Cookie Caper Casefile Worksheet
Official Detective Casefile
THE GREAT COOKIE CAPER
CASE: #2026-CHOCO
STATUS: UNSOLVED
Lead Detective:
Date:
Crime Scene Photo: Kitchen Counter
Examine the markers!
A
B
C
Cookies
Prime Suspect Dossiers
👧
Bella (Sister)
Age 11
Alibi: Reading in her room.
Traits: Wears blue hair clips. Dislikes chocolate cookies; prefers vanilla.
STATUS: CLEARED?
👦
Pip (Brother)
Age 6
Alibi: Playing in his tent.
Traits: Loves chocolate. Wears a red-and-white striped t-shirt. Height: 3.5 feet.
STATUS: INTEREST
🐶
Buster (Dog)
Age 4
Alibi: Sleeping in his bed.
Traits: Always hungry. Has muddy paws. Cannot reach the high kitchen counter.
STATUS: SUSPICIOUS
Step 1: Evaluate the Evidence
Not all clues matter! Identify which clues are helpful proof, and which are "red herrings" (distractions).
EVID. A Blue Hair Clip
Found on the kitchen floor. Bella wears hair clips, but she dislikes chocolate cookies entirely.
EVID. B Muddy Paw Prints
Found on the kitchen floor. Buster has muddy paws, but he cannot reach the high counter.
EVID. C Striped Fabric Scrap
Snagged right on the spilled cookie jar rim. Pip wears a matching red-and-white striped t-shirt.
🕵️ Who Ate the Cookies?
Bella Pip Buster
🎯 Circle/Check the STRONGEST Clue:
Evidence A Evidence B Evidence C
✍️ Explain Your Detective Logic:
Why is your chosen clue the strongest, and why are the other clues weak red herrings?