linking words (e.g., and, then, also); conclusion is weak or missing. | Lacks a clear introduction or logical sequence; ideas appear disconnected with few or no transitions; no concluding statement is provided. |
|
Paraphrasing, Vocabulary & Conventions
CT: W.6.2d, L.6.1, L.6.2
CELP: 6-8.3, 6-8.10
| Concise and written in the student’s own words; uses precise academic and domain-specific vocabulary with varied sentence structures (simple, compound, complex) and virtually no grammar or mechanics errors. | Paraphrases ideas in the student’s own words; uses grade-appropriate academic vocabulary, varied sentences, and standard English conventions with only minor errors that do not impede meaning. | Relies heavily on wording copied from the source text; uses basic vocabulary and mostly simple or compound sentences; convention errors occasionally distract the reader. | Copies phrases directly or is too brief/incomplete; uses a narrow range of vocabulary and simple sentences; frequent grammar, spelling, or punctuation errors impede meaning. |
Central Idea ___ / 4
Objectivity ___ / 4
Organization ___ / 4
Conventions ___ / 4
Total ___ / 16
English Learner Support & Standards Reference
Grades 6–8 CELP Standards Alignment
CT Core & CELP Crosswalk
Use the Connecticut English Language Proficiency (CELP) descriptors below to set appropriate scaffolds and language targets for Multilingual Learners writing 6th grade summaries alongside the 4-point rubric.
| CELP Standard |
Level 1 |
Level 2 |
Level 3 |
Level 4 |
Level 5 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| CELP 6-8.1 |
|
|
|
|
|
Construct meaning from text
| With prompting/supports, identify a few key words and phrases in simple texts. | With prompting/supports, identify the main topic and retell a few key details. | With guidance/supports, determine central idea/theme, explain details, and summarize part of the text. | Determine two or more central ideas/themes, explain supporting details, and summarize a text. | Use a wide range of strategies to determine central ideas/themes, explain development, and summarize a text. |
|
CELP 6-8.3
Write about complex texts
| With prompting/supports, communicate basic info using words/phrases from reading. | Compose short informational texts using academic/domain vocabulary and key details. | With guidance/supports, compose informational texts with academic vocabulary and general/specific details. | Compose informational texts including relevant general/specific details and academic/domain vocabulary. | Compose informational texts with relevant details/examples to fully develop a topic using academic vocabulary. |
|
CELP 6-8.7
Adapt language to task & audience
| With prompting/supports, use frequently occurring words and phrases. | Adapt language choices to task/audience; begin using general academic/content words. | Adapt style to purpose, task, and audience; show developing control of style and tone. | Use wide range of academic/content vocabulary; maintain consistent style/tone throughout most of text. | Use complex academic/content vocabulary to precisely express ideas; maintain appropriate, consistent style/tone. |
|
CELP 6-8.9
Create clear & coherent text
| Communicate basic info using narrow vocabulary and syntactically simple sentences. | Introduce topic, present 1–2 facts, use common linking words (next, because, and, also), and conclude. | Introduce/develop topic with a few facts/details, use common transitions (for example, as a result), and conclude. | Introduce/develop topic with facts/details, use varied transitions (however, on the other hand), and conclude. | Effectively develop topic with facts/details, use varied transitions showing logical relationships, and conclude. |
|
CELP 6-8.10
Use Standard English accurately
| Recognize and use a small number of frequently occurring nouns, noun phrases, and verbs. | Use frequently occurring nouns, pronouns, verbs, prepositions, adjectives, adverbs; simple/compound sentences. | Use relative pronouns/adverbs, subordinating conjunctions, prepositional phrases; expand simple, compound, complex sentences. | Use intensive/reflexive pronouns, active/passive voice, correct most modifiers; expand simple, compound, complex sentences. | Place phrases/clauses accurately, correct misplaced/dangling modifiers, and expand simple, compound, complex sentences. |
Connecticut Core Standards (Grade 6)
- RL.6.2 / RI.6.2: Determine a theme or central idea of a text and how it is conveyed through particular details; provide a summary of the text distinct from personal opinions or judgments.
- W.6.2 (a, c, d, e, f): Write informative/explanatory texts to examine a topic and convey ideas through selection, organization, and analysis of relevant content (transitions, precise vocabulary, formal style, concluding statement).
- W.6.4: Produce clear and coherent writing in which the development, organization, and style are appropriate to task, purpose, and audience.
- L.6.1 & L.6.2: Demonstrate command of the conventions of standard English grammar, usage, capitalization, punctuation, and spelling when writing.
Teacher Feedback & Next Steps
Student CELP Level (if applicable):
Annotated Exemplars • Savvas Unit 2 Mentor Text
Sample Summaries: “Reading Buddies”
Levels 4 – 1
Score 4 — Exceeds Standard RI.6.2 • W.6.2 • CELP 6-8.1 / 6-8.9 (Level 5)
In the informational essay “Reading Buddies,” the author explains how reading-companion programs use trained dogs to help struggling readers build confidence while also benefiting shelter animals. Beginning in Utah in 1999, programs pairing dogs and handlers with students in schools and libraries have expanded nationwide. Because struggling readers often feel anxious reading aloud to people, dogs provide a patient, judgment-free audience that lets children read at their own pace and self-correct mistakes. Furthermore, shelter programs such as the Arizona Animal Welfare League have volunteers read to dogs and cats awaiting adoption, helping the animals become calmer and more well-adjusted around people. Ultimately, these programs show how humans and animals mutually support one another in overcoming challenges.
Rubric Rationale: Synthesizes both parts of the central idea (helping kids & shelter animals) concisely in the student’s own words; objective, formal tone; varied transitions (Beginning in, Because, Furthermore, Ultimately) and complex sentence structures.
Score 3 — Meets Standard RI.6.2 • W.6.2 • CELP 6-8.1 / 6-8.9 (Level 4)
The article “Reading Buddies” explains how schools and libraries use trained dogs to help children improve their reading skills and confidence. Many kids have trouble reading and feel nervous about making mistakes in front of people. However, dogs do not judge or interrupt, so students can practice at their own pace, like a shy 10-year-old girl who finally finished a whole book. In addition, volunteers at animal shelters read to dogs and cats to help them stay calm and prepare for adoption. Overall, reading together helps both people and animals.
Rubric Rationale: Clearly states the central idea and key supporting details; maintains an objective tone; logical sequence with clear transitions (However, In addition, Overall) and a concluding statement; minor reliance on a single example.
Score 2 — Approaching Standard RI.6.2 • W.6.2 • CELP 6-8.1 / 6-8.9 (Level 2–3)
“Reading Buddies” is about a third-grade boy who reads to a five-year-old border collie named Theo in his school library. The program started in Utah in 1999, and now there are over 2,300 dogs. Dogs are good listeners because they don’t laugh at you or stop you when you pronounce something wrong. Also, a 10-year-old girl read a whole book. I think reading to dogs sounds like a really fun idea for kids who are shy.
Rubric Rationale: Focuses on isolated details (Theo, 1999, 2,300 dogs) rather than the full central idea and omits shelter animals; includes a personal opinion (“I think...”); relies on basic linking words (and, Also) and some copied phrasing.
Score 1 — Beginning RI.6.2 • L.6.1 • CELP 6-8.1 / 6-8.10 (Level 1–2)
A boy is petting a dog named Theo in the library. Reading is boring for some kids and they don’t like making mistakes. I really like border collies because they are cute and nice. They help kids read books and shelter cats too.
Rubric Rationale: Does not state the central idea; lists disconnected details; includes personal opinions/feelings; lacks transitions or a conclusion; uses simple sentences and informal language.