Blackrock Signal Worksheet
Reading & Writing
Name: __________________________ Date: ______________
The Signal at Blackrock Point
Read the story carefully. Use the paragraph numbers to help you find answers.
[1] Every night at sunset, Maya walked up the tall stairs of the lighthouse with her Grandpa Sam. For many years, Grandpa Sam cleaned the big glass lamp. Its bright beam shone far out over the dark sea. The fishing boats trusted that light to stay safe.
[2] One day, the town leaders held a big meeting. Ms. Lee held up a new solar lamp. She said a person in the tower was useless now. "A machine never gets tired," Ms. Lee said. "It costs less money, and it can do the job all by itself."
[3] Grandpa Sam sat quietly, but Maya felt sad and upset. She knew machines could not see everything. Last winter, thick fog hid the harbor. Grandpa Sam heard a boat horn in trouble and flashed the big lamp to guide the boat home.
[4] That night, a big storm hit the town. Hard rain hit the windows, and strong wind blew across the water. Down by the rocks, the town’s new machine light blinked once and went dark. The cold waves had broken it.
[5] "Look out there!" Grandpa Sam called. Through the rain, a small white boat was drifting close to the sharp rocks. Its radio was broken. Without a light, the boat could crash.
[6] Grandpa Sam and Maya ran to the big brass lamp. Together, they pulled the handle three times to flash a warning. Flash! Flash! Flash! Seconds later, the little boat turned away from the rocks and sailed safely into the harbor.
[7] In the morning, the storm was over. When Ms. Lee came to the lighthouse door, Maya showed her the storm notes. "Machines are neat," Maya said. "They can shine a light. But they cannot listen for a boat in trouble, and they do not care who gets home safe."
Part 1: Reading Questions
Circle the best answer for each question.
1. In paragraph [2], what does the word useless mean?
A. very loud
B. not needed anymore
C. too heavy to lift
D. brand new
2. Which sentence from paragraph [2] best helps you know what useless means?
A. "One day, the town leaders held a big meeting."
B. "Ms. Lee held up a new solar lamp."
C. "It costs less money, and it can do the job all by itself."
D. "She said a person in the tower was useless now."
3. What is the main problem in the story?
A. Maya is afraid to climb the tall lighthouse stairs at night.
B. Town leaders want a machine to replace Grandpa Sam, even though people still need him.
C. Grandpa Sam forgets how to clean the big glass lamp.
D. Ms. Lee will not let the fishing boats come into the harbor.
4. Which detail from the story best shows this main problem?
A. The fishing boats trusted the bright beam over the dark sea.
B. Ms. Lee says a machine can work alone, while Maya knows Grandpa Sam saves boats in storms.
C. Hard rain hit the windows and strong wind blew across the water.
D. In the morning, the storm was over and the sky cleared.
5. What is the big lesson of this story?
A. Machines are always better than people at every job.
B. Fishing boats should never go out on the water.
C. Caring people can do important things that machines cannot do.
D. Storms always break new machines at night.
6. Which sentence from the story best shows this lesson?
A. "Every night at sunset, Maya walked up the tall stairs of the lighthouse."
B. "That night, a big storm hit the town."
C. "But they cannot listen for a boat in trouble, and they do not care who gets home safe."
D. "When Ms. Lee came to the lighthouse door, Maya showed her the storm notes."
Part 2: Write Your Opinion
Use complete sentences and story details.
Writing Prompt
Should the town keep Grandpa Sam as the lighthouse helper, or use only the new machine? Write your opinion and give two details from the story to prove why you are right.
Blackrock Signal Answer Key
Teacher Resource · Grade 2
Answer Key: The Signal at Blackrock Point
MCQs 1–6
1. Vocabulary in Context (VIC) Answer: B
Rationale: "Not needed anymore" matches Ms. Lee’s claim that a new solar lamp can replace a person in the tower.
2. Best Evidence for Question 1 Answer: C
Rationale: Saying the machine "can do the job all by itself" directly explains why Ms. Lee thinks a human helper is useless (not needed).
3. Central Conflict Answer: B
Rationale: The main problem is the disagreement between town leaders who want a machine and Maya/Grandpa Sam who know people still need a human helper.
4. Best Evidence for Question 3 Answer: B
Rationale: Option B shows both sides of the problem—Ms. Lee wanting a machine to work alone versus Maya knowing Grandpa Sam saves boats.
5. Theme Answer: C
Rationale: When the new machine breaks in the storm, Grandpa Sam and Maya save the boat, showing that caring people do things machines cannot.
6. Best Evidence for Question 5 Answer: C
Rationale: Maya’s closing words in paragraph [7] state the story’s big lesson: machines cannot listen or care like people do.
Part 2: Opinion Writing Guide & Rubric
Both opinions are valid if supported by 2+ story details.
Side A: Keep Grandpa Sam
- The new machine light broke in the storm ([4]).
- Grandpa Sam and Maya flashed the lamp to save the white boat ([6]).
- Last winter, Grandpa Sam heard a boat horn in the fog and guided it home ([3]).
Side B: Use the New Machine
- A machine never gets tired ([2]).
- It costs the town less money ([2]).
- It can do the job by itself on normal nights ([2]).
| Criteria |
3 – Proficient |
2 – Developing |
1 – Emerging |
| Opinion |
Clearly states whether to keep Grandpa Sam or use the machine. |
States an opinion, but it is a little unclear. |
Does not state an opinion. |
| Story Details (2+) |
Gives 2+ accurate details from the story to support the opinion. |
Gives 1 story detail or 2 vague details. |
Gives no details from the story. |
| Explanation |
Explains how the details prove the opinion is right. |
Gives a short or partial explanation. |
Does not explain the details. |
Sample 2nd-Grade Response (Side A)
I think the town should keep Grandpa Sam as the lighthouse helper. First, in paragraph [4], the town’s new machine light blinked once and broke in the storm. This shows that machines can stop working when the weather is bad. Second, in paragraph [6], Grandpa Sam and Maya flashed the big lamp three times to save a little boat from the sharp rocks. A machine could not see the boat in trouble. That is why the town still needs Grandpa Sam!
Blackrock Signal Slides
Grade 2 Reading & Writing
Lanterns of Blackrock
Reading "The Signal at Blackrock Point" to find word clues, the main problem, the big lesson, and story details!
Warm-Up · 5 Minutes
People vs. Machines
"Can a machine do every job, or do we still need people to help?"
Turn and tell a partner what you think!
Word Detective
Using Context Clues
1. Read Around
Look at the sentences right before and after the new word.
2. Find Clues
Ask: What is happening here? What clues does the author give?
3. Try It Out
Put your meaning into the sentence to see if it makes sense.
Prove It!
Finding the Best Evidence
Questions 1, 3, and 5 ask what a word means, the main problem, or the big lesson.
Questions 2, 4, and 6 ask you to prove your answer with a sentence from the story.
Check yourself: Does this sentence really prove my answer above?
Story Elements
Main Problem vs. Big Lesson
Main Problem
What goes wrong or what the characters are arguing about in the story.
Big Lesson
The important message we can learn for our own lives.
Class Activity · 10 Minutes
Town Meeting: Clue Hunt
Step 1: Work with a partner to find 2 story clues for each side.
Step 2: Share your favorite clue out loud with the class.
Step 3: Write your own opinion sentence at the bottom of your sheet!
Part 2 · Write Your Opinion
Time to Write!
Should the town keep Grandpa Sam as the lighthouse helper, or use only the new machine?
• Tell your opinion clearly.
• Give two details from the story to prove you are right.
• Use complete sentences with capital letters and periods.