Proof Pro Slides
Proof Pros
Mastering Evidence in Functional Texts
What is Evidence?
The "What"
Evidence is information from a text that proves your point or supports your argument.
The "Where"
In functional texts, evidence can be found in rules, instructions, or descriptions.
The Proof Pro Process
1
Identify
Find the specific sentences that support your claim.
2
Cite
Write the evidence exactly as it appears in the text.
3
Explain
Tell the reader how this evidence proves your point.
Example: Gym Rules
"All members must wipe down machines after use to prevent the spread of germs. Proper athletic shoes are required at all times for safety."
Claim: The gym cares about cleanliness.
Evidence: "All members must wipe down machines after use."
Explanation: This shows they want the equipment to stay sanitized for the next person.
Your Turn!
Grab your worksheet and let's find some proof.
Evidence Expert Worksheet
Evidence Expert
Functional Text Analysis Portfolio
Name:
Date:
Read the handbook snippet. Cite exact evidence to support the argument and explain how it proves the point.
Document: Employee Handbook - Kitchen Safety
Section 4.2: Handling Equipment
-
All staff members must wear non-slip shoes while working in the kitchen to prevent falls on wet floors.
-
Before using the industrial meat slicer, employees must complete a mandatory 30-minute safety training and wear cut-resistant gloves.
-
Wet floor signs should be placed immediately after a spill is noticed, even if you are about to clean it up.
-
Hairnets and gloves are required at all times when handling open food containers to ensure customer health and safety.
Argument: The kitchen manager prioritizes the physical safety of the employees.
Evidence Item #1 (Direct Quote)
Explanation (How does this prove employee safety?)
Evidence Item #2 (Direct Quote)
Explanation (How does this prove employee safety?)
Evidence Expert Answer Key
Answer Key
Teacher Resource: Evidence Expert
TEACHER USE ONLY
Text Quick-Look: Kitchen Safety
-
Non-slip shoes (prevent falls)
-
Slicer training + cut-resistant gloves
-
Wet floor signs (immediate placement)
-
Hairnets/gloves (customer focus)
Target Argument:
The kitchen manager prioritizes the physical safety of the employees.
Sample Evidence Option A
CITED EVIDENCE:
"All staff members must wear non-slip shoes while working in the kitchen to prevent falls on wet floors."
EXPLANATION:
This shows the manager wants to prevent workers from slipping and getting hurt, which is a physical safety concern.
Sample Evidence Option B
CITED EVIDENCE:
"Before using the industrial meat slicer, employees must complete a mandatory 30-minute safety training and wear cut-resistant gloves."
EXPLANATION:
The training and protective gear are specific measures taken to ensure that employees don't cut themselves while using dangerous machinery.
Heads Up: Incorrect Evidence
Avoid: "Hairnets and gloves... to ensure customer health and safety." This supports customer safety, not employee safety.
