Omelas Illusion Graphic Organizer
7TH GRADE LITERATURE LAB
The Price of Perfection
Analyzing the Dark Secret of "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas"
STUDENT WORKBOOK
ACTIVITY FILE 1
Student Name
Date
Class Period
01
The Dark Truth Under the City
The Story's Big Twist: After showing us a beautiful, happy city, Le Guin takes us down into the dark basement. She reveals that all the happiness, beautiful music, and lovely weather of Omelas depend entirely on one terrible thing: a single, innocent child must live in continuous misery, dirt, and fear.
"The floor is dirt, a little damp to the touch"(24) How does the description of the dirty, dark room contrast (differ) with the bright summer festival? Why did the author make this contrast so strong? What do you call a contrast of two opposite situations that are being described?"
02
Analyzing "The Bargain"
The citizens of Omelas live under a strict set of rules. Read the quotes from the text, then explain them in your own words.
The Cruel Terms
"...if the child were brought up into the light... in that hour all the prosperity and beauty and delight of Omelas would wither and be destroyed (25)
What does this mean in plain English?
No Kind Words Allowed
"But as time goes on they begin to realize that evenif the chiuld could be released, it would not get much good of it't freedom"(25)
Why are they forbidden to even say "sorry"?
03
Making Excuses for the Child's Pain
"But as time goes on they begin to realize that evenif the chiuld could be released, it would not get much good of it't freedom"(25) When young people first learn about the child, they cry and feel angry. But as they grow up, they learn to accept the situation. They tell themselves that the child is "too broken" to enjoy freedom anyway, or that thousands of happy lives are worth more than one sad one.
If you lived in Omelas, would you be able to believe these excuses and remain happy? Explain your thinking.
THE PRICE OF PERFECTION — LEVEL: 7TH GRADE PAGE 1 OF 2
7TH GRADE LITERATURE LAB
The Two Paths
ACTIVITY FILE 2
04
The Scale: Weighing the Dilemma
Imagine you are a citizen of Omelas who has just visited the basement. Fill out the advantages and disadvantages of each path below.
Path A: Stay in Omelas
Accepting the deal to keep your luxurious, happy life.
What do you gain? What do you lose?
Path B: Walk Away
Leaving your home, family, and comfort for the unknown.
What do you gain? What do you lose?
05
Leaving the City Behind
The Climax: The Silent Departures
"Sometimes a young man or woman goes to see the child and does not go home to weep or rage... They walk straight out of Omelas, out through the beautiful gates... They leave Omelas, they walk ahead into the darkness, and they do not come back."
06
Your Moral Compass
Where do you think those who leave Omelas are going? Why is it powerful that they walk away *alone* rather than starting a revolution?
THE PRICE OF PERFECTION — LEVEL: 7TH GRADE PAGE 2 OF 2