Quality Claims Teacher Guide 1.1 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1
Quality Claims Teacher Guide
Intro Script • Question of the Day • Gradual Release (I Do • We Do • You Do)
ELPA21 Level 3 HS
Lesson 1.1 Objective & Gradual Release: 45-Min (I Do • We Do • You Do)
"I can develop a clear claim that answers a question and can be supported by information from a text."
Welcome, Intro Script & Question of the Day (3 Min) Slide 2
Intro Script (Read Aloud): "Welcome to Day 1 of Writing 2! Over the next five weeks, we are going to level up your argumentative writing using Claim-Evidence-Reasoning (CER). Today, we start with the foundation: what makes a Claim actually strong. You will learn our 3-part Quality Claim Checklist, sort strong versus weak claims with a partner, and practice fixing weak claims."
💬 Question of the Day (On Slide 2): "If you could add one brand-new class or club to our school tomorrow, what would it be—and why?"
1
Teaching Part 1: What Makes a Quality Claim & The Checklist (10 Min)
I DO • Teacher Model
Step 1 (Introduce the 3 Pillars): Direct students to the three anchor boxes on Page 1: "A quality claim has three core pillars: Clear (directly answers the prompt question in a full sentence), Focused (takes one specific stance rather than wandering), and Supported by Text (can be proven using real reading facts)."
Step 2 (Introduce & Model the Quality Claim Checklist): Draw attention to the yellow checklist box and distribute the CER Quality Reference Sheet : "We do not guess whether a claim is good—we test it against our 3-point checklist (also saved in Section 1 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet for all 5 weeks!). A quality claim must earn all three checkmarks ."
📌 Reference Sheet Tip: Have students keep their CER Quality Reference Sheet on their desks during Parts 2, 3, and 5 so they can practice using Section 1's checklist and claim stems.
2
Teaching Part 2: Checklist Application & Decision Task (10 Min)
I DO (Prompt 1) WE DO (Prompt 2)
Model Prompt 1 aloud (I Do), then release students to test Prompt 2 in pairs (We Do) using their checklists:
Prompt 1 (I DO — Teacher Think-Aloud): Financial Literacy Courses
• Weak: "Financial classes are good because they are important to have." — Fails Focused & Text-Supported (circular).
• Strong: "High schools should require financial literacy courses to teach teenagers budgeting and prevent debt." — Passes all 3 checks!
Prompt 2 (WE DO — Partner Checklist Task & Debrief Key):
• Claim A (Weak): "Plastic water bottles are things students drink out of at school." — Fails Item 1 (definition only; takes no stance).
• Claim B (Strong Quality): "School districts should prohibit single-use plastic bottles to reduce campus landfill waste." — Passes all 3 items.
• Decision: Claim B is better because Claim A merely defines water bottles with no arguable position.
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1 Teacher Guide Page 1 of 2
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1
Sorting & Claim Improvement Facilitation
Step-by-Step Instructions for Parts 3 & 4 (We Do) and Parts 5 & 6 (You Do)
Lesson 1.1 Guide • Page 2 of 2
3
Teaching Parts 3 & 4: Claim Sorting & Criteria Discussion (12 Min)
WE DO • Guided Practice
Part 3 Sorting Master Key (Checklist Applied):
✓ Effective Quality Claims: [A], [C], [E]
Pass all 3 checklist items: clear answer, focused stance, and supportable by facts.
❌ Ineffective Claims: [B], [D], [F]
[B] fails text-supported (personal hobby), [D] fails clear stance (definition only), [F] fails focus & support (vague slang).
Part 4 Discussion Talking Points:
• Why Focused? Broad claims make writing wander. A focused claim allows the student to prove one specific point in one CER paragraph.
• Why Supported by Text? In high school writing, arguments must rely on evidence, not personal assumptions.
4
Teaching Parts 5 & 6: Diagnosing Missing Elements & Rewriting (10 Min)
YOU DO • Independent
Key Instructional Shift: Students work independently to complete Step 1 (Diagnose what is missing) using their checklist before rewriting in Step 2 . Direct them to Section 1 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet for claim sentence stems:
Part 5 Master Diagnostic & Revision Key:
• Prompt 1 (Breakfast):
Step 1 Missing: Stance/answer missing; only states a definition of breakfast.
Step 2 Exemplar: "High schools should provide free breakfast to all students to reduce morning hunger and boost academic focus."
• Prompt 2 (Weekend Homework):
Step 1 Missing: Formal academic stance and focused reason missing; only gives informal opinion ("bad/boring").
Step 2 Exemplar: "School districts should establish a ban on weekend homework because two days of rest prevents academic burnout."
• Prompt 3 (Youth Sports Centers):
Step 1 Missing: Incomplete sentence; lacks specific stance or supportable reason (only says "yes/good").
Step 2 Exemplar: "Cities should fund youth sports centers to provide teenagers safe, supervised recreation after school."
Part 6 Expansion Exemplar:
"High school districts should provide universal free breakfast in hallways, for example serving fruit and oatmeal carts before first period so students avoid hunger headaches during algebra."
Lesson 1.1 Formative Checkpoints: Exit Assessment
Exceeds Accurately applies all 3 checklist items; correctly diagnoses what is missing in weak claims; writes clear, focused, text-supportable revisions.
Proficient Uses checklist to sort at least 5 claims; correctly identifies missing elements; improves weak claims with clear stances.
Developing Struggles to diagnose why definitions are not claims; writes vague revisions; needs teacher re-teaching on checklist criteria.
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1 Teacher Guide Page 2 of 2
Quality Claims Activity Sheet 1.1 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1
Quality Claims Activity Sheet
Creating a Quality Claim • Analyzing Strong vs. Weak Claims
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Learning Target:
"I can develop a clear claim that answers a question and can be supported by information from a text."
Part 1: What Makes a Quality Claim?
📌 CER Reference Sheet (Section 1) I DO
1. Clear
Directly answers the prompt question in a complete sentence.
• Never just says "yes" or "no".
• Restates the main topic.
Rule: Easy to understand instantly.
2. Focused
Takes a specific stance on one central idea rather than being too broad.
• Avoids off-topic tangents.
• Narrows the argument down.
Rule: One specific position only.
3. Supported by Text
Can be proven using real facts, data, or details in the reading passage.
• Not just personal feeling.
• Text has evidence to back it.
Rule: Backed by reading facts.
Quality Claim Checklist (Use Against Any Claim) 3 of 3 Required
Before accepting any claim as "quality," test it against these three essential criteria:
✓ Clear Answer
Does it directly answer the prompt in a complete sentence (not just "yes/no" or a topic name)?
✓ Focused Stance
Does it take a clear, arguable side on one specific issue (not broad, rambling, or circular)?
✓ Text-Supported
Can it be proven with facts, data, or quotes from a text (not just personal feelings or slang)?
Part 2: Analyze Strong and Weak Claim Examples
I DO WE DO
Test candidate claims using your Part 1 checklist to evaluate quality and decide which is better:
Prompt 1 (Teacher Model): "Should high schools offer financial literacy courses?" I DO
Weak Claim (Vague / Circular):
"Financial classes are good because they are important to have."
❌ Checklist: Fails Focused & Text-Supported (repeats "good").
Strong Quality Claim:
"High schools should require financial literacy courses to teach teenagers budgeting and prevent debt."
✓ Checklist: Passes Clear, Focused, and Text-Supported!
Prompt 2 (Partner Check): "Should school districts ban single-use plastic bottles?" WE DO
Check each claim below against your Part 1 checklist. Determine each claim's strength, then decide which one is better:
Candidate Claim A:
"Plastic water bottles are things students drink out of at school."
Test with Checklist: Clear Answer Focused Stance Text-Supported
Strength: Strong Quality Weak Claim
Candidate Claim B:
"School districts should prohibit single-use plastic bottles to reduce campus landfill waste."
Test with Checklist: Clear Answer Focused Stance Text-Supported
Strength: Strong Quality Weak Claim
Which claim is better? Claim A Claim B | Why:
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1 Page 1 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1
Claim Sorting & Analysis
Evaluating Effective vs. Ineffective Claims • Criteria Discussion
Lesson 1.1 • Page 2 of 3
Part 3: Sort Claims into Effective and Ineffective
WE DO • Guided Practice
Use your Part 1 Checklist (or Section 1 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet) to evaluate each statement. Write the letter of each claim into the correct sorting box:
[A] "Schools should fund campus garden clubs because gardening increases vegetable consumption."
[B] "I like playing soccer after school with my neighborhood friends on Tuesdays."
[C] "High school classes should start at 8:30 a.m. because extra sleep improves student focus."
[D] "Homework is schoolwork that teachers give students to do at home."
[E] "Cities should provide free bus passes because reliable transit ensures equal attendance."
[F] "Cell phones are cool and everyone has one."
Effective Quality Claims (Passed All 3 Checklist Items):
Letters of Effective Claims: ___________________________
Why they work: They state a clear position that answers a question and can be proven with facts.
Ineffective Claims (Failed 1 or More Checklist Items):
Letters of Ineffective Claims: ___________________________
Why they fail: They are definitions, random personal opinions, or too vague to prove.
Part 4: Discuss What Makes a Claim Clear, Focused & Supported
WE DO
Discuss these questions with your partner using your checklist. Write 1 key idea for each question below:
1. Why must a quality claim be FOCUSED instead of broad or vague?
2. Why does a claim need to be SUPPORTED BY THE TEXT rather than just personal feeling?
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1 Page 2 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1
Improving Weak Claims & Expansion
Diagnosing Missing Elements First • Rewriting into Quality Claims
Lesson 1.1 • Page 3 of 3
Part 5: Practice Improving Weak Claims
📌 Section 1 Stems YOU DO
For each weak claim below, first identify what is missing using your Part 1 checklist. Then, rewrite it into a complete, quality claim using sentence stems from your CER Quality Reference Sheet (Section 1) !
Prompt: "Should high schools provide free breakfast to every student?" Weak Statement
Weak: "Breakfast is food that students eat in the morning."
Step 1 — Identify what is missing (check all that apply):
Missing clear stance/answer Missing specific focus Only states a definition
Explain what is missing:
Step 2 — Rewrite into an Improved Quality Claim:
Prompt: "Should districts establish a ban on weekend homework?" Weak Statement
Weak: "Homework is bad because it is boring."
Step 1 — Identify what is missing (check all that apply):
Missing formal academic stance Missing focused reason Only gives personal feeling
Explain what is missing:
Step 2 — Rewrite into an Improved Quality Claim:
Prompt: "Should cities fund youth sports centers?" Weak Statement
Weak: "Yes, sports centers are good."
Step 1 — Identify what is missing (check all that apply):
Missing complete sentence/stance Missing supportable proof Too vague (says only "good")
Explain what is missing:
Step 2 — Rewrite into an Improved Quality Claim:
Part 6: Sentence Expansion • Making It Interesting & Adding Examples YOU DO
Pick ONE of your improved claims from above. Expand it by adding descriptive details and a concrete, relevant real-world example:
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1 Page 3 of 3
Quality Claims Instructional Slides UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.1 Student Sheet Companion Deck
Lesson 1.1 Master Presentation
What Makes a Quality Claim?
Clear • Focused • Supported
Learning Target: "I can develop a clear claim that answers a question and can be supported by information from a text."
Part 1 (I DO) 3 Pillars & Checklist
Part 2 (I/WE) Claim Analysis
Part 3 (WE DO) Claim Sorting
Part 4 (WE DO) Discussion
Part 5–6 (YOU) Diagnose & Expand
Welcome • Today's Plan & Question of the Day Warm-Up
💬 Question of the Day:
"If you could add one brand-new class or club to our school tomorrow, what would it be—and why?"
Coming Up Today:
• Learn the 3 Pillars & Quality Claim Checklist (Part 1)
• Test strong vs. weak claims and sort 6 real examples (Parts 2–4)
• Diagnose what's missing in weak claims, rewrite them, and expand one (Parts 5–6)
Share your answer with a partner before we dive into Part 1!
Part 1: What Makes a Quality Claim?
I DO Page 1
1. Clear
Directly answers the prompt in a complete sentence.
2. Focused
Takes one specific position; avoids broad tangents.
3. Supported
Can be backed up using real facts in the text.
📋 Quality Claim Checklist (Section 1 of Reference Sheet) All 3 Required
☑ 1. Clear Answer? Does it answer the prompt directly? (Not just "yes/no")
☑ 2. Focused Stance? Does it take one specific, arguable side?
☑ 3. Text-Supported? Can reading facts prove it? (Not just personal feeling)
Keep Section 1 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet on your desk!
Part 2: Testing Claims with the Checklist
I DO WE DO
Prompt 1 (I DO — Teacher Model): Financial Literacy Courses
"Financial classes are good because they are important to have." ❌ Fails Focused & Supported (circular)
"High schools should require financial literacy courses to teach teenagers budgeting and prevent debt." ✓ Passes all 3 checklist tests!
Prompt 2 (WE DO — Partner Check): "Should school districts ban single-use plastic bottles?"
Candidate Claim A: "Plastic water bottles are things students drink out of at school."
Candidate Claim B: "School districts should prohibit single-use plastic bottles to reduce campus landfill waste."
Test Claim A and Claim B against your checklist on Page 1 and decide which is better!
Part 3: Sort Claims • Effective vs. Ineffective
WE DO Page 2
[A] "Schools should fund campus garden clubs because gardening increases vegetable consumption."
[B] "I like playing soccer after school with my neighborhood friends on Tuesdays."
[C] "High school classes should start at 8:30 a.m. because extra sleep improves student focus."
[D] "Homework is schoolwork that teachers give students to do at home."
[E] "Cities should provide free bus passes because reliable transit ensures equal attendance."
[F] "Cell phones are cool and everyone has one."
Test each claim against Section 1 of your Reference Sheet and sort [A]–[F] on Page 2!
Part 4: Discuss What Makes a Claim Work
WE DO Page 2
Question 1:
Why must a quality claim be FOCUSED instead of broad or vague?
Question 2:
Why does a claim need to be SUPPORTED BY THE TEXT rather than just personal feeling?
Discuss with your partner and write 1 key takeaway for each question on Page 2!
Part 5: 2-Step Protocol • Diagnose First, Then Rewrite
YOU DO Page 3
1. "Breakfast is food that students eat in the morning." Step 1: What is missing? → Step 2: Rewrite into a quality claim.
2. "Homework is bad because it is boring." Step 1: What is missing? → Step 2: Rewrite into a quality claim.
3. "Yes, sports centers are good." Step 1: What is missing? → Step 2: Rewrite into a quality claim.
Identify what is missing first, then use Section 1 stems on your Reference Sheet to rewrite!
Part 6: Sentence Expansion • Making It Interesting
YOU DO Page 3
Expansion Challenge: Pick ONE of your improved claims from Part 5. Expand it by adding descriptive details and a concrete, relevant real-world example!
Check: Did you add specific details? Did you include "for example" or "such as" ?
Next: Lesson 1.2 will focus on writing claims directly from short reading texts!
Curriculum Overview Teacher Guide UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Curriculum Overview
Curriculum Overview & Pacing Guide
5-Week Instructional Scope & Sequence • Calibrated for ELPA21 Level 3 High School English Learners
Teacher Resource
5-Week Instructional Progression (2 Lessons Per Week • 10 Lessons Total): CER Mastery Roadmap
This Tier 3 writing intervention moves intentionally through five developmental stages: creating quality claims , selecting quality evidence , understanding reasoning (major focus) , developing and strengthening reasoning , and independent synthesis .
1 Week 1: Creating a Quality Claim Clear • Focused • Supported
Target: "I can develop a clear claim that answers a question and can be supported by information from a text."
Lesson 1: What Makes a Quality Claim?
• Analyze strong vs. weak claims; sort effective vs. ineffective.
• Discuss criteria; practice improving weak claims.
Lesson 2: Writing a Claim from a Text (6 Pts)
• Read short text; compare multiple possible claims.
• Select strongest claim and justify why; independent write.
2 Week 2: Selecting Quality Evidence Relevant • Specific • Text-Based
Target: "I can select relevant evidence from a text that supports my claim."
Lesson 3: What Makes Evidence Strong?
• Analyze strong, weak, and unrelated evidence.
• Determine which evidence best supports claims.
Lesson 4: Matching Evidence to a Claim (8 Pts)
• Read text, develop claim, evaluate 2–3 evidence options.
• Write claim and include strongest evidence with tag.
3 Week 3: Understanding Reasoning (Major Focus Begins) The Connective Engine
Target: "I can explain how and why my evidence supports my claim."
Lesson 5: What is Reasoning?
• Review claim & evidence; introduce reasoning bridge.
• Compare 3 tiers: no reasoning / echoes / explains.
Lesson 6: How Does Evidence Support Claims? (8 Pts)
• 3 Think-Aloud questions: What? Why? How?
• Dual-evidence reasoning assessment on shade trees.
4 Week 4: Developing and Strengthening Reasoning Audit & Repair Writing
Target: "I can develop reasoning that clearly explains the connection between my evidence and claim."
Lesson 7: Moving Beyond Repeating Evidence
• Compare repeating vs. explaining; identify missing links.
• Model expanding basic statements; revise weak reasoning.
Lesson 8: Evaluating & Improving Reasoning (8 Pts)
• Rank 4 CER responses from weakest to strongest.
• Diagnose 4 flaws; revise weak CER with justification.
5 Week 5: Independent Application & CER Capstone Complete Synthesis
Target: "I can independently construct a complete CER response with clear claim, cited evidence, and deep reasoning."
Lesson 9: Pre-Capstone Workshop & Simulation
• Unassisted prompt analysis, evidence selection & reasoning draft.
• Peer rubric review and self-correction protocols.
Lesson 10: Independent CER Capstone Assessment (9 Pts)
• Read new text, formulate claim, cite evidence & write deep reasoning.
• 9-pt comprehensive formative capstone assessment.
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Curriculum Overview & Pacing Guide Page 1 of 2
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Assessment Tracker
Lesson 2 Student Work Scoring Roster
Track and Record Student Work Scores on Lesson 2 of Each Week (Weeks 1–5 • 39 Points Total)
Period: _______ • Term: _______
Lesson 2 Student Sheet Scoring Points Breakdown: Total Intervention Sheet Points: 39 pts
Week 1 (L2): 6 pts
Task (1) • Stance (2) • Focus (2) • Text (1)
Week 2 (L4): 8 pts
Claim (2) • Evid (2) • Tag (2) • Connect (2)
Week 3 (L6): 8 pts
Evid 1 Reas (4) • Evid 2 Reas (4)
Week 4 (L8): 8 pts
Diagnose (2) • Revise (4) • Justify (2)
Week 5 (L10): 9 pts
Claim (2) • Evid (2) • Reas (3) • Concl (2)
| # | Student Name | W1 L2
( / 6) | W2 L4
( / 8) | W3 L6
( / 8) | W4 L8
( / 8) | W5 L10
( / 9) | Total
( / 39) | Status / Notes |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | | | | | | | | |
| 2 | | | | | | | | |
| 3 | | | | | | | | |
| 4 | | | | | | | | |
| 5 | | | | | | | | |
| 6 | | | | | | | | |
| 7 | | | | | | | | |
| 8 | | | | | | | | |
| 9 | | | | | | | | |
| 10 | | | | | | | | |
| 11 | | | | | | | | |
| 12 | | | | | | | | |
| 13 | | | | | | | | |
| 14 | | | | | | | | |
| 15 | | | | | | | | |
| 16 | | | | | | | | |
Performance Benchmarks (39 Pts Total): • Exceeds: 35–39 pts • Proficient: 30–34 pts • Developing: <30 pts
Target students scoring <30 pts for targeted reasoning support in Week 5
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Lesson 2 Student Work Scoring Roster Page 2 of 2
CER Quality Reference Sheet UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Student Toolkit
CER Quality Reference Sheet
Keep this sheet on your desk to test your Claims, Evidence, and Reasoning and use the sentence stems in every lesson.
Name: ___________________________
Weeks 1–5 Master Reference
1. Claim Strength Checklist (Lesson 1)
Must Earn 3 of 3
Clear Answer
Directly answers the prompt in a complete sentence (not just "yes/no" or a definition).
Focused Stance
Takes one specific, arguable side on a single issue (not broad, rambling, or circular).
Text-Supported
Can be proven with facts, data, or details from a text (not just personal feelings).
Potential Claim Sentence Stems: Avoid: "I think..." / "It is good."
• [Subject] should [action] because [specific reason]...
• In order to [outcome], [subject] ought to [action]...
• [Subject] must require / prohibit [topic] so that [benefit]...
• To prevent [problem], [subject] should [action]...
2. Finding Supporting Evidence Checklist
The 3 Evidence Tests
Relevant to Claim
Directly matches the topic and stance of my claim (actually proves my point).
Specific & Concrete
Provides exact data, numbers, statistics, or expert findings (not vague talk).
Text-Based & Cited
Can be found in the passage and is introduced with a clear attribution tag.
✓ Strong: Relevant + specific numbers or facts.
⚠ Weak: Related topic, but too vague/opinion.
❌ Unrelated: Off-topic detail proving nothing.
Potential Evidence Sentence Stems:
• According to the text, "[exact quote or fact]..."
• The author / study reports that [specific data or finding]...
• For example, paragraph [#] states that [evidence detail]...
• Data from [source] confirms that [exact number/fact]...
3. Does the Reasoning Connect to the Claim? Checklist
The Connective Bridge
Explains HOW & WHY
Explains how the evidence causes an outcome and why that proves the claim.
No Echoing (New Insight)
Adds logical explanation instead of just repeating the evidence or claim.
Bridges Back to Claim
Explicitly ties the evidence back to the claim's exact stance.
✓ Tier 3 (Mastery): Explains cause, effect, and link.
⚠ Tier 2 (Echo Trap): Repeats evidence without why.
❌ Tier 1 (Dropped Fact): Stops after quote; no reasoning.
Potential Reasoning Sentence Stems:
• This evidence proves [claim] because [how/why link]...
• This data is significant because it shows how [cause] leads to [effect]...
• In other words, when [evidence occurs], people can [claim outcome]...
• Because [evidence detail], it follows that [claim stance]...
C Claim: Clear, focused answer
E Evidence: Relevant, specific text proof
R Reasoning: Explains HOW & WHY E proves C
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Student CER Reference Sheet Page 1 of 1
Writing Claims Activity Sheet 1.2 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2
Writing Claims Activity Sheet
Writing a Claim from a Text • Comparing Claims • Selecting the Strongest
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Learning Target:
"I can develop a clear claim that answers a question and can be supported by information from a text."
Part 1: Retrieval Warm-Up The 3 Pillars Review
WE DO
In Lesson 1.1, we learned that every quality claim must have three key ingredients. Review each pillar:
1. Clear Answers the question directly in a complete sentence (not just "yes/no").
2. Focused Takes one specific position on a central topic without drifting off-topic.
3. Supported Can be backed up using real facts and data found in the reading text.
Claim Sentence Stems Bank: Select or adapt 1 stem
• [Subject] should [action] because [specific reason]...
• In order to [positive outcome], districts ought to [action]...
• [Subject] must require / prohibit [topic] so that [benefit]...
• To prevent [negative problem], high schools should [action]...
My Warm-Up Claim + Reason: (choose a stem from the bank above) Prompt: "Should high schools require all students to join an after-school sports club? State a clear claim with a reason."
Part 2
Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO (Model) WE DO (Turn)
The 3-Step Expansion Formula:
1. Specific Who / What
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain purpose or outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded):
Plain: "Students need breaks."
Expanded: "High school students need short mental breaks during long block periods to stay focused , for example taking a five-minute stretch between math lessons so their brains can reset."
WE DO • Your Turn: Apply the formula to expand this plain sentence:
Plain Sentence: "High schools should offer team sports."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2 Page 1 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2
Reading & Comparing Claims
Read Short Text • Test Claims with Checklist • Rewrite a Weak Claim
Lesson 1.2 • Page 2 of 3
Part 3: Read Short Text & Respond to a Question WE DO
Paragraph 1: Many high school students spend five to eight hours every weekend doing homework. Teachers assign this work to practice classroom skills. However, student surveys show that heavy weekend homework causes students to lose sleep, feel anxious, and start Monday already tired.
Paragraph 2: Weekends give teenagers time to rest, spend time with family, work part-time jobs, and do creative hobbies. Education experts suggest cutting or stopping weekend homework. This helps students return to school on Monday well-rested and ready to learn.
Question Prompt: "Should high school districts establish a policy that prohibits homework assignments on weekends?"
Part 4: Evaluate Possible Claims & Rewrite One
📌 Section 1 WE DO
Test each claim below against Section 1 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet . Check the boxes it passes, decide if it is Strong or Not Strong , and then rewrite one weak claim to make it better:
Claim Option [A]: "Homework is assignments that teachers give students to practice school subjects at home."
Clear Answer Focused Stance Text-Supported
Result: Strong Not Strong
Claim Option [B]: "Weekend homework is bad because students do not like doing it on Saturdays."
Clear Answer Focused Stance Text-Supported
Result: Strong Not Strong
Claim Option [C]: "High school districts should prohibit weekend homework because two days of rest prevents student exhaustion and improves Monday focus."
Clear Answer Focused Stance Text-Supported
Result: Strong Not Strong
Which claim is strongest? Circle: [ Option A ] [ Option B ] [ Option C ]
Choose ONE "Not Strong" claim above and rewrite it to make it a better, quality claim:
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2 Page 2 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2
Independent Practice: Write a Claim
Read New Text • Independently Formulate Quality Claim • Scored Work (6 Points)
YOU DO
Score: _____ / 6 pts
YOU DO • Independent Application: Read the new reading text below. Use Section 1 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet (Claim Strength Checklist & Stems) to write a claim that is Clear , Focused , and Supported by Text .
New Reading Text: How Sleep Protects the Teenage Brain 2 Paragraphs
Paragraph 1: During the teenage years, the human brain grows and changes quickly. When high school students sleep, their brains organize new facts learned in class. Deep sleep helps lock in memories and clears out waste chemicals that build up during the day.
Paragraph 2: Doctors recommend that teenagers get eight to ten hours of sleep every night. Students who keep steady sleep habits pay better attention during morning tests, stay calmer during stressful days, and get sick less often.
Question Prompt:
"Should high school students prioritize sleeping at least eight hours each night? State a clear, focused claim supported by the text."
Write Your Independent Quality Claim (6 pts) Worth: 6 pts
Write a complete 1–2 sentence quality claim that directly answers the prompt and states a focused reason supported by the text:
Student Sheet Scoring Points Breakdown (6 pts Total): Target: 5–6 pts (Proficient)
Clear Stance (2 pts): Full sentence taking a definitive side answering the prompt.
Focused Topic (2 pts): Targets one specific issue (not broad or wandering).
Supported by Text (2 pts): References verifiable text details or benefits.
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2 Page 3 of 3
Writing Claims Teacher Guide 1.2 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2
Writing Claims Teacher Guide
Intro Script • Question of the Day • Gradual Release (I Do • We Do • You Do)
ELPA21 Level 3 HS
Lesson 1.2 Learning Target & Gradual Release: 45-Min (I Do • We Do • You Do)
"I can develop a clear claim that answers a question and can be supported by information from a text."
Welcome, Intro Script & Question of the Day (3 Min) Slide 2
Intro Script (Read Aloud): "Welcome back! Yesterday we learned what makes a claim strong. Today, we are taking it a step further: reading short texts and writing quality claims directly from the reading. We will warm up with our claim sentence stems, practice our 3-step sentence expansion formula, compare three claims about weekend homework, and finish with a 6-point independent claim check on teen sleep."
💬 Question of the Day (On Slide 2): "What is one rule at school or home that you think should be changed—or kept forever?"
1
Teaching Part 1: Retrieval Warm-Up & Stems Bank (8 Min)
I DO (Review) WE DO (Warm-Up)
Step 1 (I DO — Choral Review): Have students review the 3 pillars: "Clear (answers the question directly), Focused (specific stance on one issue), and Supported (can be proven by reading facts)."
Step 2 (WE DO — Claim Stems Bank & Warm-Up Check): Direct students to the Claim Sentence Stems Bank on Page 1 (and Section 1 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet ). Have them select one stem to answer the question on whether high schools should require all students to join an after-school sports club.
2
Teaching Part 2: Sentence Expansion Protocol (10 Min)
I DO (Model) WE DO (Practice)
🖼️ Visual Anchor: Pull up a photo of a high school soccer or basketball team huddling together on the field or court so students can visualize the topic before writing.
💬 Anticipatory Questions: 1) What sports or clubs do students at our school enjoy most? 2) What skills (like teamwork or leadership) do you learn from playing on a team? 3) How does playing a sport after school help with stress?
Walk through the Model Example (I Do), then guide students to apply the 3 steps (Specific Words + Add Purpose + Real Example) together:
Student Practice Prompt (WE DO): "High schools should offer team sports."
Exemplar Expansion: "High schools should provide organized team sports to build leadership, for example soccer and basketball clubs where students learn communication while relieving stress."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2 Teacher Guide Page 1 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2
Comparing & Selecting Claims Facilitation
Step-by-Step Instructions for Reading Texts, Checklist Evaluation & Rewriting
Lesson 1.2 Guide • Page 2 of 3
3
Teaching Part 3: Reading Short Text & Deconstructing Question (10 Min)
WE DO • Guided Reading
Have student pairs partner-read the two-paragraph text on Page 2. Direct them to underline the central problem: sleep loss, anxiety, and starting Monday already tired .
4
Teaching Part 4: Checklist Evaluation & Rewriting Weak Claims (14 Min)
WE DO • Partner/Class
Do NOT reveal which claim is strongest upfront. Have students pull out Section 1 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet to test Options A, B, and C, mark Strong vs. Not Strong, and then rewrite Option A or B:
Option [A] Debrief Key: Not Strong (Definition Only)
Fails Clear Answer & Focused Stance. It merely defines what homework is without taking a side on weekend bans.
Option [B] Debrief Key: Not Strong (Informal Feeling)
Fails Text-Supported & Focused Stance. Says "homework is bad because students do not like it" rather than citing sleep or exhaustion.
Option [C] Debrief Key: Strong Quality Claim (Correct)
Passes all 3 checklist items: clear stance ("should prohibit" ), focused reason (two days of rest), and text-supported (exhaustion and Monday focus ).
Exemplar Rewrite (Revising Option A or B):
"School districts should stop assigning weekend homework because cutting weekend work prevents student anxiety and helps teenagers arrive well-rested on Monday."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2 Teacher Guide Page 2 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2
Formative Assessment Scoring Guide
6-Point Scoring Rubric for Page 3 Independent Claim Writing (You Do)
YOU DO • Independent
Page 3 Independent Task (YOU DO):
Students read "How Sleep Protects the Teenage Brain" and independently write a quality claim responding to the sleep prompt. Allow EL students to reference Section 1 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet for claim sentence stems. Record scores out of 6 points total .
Itemized Point Allocation (6 Points Total):
1. Clear Stance — 2 Points 2 pts
• 2 pts: Full, grammatically complete sentence taking a definitive side answering the prompt (e.g., "High school students should prioritize sleeping at least eight hours each night..." ).
2. Focused Topic — 2 Points 2 pts
• 2 pts: Focuses specifically on one argument rather than drifting into unrelated topics (e.g., focused on memory consolidation or academic attention).
3. Supported by Text — 2 Points 2 pts
• 2 pts: Claim references verifiable text details or benefits (e.g., organizing new facts, clearing waste chemicals, paying better attention on morning tests).
Exemplar Student Response (6/6 Points):
"High school students should prioritize sleeping at least eight hours each night because deep sleep helps organize new facts and improves attention during morning tests."
Record scores on Page 2 of Curriculum Overview Teacher Guide (Column: W1 L2 Sheet). Score Tracking
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2 Teacher Guide Page 3 of 3
Quality Claims Formative Check - Week 1 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 Formative Check
Quality Claims Formative Check
Target: I can develop a clear claim that answers a question and can be supported by text.
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Score: ______ / 6 pts
Directions: In Part 1, compare the claims and select the one that is Clear, Focused, and Supported by text. In Part 2, read the text snippet and independently write a quality claim.
Part 1: Comparing Claims & Selecting the Strongest
Total: 3 pts (1 pt each)
1. Question: "Should school districts ban homework on weekends?" Worth: 1 pt
Which option is the strongest quality claim (Clear, Focused, Supported)?
[A] Homework is what teachers give students over the weekend.
[B] Districts should ban weekend homework because two days of rest prevents burnout.
2. Question: "Should high schools provide free breakfast to every student?" Worth: 1 pt
Which option is the strongest quality claim (Clear, Focused, Supported)?
[A] Schools should serve free breakfast because morning nutrition boosts classroom focus.
[B] Free breakfast is food that students eat in the morning.
3. Question: "Should cities fund youth sports centers?" Worth: 1 pt
Which option is the strongest quality claim (Clear, Focused, Supported)?
[A] Cities should fund youth centers because they offer safe recreation after school.
[B] Centers are really cool places where teenagers hang out.
Part 2: Read Snippet & Independently Write a Claim
Total: 3 pts
📌 Toolkit Tip: Use Section 1 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet (Claim Strength Checklist & Sentence Stems) to help write and check your claim.
Reading Snippet: Teen Sleep Biology
"During adolescence, biological sleep hormones release later in the evening, making early bedtimes unnatural. Medical trials demonstrate that delaying high school start times to 8:30 a.m. results in fewer tardy arrivals and higher attendance on morning exams."
Question: "Should high schools start classes at 8:30 a.m. or later?" Worth: 3 pts
Write a complete quality claim: Clear stance (1 pt) + Focused topic (1 pt) + Supported by text facts (1 pt):
Quality Checklist:
[ ] Part 1 MC (3 pts) [ ] Clear Stance (1 pt) [ ] Focused Topic (1 pt) [ ] Supported by Text (1 pt)
Exceeds (6 pts) All 3 MC items correct (3 pts) + complete, focused claim answering question with text-supported reason (3 pts).
Proficient (5 pts) At least 2 MC items correct (2 pts) + quality claim with clear stance answering the question (3 pts).
Developing (<5 pts) Vague or circular answer ("because it is good" ); lacks focused stance; requires reteaching on the 3 pillars.
Writing Claims Instructional Slides UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 1 • Lesson 1.2 Student Sheet Companion Deck
Lesson 1.2 Master Presentation
Writing Claims from Text
Comparing & Selecting the Strongest
Learning Target: "I can develop a clear claim that answers a question and can be supported by information from a text."
Part 1 (WE DO) 3 Pillars & Stems
Part 2 (I/WE) Expansion Formula
Part 3–4 (WE DO) Evaluate & Rewrite
Part 5 (YOU DO) 6-Pt Assessment
Welcome • Today's Plan & Question of the Day Warm-Up
💬 Question of the Day:
"What is one rule at school or home that you think should be changed—or kept forever?"
Coming Up Today:
• Warm up with the 3 Pillars & Claim Sentence Stems Bank (Part 1)
• Practice our 3-Step Sentence Expansion Formula (Part 2)
• Read about weekend homework, test 3 claims, and write your own claim on teen sleep (Parts 3–5)
Share your answer with a partner before we start Part 1!
Part 1: Retrieval • 3 Pillars & Claim Stems Bank
WE DO Page 1
1. Clear
Answers prompt in a full sentence.
2. Focused
Takes one specific position.
3. Supported
Proven using text facts and data.
🔑 Claim Sentence Stems Bank:
• [Subject] should [action] because [reason]...
• In order to [outcome], districts ought to...
• [Subject] must require [topic] so that...
• To prevent [problem], high schools should...
Prompt: "Should high schools require all students to join an after-school sports club?"
Part 2: The 3-Step Sentence Expansion Formula
I DO WE DO
1. Specific Words
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain the outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded): "Students need breaks." → "High school students need short mental breaks during long block periods to stay focused, for example taking a five-minute stretch between math lessons."
WE DO • Your Turn on Page 1: Expand "High schools should offer team sports."
Write your expanded sentence in the Part 2 box on Page 1!
Part 3: Read Short Text & Respond to Question
WE DO Page 2
Paragraph 1:
"Many high school students spend five to eight hours every weekend doing homework. Teachers assign this work to practice classroom skills. However, student surveys show that heavy weekend homework causes students to lose sleep, feel anxious, and start Monday already tired."
Paragraph 2:
"Weekends give teenagers time to rest, spend time with family, work part-time jobs, and do creative hobbies. Education experts suggest cutting or stopping weekend homework. This helps students return to school on Monday well-rested and ready to learn."
Question: Should high school districts establish a policy prohibiting homework on weekends?
Read the text on Page 2 before testing the three candidate claims!
Part 4: Test Claims with Checklist & Rewrite One
WE DO Page 2
Option [A]: "Homework is assignments that teachers give students to practice school subjects at home."
Option [B]: "Weekend homework is bad because students do not like doing it on Saturdays."
Option [C]: "High school districts should prohibit weekend homework because two days of rest prevents student exhaustion and improves Monday focus."
Tasks: 1) Check each option against Section 1 of your Reference Sheet. 2) Mark Strong or Not Strong. 3) Rewrite one weak option!
Complete Part 4 on Page 2 using Section 1 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet!
Part 5: Independent Practice • Reading Passage
YOU DO Page 3
Paragraph 1:
"During the teenage years, the human brain grows and changes quickly. When high school students sleep, their brains organize new facts learned in class. Deep sleep helps lock in memories and clears out waste chemicals that build up during the day."
Paragraph 2:
"Doctors recommend that teenagers get eight to ten hours of sleep every night. Students who keep steady sleep habits pay better attention during morning tests, stay calmer during stressful days, and get sick less often."
Question: Should high school students prioritize sleeping at least eight hours each night?
Read both paragraphs carefully on Page 3 before writing your independent claim!
Part 5: Independent Assessment • 6-Point Rubric
YOU DO Page 3
2 Points Clear Stance Full sentence takes a side
2 Points Focused Topic One specific argument
2 Points Supported by Text Uses verifiable text details
Use Section 1 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet to check your claim before turning in Page 3!
Next Week: What Makes Evidence Strong?
Quality Evidence Activity Sheet 2.1 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 3
Quality Evidence Activity Sheet
What Makes Evidence Strong • Analyzing Strong, Weak & Unrelated Evidence
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Learning Target:
"I can select relevant evidence from a text that supports my claim."
Part 1: The Three Tests of Strong Evidence
📌 Section 2 I DO
1. Relevant
Directly connects to the specific topic and stance of your claim.
Ask: "Does this fact actually prove my point?"
2. Specific
Provides concrete data, numbers, facts, or expert findings rather than general talk.
Ask: "Does it name exact facts or numbers?"
3. Text-Based
Comes directly from the reading text, cited with an attribution tag.
Ask: "Can the reader find it in the passage?"
Part 2
Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO (Model) WE DO (Turn)
The 3-Step Expansion Formula:
1. Specific Who / What
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain purpose or outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded):
Plain: "School lunches should be healthier."
Expanded: "Public high school cafeterias should serve nutrient-rich lunches to boost student energy , for example offering fresh fruit bowls and whole-grain wraps so teens stay alert after lunch."
WE DO • Your Turn: Apply the formula to expand this plain sentence:
Plain Sentence: "Apprenticeship programs help teens find careers."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 3 Page 1 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 3
Evidence Analysis & Evaluation
Test Evidence Options Against Checklist • Rewrite One Option as a Class
Lesson 2.1 • Page 2 of 3
Part 3: Test Evidence Options Against Your Checklist
📌 Section 2 WE DO
Read the Target Claim below. Check each evidence option against Section 2 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet to decide how strong it is:
Target Claim: "High schools should delay morning start times until 8:30 a.m. to improve student focus and test scores."
Evidence Option [A]:
"Many modern high school classrooms now use interactive smart boards and digital projectors."
Relevant to Claim Specific & Concrete Text-Based & Cited
Rating: Strong Weak Unrelated
Evidence Option [B]:
"Some students say they feel very tired early in the morning when waking up for school."
Relevant to Claim Specific & Concrete Text-Based & Cited
Rating: Strong Weak Unrelated
Evidence Option [C]:
"According to a multi-district medical study, shifting start times to 8:30 a.m. gave teens 45 extra minutes of sleep and increased first-period test pass rates by 14%."
Relevant to Claim Specific & Concrete Text-Based & Cited
Rating: Strong Weak Unrelated
Part 4: Rewrite One Weak Option Together as a Class
WE DO • Class
Choose one option above that was Weak or Unrelated (Option A or B). As a class, rewrite it using a stem from Section 2 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet so it becomes Strong, Specific, and Relevant to the Target Claim:
Option We Are Rewriting: [ Option A / Option B ]
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 3 Page 2 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 3
Practice Selecting Quality Evidence
Evaluating Options • Selecting Best Evidence • Explaining Choices
Lesson 2.1 • Page 3 of 3
Part 5: Practice Selecting Evidence for Claims
📌 Section 2 YOU DO
Read each claim below. Use Section 2 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet to circle the STRONGEST piece of evidence, then explain why it supports the claim:
Claim 1: "High schools should allow students to choose their own outfits instead of requiring uniforms."
[A] "Local department stores sell thousands of school backpacks every August."
[B] "A student wellness survey showed 84% of teenagers felt higher self-confidence when allowed personal clothing choice."
[C] "School uniform polo shirts are usually made from heavy cotton fabric."
Circle Best Evidence: [ A ] [ B ] [ C ] Explain why it proves Claim 1:
Claim 2: "School districts should invest in solar panels on school roofs to save money."
[A] "Solar panels cut Oakwood High's annual electricity bill by $45,000, funding two new school counselors."
[B] "Solar panels are usually dark blue rectangles mounted on flat roofs."
[C] "The sun is over 93 million miles away from Earth."
Circle Best Evidence: [ A ] [ B ] [ C ] Explain why it proves Claim 2:
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 3 Page 3 of 3
Quality Evidence Teacher Guide 2.1 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 3
Quality Evidence Teacher Guide
Intro Script • Question of the Day • Gradual Release (I Do • We Do • You Do)
ELPA21 Level 3 HS
Lesson 3 Learning Target & Gradual Release: 45-Min (I Do • We Do • You Do)
"I can select relevant evidence from a text that supports my claim."
Welcome, Intro Script & Question of the Day (3 Min) Slide 2
Intro Script (Read Aloud): "Welcome to Week 2! Last week you mastered writing strong Claims. Now we are moving to the 'E' in CER: Evidence. Today, you will learn the Three Tests of Strong Evidence—Relevant, Specific, and Text-Based—evaluate three evidence options about school start times, rewrite a weak option together as a class, and practice picking the best proof for two new claims."
💬 Question of the Day (On Slide 2): "If someone tries to convince you to watch a movie or try a new food, what kind of proof actually convinces you?"
1
Teaching Part 1: What Makes Evidence Strong? (9 Min)
I DO • Teacher Model
Step 1 (Introduce the 3 Tests): Direct students to the three boxes on Page 1 and Section 2 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet : "Evidence is the proof that holds up your claim. To be strong, it must pass three tests: Relevant (directly connects to your specific claim), Specific (provides concrete numbers, facts, or data), and Text-Based (found in the passage, not made up)."
Step 2 (Contrast 3 Evidence Types): "Strong evidence proves the point with facts. Weak evidence is vague or just a general opinion. Unrelated evidence is an interesting fact that has nothing to do with your claim."
📌 Reference Sheet Tip: Have students keep Section 2 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet open on their desks during Parts 3, 4, and 5 to test and rewrite evidence options.
2
Teaching Part 2: Sentence Expansion Protocol (8 Min)
I DO (Model) WE DO (Practice)
🖼️ Visual Anchor: Pull up a photo of a young apprentice working alongside a certified electrician or mechanic in a workshop so students can see hands-on career training.
💬 Anticipatory Questions: 1) What hands-on jobs or trades do you see people doing in our community? 2) What is the difference between learning from a textbook and learning on the job? 3) Why might earning a trade certificate in high school help a student's future?
Review the Model Example (I Do), then guide students through the 3-Step Expansion Formula together (We Do):
Student Practice Prompt (WE DO): "Apprenticeship programs help teens find careers."
Exemplar Expansion: "Vocational apprenticeship programs provide fast-track career pathways for high school seniors, for example training students in certified electrician and plumbing trades where starting wages exceed forty thousand dollars."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 3 Teacher Guide Page 1 of 2
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 3
Evidence Analysis & Selection Facilitation
Step-by-Step Instructions for Parts 3 & 4 (We Do) and Part 5 (You Do)
Lesson 2.1 Guide • Page 2 of 2
3
Teaching Parts 3 & 4: Checklist Testing & Whole-Class Rewrite (12 Min)
WE DO • Guided Practice
Have students test Options A, B, and C against Section 2 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet before debriefing and co-rewriting:
Option [A] Debrief (Unrelated): Smart boards have zero connection to whether starting school at 8:30 a.m. improves learning.
Option [B] Debrief (Weak): Related to sleep, but it is a vague personal opinion with zero measurable data or citation.
Option [C] Debrief (Strong): Passes all 3 tests: directly relevant, exact numbers (45 min, 14%), and cited with an attribution tag.
Part 4 Whole-Class Rewrite Exemplar (Fixing Option B): "According to a national adolescent sleep survey, 78% of high school students who woke up before 6:30 a.m. scored lower on first-period comprehension quizzes."
4
Teaching Part 5: Evidence Selection Drills (Page 3) (13 Min)
YOU DO • Independent
Claim 1 (Uniforms) Key:
Correct Choice: [B]
Why: Option B provides survey data (84% higher confidence) directly linking clothing choice to individuality. Options A and C describe clothing stores and fabric, which are unrelated.
Claim 2 (Solar Energy) Key:
Correct Choice: [A]
Why: Option A names exact funds ($45,000 saved) and specific student programs funded (counselors). Options B and C describe solar panel appearance and distance to the sun, which are unrelated.
Lesson 3 Formative Checkpoints: Exit Assessment
Exceeds Accurately evaluates evidence with checklist; contributes specific data/citation to class rewrite; selects correct evidence options in Part 5.
Proficient Identifies strong evidence; selects correct choices in Part 5 with basic written justification.
Developing Selects unrelated or weak evidence; mistakes general topic overlap for relevance; needs coaching on the 3 tests.
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 3 Teacher Guide Page 2 of 2
Quality Evidence Instructional Slides UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 3 Student Sheet Companion Deck
Lesson 3 Master Presentation
What Makes Evidence Strong?
Relevant • Specific • Text-Based
Learning Target: "I can select relevant evidence from a text that supports my claim."
Part 1 (I DO) The 3 Tests
Part 2 (I/WE) Expansion Formula
Part 3–4 (WE DO) Test & Rewrite
Part 5 (YOU DO) Selection Drills
Welcome • Today's Plan & Question of the Day Warm-Up
💬 Question of the Day:
"If someone tries to convince you to watch a movie or try a new food, what kind of proof actually convinces you?"
Coming Up Today:
• Learn the Three Tests of Strong Evidence (Part 1) & Sentence Expansion (Part 2)
• Rate evidence options about school start times and rewrite a weak one together (Parts 3–4)
• Practice picking the strongest proof for two new claims independently (Part 5)
Share your answer with a partner before we start Part 1!
Part 1: The Three Tests of Strong Evidence
I DO Page 1
Does Your Evidence Pass These Three Tests?
1. Relevant
Directly connects to the specific topic and stance of the claim.
Does it actually prove your point?
2. Specific
Provides concrete data, numbers, facts, or expert findings (not general talk).
Names exact facts or figures!
3. Text-Based
Directly cited or quoted from the reading passage with an attribution tag.
Verifiable in the reading passage!
✓ Strong: Relevant + Specific Facts
⚠️ Weak: Related, but Vague / Opinion
❌ Unrelated: Off-Topic / Proves Nothing
Keep Section 2 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet on your desk!
Part 2: The 3-Step Sentence Expansion Formula
I DO WE DO
1. Specific Words
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain the direct outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded): "School lunches should be healthier." → "Public high school cafeterias should serve nutrient-rich lunches to boost student energy, for example fresh fruit bowls and whole-grain wraps."
WE DO • Your Turn on Page 1: Expand "Apprenticeship programs help teens find careers."
Write your expanded sentence in the Part 2 box on Page 1!
Part 3: Test Evidence Options Against Checklist
WE DO Page 2
Target Claim:
"High schools should delay morning start times until 8:30 a.m. to improve student focus and test scores."
Option [A]: "Many modern high school classrooms now use interactive smart boards and digital projectors."
Option [B]: "Some students say they feel very tired early in the morning when waking up for school."
Option [C]: "According to a multi-district medical study, shifting start times to 8:30 a.m. gave teens 45 extra minutes of sleep and increased first-period test pass rates by 14%."
Test Options A, B, and C against Section 2 of your Reference Sheet on Page 2!
Part 4: Rewrite One Weak Option Together as a Class
WE DO Page 2
Class Task:
Choose one option from Part 3 that was Weak or Unrelated (Option A or Option B).
Make It Pass All 3 Tests Together:
1. Use an attribution stem from Section 2 of your Reference Sheet ("According to..." ).
2. Add specific, relevant data or facts that prove the Target Claim.
Write our class-improved evidence statement in Part 4 on Page 2!
Part 5: Practice Selecting Evidence
YOU DO Page 3
Claim 1 (Uniforms):
"High schools should allow students to choose their own outfits instead of requiring uniforms."
→ Test [A], [B], and [C] on Page 3, circle the strongest, and explain why!
Claim 2 (Solar Energy):
"School districts should invest in solar panels on school roofs to save money."
→ Test [A], [B], and [C] on Page 3, circle the strongest, and explain why!
Complete Part 5 independently on Page 3 using Section 2 of your Reference Sheet!
Matching Evidence Activity Sheet 2.2 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 4
Matching Evidence Activity Sheet
Matching Evidence to a Claim • Evaluating & Embedding the Strongest Evidence
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Learning Target:
"I can select relevant evidence from a text that supports my claim."
Part 1: Warm-Up Match
📌 Section 2 WE DO
Read the claim: "High schools should provide free public bus passes to all enrolled students."
Which piece of evidence below best matches and supports this claim? Circle your choice:
[A] "City public buses operate on clean natural gas and have twenty-four seats."
[B] "Transit data shows providing free student passes increased high school daily attendance by 18%."
Explain in 1 sentence: Why does your choice match the claim better?
Part 2
Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO (Model) WE DO (Turn)
The 3-Step Expansion Formula:
1. Specific Who / What
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain purpose or outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded):
Plain: "Libraries help students learn."
Expanded: "Updated high school libraries give teenagers quiet spaces to succeed academically , for example offering free high-speed laptops and research databases for afternoon homework."
WE DO • Your Turn: Apply the formula to expand this plain sentence:
Plain Sentence: "Rooftop gardens cool down school buildings."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 4 Page 1 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 4
Matching Evidence to Claims
Read Text • Develop a Claim • Evaluate & Combine Evidence
Lesson 2.2 • Page 2 of 3
Part 3: Read Text & Develop Your Claim
📌 Section 1 WE DO
"Environmental study data shows that planting rooftop vegetable gardens on city high schools lowered classroom summer temperatures by 7°F. Because of this, schools cut their air conditioning electric bills by 24%, saving more than $18,000 each year. Science teachers also reported that garden clubs doubled student enrollment in advanced environmental science classes."
Prompt: Should city high schools install rooftop vegetable gardens?
Your Developed Claim:
Part 4: Evaluate 3 Pieces of Evidence & Combine
📌 Section 2 WE DO
Look at three pieces of evidence from the reading. Rate each piece as Strong , Weak , or Unrelated using Section 2 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet :
Evidence Option [A]: Rating: [ Strong / Weak / Unrelated ]
"Rooftop vegetable gardens on city high schools lowered classroom summer temperatures by 7°F and cut cooling bills by 24%."
Evidence Option [B]: Rating: [ Strong / Weak / Unrelated ]
"School building roofs are constructed with asphalt tar and heavy concrete slabs."
Evidence Option [C]: Rating: [ Strong / Weak / Unrelated ]
"Gardens look nice from tall skyscraper windows in downtown city centers."
Which evidence best supports your claim and why? Circle: [ A ] [ B ] [ C ]
Put It Together: Write Your Claim + Strongest Evidence Together
Sentence Frame: "[Your Claim], because according to the text, '[your selected evidence].'"
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 4 Page 2 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 4
Independent Practice: Match & Embed Evidence
Read Text • Develop Claim • Identify & Embed Strongest Evidence (8 Points)
YOU DO
Score: _____ / 8 pts
Reading Passage: Plastic Bottle Bans in High Schools 📌 Use Reference Sheet (Sections 1 & 2)
Paragraph 1: American teenagers throw away over 500 million plastic water bottles into city landfills every year. Scientists report that plastic bottles take 450 years to break down. As they sit in landfills, they leak harmful plastic chemicals into dirt and drinking water.
Paragraph 2: When Maple Valley High banned plastic bottles and put in five filtered water refill stations, school trash audits showed an 85% drop in plastic garbage. In addition, 91% of students brought refillable metal bottles to school, saving families an average of $210 each year on store-bought drinks.
Prompt: Should high school campuses ban single-use plastic water bottles? Worth: 8 pts Total
1. Develop Your Clear Quality Claim (2 pts):
2. Quote the Strongest Evidence from the Text with an Attribution Tag (2 pts): (See Section 2 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet for Evidence Stems)
3. Write Your Complete Claim + Embedded Evidence Response (4 pts):
Student Sheet Scoring Breakdown (8 pts Total): Target: 7–8 pts (Proficient)
Claim (2 pts): Clear, focused stance answering prompt.
Evidence Selected (2 pts): Relevant, specific fact from text.
Attribution Tag (2 pts): Uses proper framing tag (According to... ).
Connection (2 pts): Logically connects evidence to claim.
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 4 Page 3 of 3
Matching Evidence Teacher Guide 2.2 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 4
Matching Evidence Teacher Guide
Intro Script • Question of the Day • Gradual Release (I Do • We Do • You Do)
ELPA21 Level 3 HS
Lesson 4 Learning Target & Gradual Release: 45-Min (I Do • We Do • You Do)
"I can select relevant evidence from a text that supports my claim."
Welcome, Intro Script & Question of the Day (3 Min) Slide 2
Intro Script (Read Aloud): "Welcome back! Yesterday we learned how to test whether evidence is strong, weak, or unrelated. Today, we are matching evidence directly to your own claims. We will warm up with a bus pass match, expand sentences using our 3-step formula, read about rooftop gardens to build a Claim + Evidence combo, and finish with an 8-point independent check on plastic water bottle bans."
💬 Question of the Day (On Slide 2): "If our school had an extra $10,000 to spend on one campus upgrade, what should we buy—and what is one fact that proves it is worth it?"
1
Teaching Part 1: Warm-Up Match (7 Min)
I DO (Debrief) WE DO (Match)
Step 1 (Analyze Claim): Direct students to the claim: "High schools should provide free public bus passes to all enrolled students."
Step 2 (Compare Options via Reference Sheet): Have students check Option A and Option B against Section 2 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet : "Option A is a factual detail about buses, but it does not prove why schools should provide passes. Option B directly proves the school attendance benefit!"
2
Teaching Part 2: Sentence Expansion Protocol (8 Min)
I DO (Model) WE DO (Practice)
🖼️ Visual Anchor: Pull up a photo of a lush green rooftop vegetable garden on top of a city school building so students can visualize urban rooftop farming.
💬 Anticipatory Questions: 1) Have you ever noticed how hot dark pavement or roofs get in the summer? 2) What do you think happens to the temperature inside a building if plants and soil cover the roof? 3) How else could a school use a rooftop garden?
Walk through the Model Example (I Do), then guide students through the 3-Step Expansion Formula together (We Do):
Student Practice Prompt (WE DO): "Rooftop gardens cool down school buildings."
Exemplar Expansion: "Rooftop vegetable gardens provide natural biological insulation across urban school roofs, for example dropping indoor classroom temperatures by seven degrees and cutting electricity expenses by twenty-five percent."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 4 Teacher Guide Page 1 of 2
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 4
Matching & Embedding Evidence Facilitation
Step-by-Step Instructions for Parts 3 & 4 (We Do) and Part 5 (You Do)
Lesson 2.2 Guide • Page 2 of 2
3
Teaching Parts 3 & 4: Read Text, Evaluate & Combine (12 Min)
WE DO • Guided Practice
Students partner-read Urban Rooftop Gardens , draft their claim (Section 1), evaluate Options A–C (Section 2), and combine them using the Part 4 Sentence Frame:
Option [A] (Strong Evidence): Provides exact data (7°F temp drop, 24% bill reduction, $18,000 saved) directly proving why schools should install gardens.
Option [B] (Unrelated Fact): Mentions asphalt and concrete roofs; describes building materials but proves zero benefits.
Option [C] (Weak / Irrelevant): Mentions skyscraper views; subjective aesthetic comment with no educational or financial proof.
4
Scoring Part 5 Independent Assessment (8 Points Total) (15 Min)
YOU DO • Independent
Allow students to consult Sections 1 & 2 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet for claim and evidence attribution stems. Evaluate responses on the Plastic Bottle Ban prompt using this 8-point rubric:
1. Claim (2 pts): Clear, focused stance answering prompt (e.g., "Schools should prohibit single-use plastic bottles..." ).
2. Evidence Selected (2 pts): Cites specific text fact (85% reduction in trash or $210 saved per family).
3. Attribution Tag (2 pts): Properly embeds evidence with tag (e.g., "According to text data from Maple Valley High..." ).
4. Claim-Evidence Connection (2 pts): Explains how the cited fact directly supports the claim.
Exemplar Student Response (8/8 Points):
"High school campuses should establish a policy banning single-use plastic water bottles. According to text data from Maple Valley High, installing water refill stations resulted in an 85% drop in plastic trash and saved families an average of $210 each year. This evidence proves that banning plastic bottles creates immediate environmental protection and saves money for student families."
Record final student score (0–8 pts) on Curriculum Overview Roster (Column: W2 L2 Sheet). Target: 7–8 pts
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 4 Teacher Guide Page 2 of 2
Evidence Selection Formative Check - Week 2 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 Formative Check
Evidence Selection Formative Check
Target: I can select relevant evidence from a text that supports my claim.
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Score: ______ / 8 pts
Directions: In Part 1, evaluate strong vs. weak evidence. In Part 2, read the text snippet, develop a clear claim, and embed the strongest evidence using an attribution tag.
Part 1: Evaluating Strong vs. Weak Evidence
Total: 2 pts (1 pt each)
1. Claim: "High schools should install electric vehicle charging stations." Worth: 1 pt
Which option is the strongest quality evidence (Relevant, Specific, Text-based)?
[A] An environmental trial confirmed campus EV stations reduced parking lot emissions by 40%.
[B] Electric cars have batteries that plug into electrical cords.
2. Claim: "Schools should require water refill stations." Worth: 1 pt
Which piece of evidence best proves that stations reduce campus plastic trash?
[A] Water refill stations dispense chilled filtered water through touchless spouts.
[B] Waste audits recorded an 85% drop in plastic trash after stations were installed.
Part 2: Reading Snippet & Constructed Response
Total: 6 pts
Reading Excerpt: Universal High School Breakfast
"When Washington High introduced universal free breakfast carts in school hallways, nurse office visits for morning stomachaches dropped by 45%. School counselors reported that well-fed students completed morning algebra assignments with fewer behavioral distractions."
Prompt: Should high school districts provide free universal breakfast to all students?
Task A: Develop Your Clear Quality Claim (2 pts): [Worth: 2 pts]
Task B: Quote the Strongest Evidence with an Attribution Tag (2 pts): [Worth: 2 pts]
Task C: Explain Why this Evidence Directly Proves Your Claim (2 pts): [Worth: 2 pts]
Quality Checklist:
[ ] Part 1 MC (2 pts) [ ] Task A Claim (2 pts) [ ] Task B Evidence (2 pts) [ ] Task C Explanation (2 pts)
Exceeds (7–8 pts) Accurate MC answers; clear stance; specific cited data; explicit explanation connecting stomachache drop to learning.
Proficient (6 pts) Both MC items correct; clear claim; relevant evidence cited with tag; logical connection written.
Developing (<6 pts) Selects unrelated evidence; missing attribution tag; echoes text without explanation; needs reteaching on 3 tests.
Matching Evidence Instructional Slides UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 2 • Lesson 4 Student Sheet Companion Deck
Lesson 4 Master Presentation
Matching Evidence to Claims
Evaluating & Embedding the Strongest
Learning Target: "I can select relevant evidence from a text that supports my claim."
Part 1 (WE DO) Warm-Up Match
Part 2 (I/WE) Expansion Formula
Part 3–4 (WE DO) Match & Combine
Part 5 (YOU DO) 8-Pt Assessment
Welcome • Today's Plan & Question of the Day Warm-Up
💬 Question of the Day:
"If our school had an extra $10,000 to spend on one campus upgrade, what should we buy—and what is one fact that proves it is worth it?"
Coming Up Today:
• Warm up by matching evidence to a bus-pass claim (Part 1) & expanding sentences (Part 2)
• Read about rooftop gardens, develop a claim, and combine Claim + Evidence (Parts 3–4)
• Complete an 8-point independent reading & evidence task on plastic bottle bans (Part 5)
Share your answer with a partner before we start Part 1!
Part 1: Warm-Up Match • Which Evidence Supports the Claim?
WE DO Page 1
Provided Claim:
"High schools should provide free public bus passes to all enrolled students."
Option [A]: "City public buses operate on clean natural gas and have twenty-four seats."
Option [B]: "Transit data shows providing free student passes increased high school daily attendance by 18%."
Circle your choice and explain why it matches the claim on Page 1!
Part 2: The 3-Step Sentence Expansion Formula
I DO WE DO
1. Specific Words
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain the direct outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded): "Libraries help students learn." → "Updated high school libraries give teenagers quiet spaces to succeed academically, for example offering free high-speed laptops and research databases."
WE DO • Your Turn on Page 1: Expand "Rooftop gardens cool down school buildings."
Write your expanded sentence in the Part 2 box on Page 1!
Part 3: Read Text & Develop Your Claim
WE DO Page 2
Reading Passage: Urban Rooftop Gardens
"Environmental study data shows that planting rooftop vegetable gardens on city high schools lowered classroom summer temperatures by 7°F . Because of this, schools cut their air conditioning electric bills by 24% , saving more than $18,000 each year. Science teachers also reported that garden clubs doubled student enrollment in advanced environmental science classes."
Prompt: Should city high schools install rooftop vegetable gardens? (Use Section 1 of your Reference Sheet to write your claim!)
Write your developed claim in the Part 3 box on Page 2!
Part 4: Evaluate 3 Pieces of Evidence & Combine
WE DO Page 2
Option [A]: "Rooftop vegetable gardens on city high schools lowered classroom summer temperatures by 7°F and cut cooling bills by 24%."
Option [B]: "School building roofs are constructed with asphalt tar and heavy concrete slabs."
Option [C]: "Gardens look nice from tall skyscraper windows in downtown city centers."
Put It Together Frame: "[Your Claim], because according to the text, '[your selected evidence].'"
Rate Options A, B, and C, circle the strongest, and combine your Claim + Evidence on Page 2!
Part 5: Independent Practice • Reading Passage
YOU DO Page 3
Paragraph 1:
"American teenagers throw away over 500 million plastic water bottles into city landfills every year. Scientists report that plastic bottles take 450 years to break down. As they sit in landfills, they leak harmful plastic chemicals into dirt and drinking water."
Paragraph 2:
"When Maple Valley High banned plastic bottles and put in five filtered water refill stations, school trash audits showed an 85% drop in plastic garbage. In addition, 91% of students brought refillable metal bottles, saving families an average of $210 each year."
Prompt: Should high school campuses ban single-use plastic water bottles?
Read both paragraphs carefully on Page 3 before completing Tasks 1–3!
Part 5: Independent Assessment • 8-Point Rubric
YOU DO Page 3
2 Points Quality Claim Clear, focused stance
2 Points Strong Evidence Specific fact from text
2 Points Attribution Tag Uses "According to..."
2 Points Connection Links evidence to claim
Use Sections 1 & 2 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet to check your response!
Next Week: What Is Reasoning? Making the Connective Bridge!
Understanding Reasoning Activity Sheet 3.1 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 5
Understanding Reasoning Activity Sheet
Major Instructional Focus Begins • What Reasoning Actually Does
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Major Instructional Focus: The Connective Engine
Learning Target: "I can explain how and why my evidence supports my claim."
Part 1: Retrieval Review • Claim & Evidence
I DO
Before we explore reasoning, let's review the two parts of CER we already mastered:
1. The Claim (Week 1):
Your 1-sentence answer that states a clear, focused stance on the prompt question.
Role: Tells WHAT you are arguing.
2. The Evidence (Week 2):
A relevant, specific fact, quote, or data detail taken directly from the reading text.
Role: Gives the PROOF for your claim.
The Missing Link: Evidence cannot speak for itself! Readers need Reasoning to explain the logical connection between the evidence and the claim.
Part 2
Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO (Model) WE DO (Turn)
The 3-Step Expansion Formula:
1. Specific Who / What
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain purpose or outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded):
Plain: "Sleep helps teenagers."
Expanded: "Consistent nightly sleep protects developing teenage brains to improve memory , for example helping ninth graders recall science vocabulary during morning quizzes."
WE DO • Your Turn: Apply the formula to expand this plain sentence:
Plain Sentence: "Air purifiers protect student health."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 5 Page 1 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 5
The Connective Engine: Reasoning
What Reasoning Does • Evaluating Samples with Checklist & Rewriting
Lesson 3.1 • Page 2 of 3
Part 3: What is Reasoning?
📌 Section 3 I DO
Reasoning is the explanation that connects your evidence directly back to your claim. It answers two critical questions:
1. The "HOW" Question: HOW does this piece of evidence physically cause change or operate?
2. The "WHY" Question: WHY does this outcome prove that your initial claim is true?
Part 4: Evaluate Reasoning Samples, Discuss & Rewrite
WE DO • Partner/Class
Use Section 3 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet to check each sample below. Decide its quality, discuss as a class which is best and what is missing from the other two, then rewrite one weak sample:
[Claim]: Cities should provide free public bus passes to high school students.
[Evidence]: Transit data confirms free bus passes increased daily attendance by 18%.
Sample [A]:
"Cities should provide bus passes. Data confirms free passes increased attendance by 18%." [Writer stops here.]
Explains HOW/WHY No Echoing Bridges to Claim
Quality: Strong Needs Work
Sample [B]:
"...This proves cities should give passes because attendance increased by 18% when students got passes."
Explains HOW/WHY No Echoing Bridges to Claim
Quality: Strong Needs Work
Sample [C]:
"...This data is significant because free transportation eliminates costly fare barriers for low-income teens, ensuring they can travel safely to campus every morning without missing instruction."
Explains HOW/WHY No Echoing Bridges to Claim
Quality: Strong Needs Work
Class Discussion — Best Sample: [ A / B / C ] | Missing from the other two:
Partner / Class Rewrite — Choose ONE weak sample (A or B) and rewrite it to make it strong:
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 5 Page 2 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 5
Identifying & Writing Reasoning
Practice Spotting Reasoning in CER Texts • Writing Your Own Connective Statement
Lesson 3.1 • Page 3 of 3
Part 5: Practice Identifying Reasoning in Sample CER Responses
WE DO • Guided Practice
Read each student response. Underline the sentence that acts as the reasoning statement connecting the evidence to the claim:
Sample CER A (Universal Breakfast):
"School districts should provide free universal breakfast to all students. Data from Washington High revealed that morning nurse visits for stomachaches dropped by 45%. This evidence proves breakfast is vital because morning nutrition prevents painful hunger cramps, allowing students to maintain mental focus during challenging morning classes."
Does this reasoning explain the connection, or just repeat the fact? [ Explains Connection / Repeats Fact ]
Sample CER B (Campus Solar Panels):
"High schools should install rooftop solar panels. Lincoln High saved $45,000 in annual electric bills after installing solar panels. This shows schools should install solar panels because saving $45,000 on electricity is a lot of money."
Does this reasoning explain the connection, or just repeat the fact? [ Explains Connection / Repeats Fact ]
Part 6: Write Your Own Reasoning Statement
📌 Section 3 Stems YOU DO
Read the provided Claim and Evidence below. Use a stem from Section 3 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet to write ONE strong reasoning statement explaining HOW and WHY the evidence proves the claim:
[Provided Claim]: High school students should prioritize sleeping at least eight hours every night.
[Provided Evidence]: Neuroscientists report that eight hours of sleep allows the brain to consolidate memories and flush out cellular toxins.
Your Connective Reasoning Statement (Explain HOW & WHY this proves the claim):
Reasoning Check: [ ] Explains HOW/WHY [ ] Connects directly to claim [ ] Does NOT just repeat evidence
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 5 Page 3 of 3
Understanding Reasoning Teacher Guide 3.1 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 5
Understanding Reasoning Teacher Guide
Intro Script • Question of the Day • Gradual Release (I Do • We Do • You Do)
ELPA21 Level 3 HS
Major Instructional Focus & Gradual Release: 45-Min (I Do • We Do • You Do)
Learning Target: "I can explain how and why my evidence supports my claim."
Welcome, Intro Script & Question of the Day (3 Min) Slide 2
Intro Script (Read Aloud): "Welcome to Week 3! This week is the heart of our entire 5-week course: Reasoning. You already know how to write strong Claims and pick strong Evidence—today you will learn how to build the bridge between them. We will review Claim and Evidence, practice sentence expansion, learn the HOW and WHY questions, evaluate three reasoning samples, and finish by writing your own reasoning statement on teen sleep."
💬 Question of the Day (On Slide 2): "If you tell a friend 'You HAVE to try this new restaurant,' and they ask 'Why?', what is the difference between saying 'Because it is good' versus actually explaining why?"
1
Teaching Part 1: Review Claim & Evidence (7 Min)
I DO • Teacher Model
Step 1 (Retrieval Drill): Review the distinct roles mastered in Weeks 1 and 2: "Your claim tells WHAT you believe. Your evidence gives the facts PROVING your claim. But who connects them? The reader cannot read your mind!"
Step 2 (The Bridge Metaphor): Draw two islands on the board: Island 1 (Claim) and Island 2 (Evidence). Explain: "Reasoning is the suspension bridge built between the two islands. Without reasoning, the reader is stuck on Island 2 wondering why you showed them that fact."
2
Teaching Part 2: Sentence Expansion Protocol (8 Min)
I DO (Model) WE DO (Practice)
🖼️ Visual Anchor: Pull up a photo of a HEPA air purifier running inside a classroom next to students' desks so learners connect the sentence to real classroom health.
💬 Anticipatory Questions: 1) What kinds of things float in classroom air during winter cold season or allergy season? 2) How might cleaner air help a student who has asthma or allergies? 3) Why would filtering the air help students miss fewer days of school?
Walk through the Model Example (I Do), then guide students to apply the 3-step formula together (We Do):
Student Practice Prompt (WE DO): "Air purifiers protect student health."
Exemplar Expansion: "High-efficiency classroom air purifiers protect student lung health, for example filtering airborne winter viruses so children with asthma attend school without breathing difficulties."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 5 Teacher Guide Page 1 of 2
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 5
Reasoning Evaluation & Synthesis Facilitation
Step-by-Step Instructions for Part 3 (I Do), Parts 4 & 5 (We Do), and Part 6 (You Do)
Lesson 3.1 Guide • Page 2 of 2
3
Teaching Parts 3 & 4: Checklist Evaluation, Discussion & Rewrite (14 Min)
I DO (Part 3) WE DO (Part 4)
After teaching Part 3 (HOW & WHY), do NOT give away which sample is best. Have students test Samples A, B, and C against Section 3 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet , discuss as a class, and rewrite A or B together:
Sample [A] Debrief (Needs Work — Dropped Fact): Missing all reasoning! Writer drops the 18% stat and stops without explaining what it means.
Sample [B] Debrief (Needs Work — Echo): Missing HOW & WHY! Simply repeats "attendance increased by 18%" without explaining why fares mattered.
Sample [C] Debrief (Strong — Best Sample): Passes all 3 checklist items: explains HOW (eliminates fare barriers) and WHY (ensures safe daily travel).
Partner / Class Rewrite Exemplar (Fixing A or B): "This evidence proves free passes are essential because removing bus costs allows low-income students to ride safely to school every morning without missing class."
4
Teaching Parts 5 & 6: Spotting & Drafting Reasoning (13 Min)
WE DO (Part 5) YOU DO (Part 6)
📌 Reference Sheet Tip: For Part 6 (You Do), have students pick a connective sentence stem from Section 3 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet before drafting.
Part 5 Identification Key (WE DO):
• Sample A (Breakfast): The 3rd sentence is reasoning. It explains the connection (nutrition prevents stomach cramps, enabling math focus).
• Sample B (Solar): The 3rd sentence is reasoning, but it repeats the fact (circular echo: saying $45k is a lot of money without explaining what it funded).
Part 6 Writing Exemplar (YOU DO — Teen Sleep):
"This evidence is significant because flushing neural toxins and consolidating memories restores cognitive clarity, ensuring teenagers can comprehend complex classroom formulas without morning brain exhaustion."
Lesson 5 Formative Checkpoints: Exit Assessment
Exceeds Identifies reasoning vs. echo in both samples; writes original reasoning explaining both HOW and WHY evidence proves the claim.
Proficient Identifies reasoning accurately; writes a reasoning statement that moves beyond repeating evidence to state a logical outcome.
Developing Echoes the provided evidence in Part 6; confuses evidence with reasoning; needs coaching on explaining the "Why".
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 5 Teacher Guide Page 2 of 2
Understanding Reasoning Instructional Slides UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 5 Student Sheet Companion Deck
Lesson 5 Master Presentation
What is Reasoning?
The Connective Engine of CER
Learning Target: "I can explain how and why my evidence supports my claim."
Part 1 (I DO) Claim/Evidence
Part 2 (I/WE) Expansion
Part 3–4 (I/WE) Test Samples
Part 5 (WE DO) Spot Reasoning
Part 6 (YOU DO) Write Reasoning
Welcome • Today's Plan & Question of the Day Warm-Up
💬 Question of the Day:
"If you tell a friend 'You HAVE to try this new restaurant,' and they ask 'Why?', what is the difference between saying 'Because it is good' versus actually explaining why?"
Coming Up Today:
• Review Claim & Evidence (Part 1) and practice Sentence Expansion (Part 2)
• Learn the HOW & WHY of Reasoning and evaluate 3 samples (Parts 3–4)
• Spot reasoning in CER paragraphs and write your own reasoning on teen sleep (Parts 5–6)
Share your answer with a partner before we start Part 1!
Part 1: Retrieval Review • Claim & Evidence
I DO Page 1
Two Islands that Need a Bridge:
Island 1: The Claim (Week 1)
Your 1-sentence answer stating a clear, focused position on the prompt.
Island 2: The Evidence (Week 2)
A specific, relevant fact, quote, or data detail taken directly from the text.
The Missing Link: Evidence cannot speak for itself! Reasoning is the bridge between Claim and Evidence.
Review Part 1 on Page 1 of your activity packet!
Part 2: The 3-Step Sentence Expansion Formula
I DO WE DO
1. Specific Words
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain the direct outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded): "Sleep helps teenagers." → "Consistent nightly sleep protects developing teenage brains to improve memory, for example helping ninth graders recall science vocabulary during morning quizzes."
WE DO • Your Turn on Page 1: Expand "Air purifiers protect student health."
Write your expanded sentence in the Part 2 box on Page 1!
Part 3: What is Reasoning?
I DO Page 2
Reasoning explains HOW and WHY your evidence proves your claim!
1. The "HOW" Question:
HOW does this fact physically cause change, work, or affect people?
2. The "WHY" Question:
WHY does this outcome prove that your initial claim is true?
Keep Section 3 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet on your desk!
Part 4: Evaluate Reasoning Samples, Discuss & Rewrite
WE DO Page 2
Claim: Cities should provide free bus passes. | Evidence: Free passes increased attendance by 18%.
Sample [A]: "Cities should provide bus passes. Data confirms free passes increased attendance by 18%." [Stops here.]
Sample [B]: "...This proves cities should give passes because attendance increased by 18% when students got passes."
Sample [C]: "...This data is significant because free transportation eliminates costly fare barriers for low-income teens, ensuring they can travel safely to campus every morning."
Check each with Section 3, discuss which is best & what is missing, then rewrite A or B!
Part 5: Practice Identifying Reasoning in CER
WE DO Page 3
Sample CER A (Universal Breakfast):
"School districts should provide free universal breakfast to all students. Data from Washington High revealed that morning nurse visits for stomachaches dropped by 45%. This evidence proves breakfast is vital because morning nutrition prevents painful hunger cramps, allowing students to maintain mental focus during challenging morning classes."
Sample CER B (Campus Solar Panels):
"High schools should install rooftop solar panels. Lincoln High saved $45,000 in annual electric bills after installing solar panels. This shows schools should install solar panels because saving $45,000 on electricity is a lot of money."
Underline the reasoning sentence in each sample on Page 3 and circle whether it explains or repeats!
Part 6: Write Your Own Reasoning Statement
YOU DO Page 3
Claim: High school students should prioritize sleeping at least eight hours every night.
Evidence: Neuroscientists report that eight hours of sleep allows the brain to consolidate memories and flush out cellular toxins.
Your Task: Pick a connective stem from Section 3 of your Reference Sheet and explain HOW and WHY this evidence proves the claim!
Next: Lesson 6 will model the 3 Core Analytical Questions!
Evidence Support Activity Sheet 3.2 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 6
Evidence Support Activity Sheet
How Does My Evidence Support My Claim? • The 3 Core Analytical Questions
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Learning Target:
"I can explain how and why my evidence supports my claim."
Part 1: Model Thinking Aloud Using 3 Core Questions
📌 Section 3 I DO
Whenever you introduce a piece of evidence, ask yourself these three questions to build deep reasoning:
Question 1: What? "What does this evidence tell me?"
State the literal fact or number in your own words.
Question 2: Why? "Why is this evidence important?"
Explain the real-world consequence or human impact.
Question 3: How? "How does it support my claim?"
Bridge the fact directly back to your overall position.
Teacher Model Claim: "Schools should fund free breakfast." • Evidence: "Nurse visits for stomachaches fell 45%."
• Q1 (What): Almost half of all morning stomach illness complaints disappeared.
• Q2 (Why): When students aren't hungry, they avoid physical pain and stay in class instead of missing lessons in the nurse's office.
• Q3 (How): This supports the claim because free breakfast directly protects learning time by eliminating health distractions.
Part 2
Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO (Model) WE DO (Turn)
The 3-Step Expansion Formula:
1. Specific Who / What
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain purpose or outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded):
Plain: "Trees help cities."
Expanded: "Urban shade trees cool down concrete neighborhoods during summer heatwaves , for example lowering sidewalk temperatures near bus stops so commuters stay safe."
WE DO • Your Turn: Apply the formula to expand this plain sentence:
Plain Sentence: "Shade trees make school campuses cooler."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 6 Page 1 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 6
Reasoning Analysis & Brainstorming
Evaluate Samples with Checklist • Discuss & Rewrite • Multiple Explanations
Lesson 3.2 • Page 2 of 3
Part 3: Evaluate Reasoning Samples, Discuss & Rewrite
📌 Section 3 WE DO
Use Section 3 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet to rate each sample, discuss as a class which is best and what is missing from the other two, then rewrite one weak sample:
[Claim]: High schools should prohibit single-use plastic water bottles.
[Evidence]: According to waste audits, hydration stations caused an 85% drop in campus plastic trash.
Sample [A]: "This proves schools should ban bottles because having an 85% drop in trash means there is way less trash on campus."
Explains HOW/WHY No Echoing Bridges to Claim
Quality: Strong Needs Work
Sample [B]: "This proves schools should ban bottles because plastic water bottles are bad for the school and students."
Explains HOW/WHY No Echoing Bridges to Claim
Quality: Strong Needs Work
Sample [C]: "This data is vital because eliminating plastic bottles prevents toxic microplastics from contaminating soil, proving bans protect ecosystems."
Explains HOW/WHY No Echoing Bridges to Claim
Quality: Strong Needs Work
Class Discussion — Best: [ A / B / C ] | Missing from the other two:
Partner / Class Rewrite — Choose ONE weak sample (A or B) and rewrite it to improve it:
Part 4: Generate Multiple Possible Explanations
WE DO • Guided Practice
One piece of evidence can be explained from different angles. Brainstorm two different logical explanations below:
[Claim]: High schools should expand technical vocational apprenticeships.
[Evidence]: Graduates of apprenticeship programs earn starting salaries 40% higher than non-certified peers.
Angle 1: Financial Independence & Debt
How does a 40% higher salary help avoid loans?
Angle 2: Career Confidence & Job Security
How does certification protect young workers?
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 6 Page 2 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 6
Independent Practice: Dual Evidence Reasoning
Apply the 3 Core Questions • Write Reasoning for Two Different Pieces of Evidence (8 Points)
YOU DO
Score: _____ / 8 pts
Reading Passage: Urban Heat Islands & Campus Shade Trees 📌 Use Reference Sheet (Section 3 Stems)
Paragraph 1: City high school campuses covered in dark asphalt trap sun heat like giant heat islands, pushing outdoor temperatures over 100°F. When school districts planted shade trees along school pathways, temperature sensors showed that tree shade lowered ground asphalt heat by up to 25°F during summer heatwaves.
Paragraph 2: In addition to cooling schoolyards, city environmental data showed that mature campus trees filter out over 48 pounds of toxic smoke and dust pollution per tree every year. School nurses reported that students with asthma had 30% fewer breathing emergencies during outdoor gym classes.
[Central Provided Claim]: "City school districts should invest in planting shade trees across all urban high school campuses."
[Evidence Piece 1 (Temperature)]: Worth: 4 pts
"Temperature sensors showed that tree shade lowered ground asphalt heat by up to 25°F during summer heatwaves."
Write your reasoning statement for Evidence 1 (Use Section 3 stems on your Reference Sheet):
[Evidence Piece 2 (Air Quality & Asthma)]: Worth: 4 pts
"Mature campus trees filter out 48 pounds of toxic pollution per tree, and asthmatic students had 30% fewer breathing emergencies."
Write your reasoning statement for Evidence 2 (Check against Section 3 checklist):
Student Sheet Scoring Points Breakdown (8 pts Total): Target: 7–8 pts (Proficient)
Evidence 1 Reasoning (4 pts): Explains HOW/WHY 25°F drop matters (2 pts) + connects directly to tree investment claim (2 pts).
Evidence 2 Reasoning (4 pts): Explains HOW/WHY air filtering protects health (2 pts) + connects directly to tree investment claim (2 pts).
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 6 Page 3 of 3
Evidence Support Teacher Guide 3.3 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 6
Evidence Support Teacher Guide
Intro Script • Question of the Day • Gradual Release (I Do • We Do • You Do)
ELPA21 Level 3 HS
Lesson 6 Learning Target & Gradual Release: 45-Min (I Do • We Do • You Do)
"I can explain how and why my evidence supports my claim."
Welcome, Intro Script & Question of the Day (3 Min) Slide 2
Intro Script (Read Aloud): "Welcome back! Yesterday we learned that Reasoning is the bridge between Evidence and Claim. Today, we are going to level up your reasoning using Three Core Think-Aloud Questions: What does it tell me? Why is it important? How does it support my claim? We will practice those questions, evaluate three reasoning samples on plastic bottle bans, brainstorm two different angles for one fact, and finish by writing reasoning for two pieces of evidence on campus shade trees."
💬 Question of the Day (On Slide 2): "What is one thing in everyday life (like a phone, a pair of shoes, or a class) that has two completely different benefits depending on who you ask?"
1
Teaching Part 1: The 3 Core Think-Aloud Questions (8 Min)
I DO • Teacher Model
Model internal dialogue aloud using the three questions and the Free Breakfast example on Page 1 (pair with Section 3 of the CER Quality Reference Sheet ):
Q1 ("What does this evidence tell me?"): Summarize the literal number or fact in plain English (almost half of stomachache visits disappeared ).
Q2 ("Why is this evidence important?"): Explain the real-world consequence (students avoid pain and stay in class ).
Q3 ("How does this support my claim?"): Bridge back to your stance (free breakfast protects learning time ).
2
Teaching Part 2: Sentence Expansion Protocol (7 Min)
I DO (Model) WE DO (Practice)
🖼️ Visual Anchor: Pull up a photo of students sitting and talking under large, leafy shade trees in a sunny school courtyard.
💬 Anticipatory Questions: 1) Where do students prefer to sit outside at 95°F—on open asphalt or under a tree? 2) How does shade change the ground temperature? 3) What happens to students' energy during outdoor gym without shade?
Student Practice Prompt (WE DO): "Shade trees make school campuses cooler."
Exemplar Expansion: "Mature oak and maple shade trees dramatically cool urban high school campuses, for example lowering courtyard asphalt ground temperatures by twenty-five degrees so students avoid heat exhaustion."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 6 Teacher Guide Page 1 of 2
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 6
Brainstorming & Dual Evidence Scoring
Step-by-Step Instructions for Parts 3 & 4 (We Do) and Part 5 (You Do)
Lesson 3.2 Guide • Page 2 of 2
3
Teaching Parts 3 & 4: Checklist Evaluation, Rewrite & Brainstorming (12 Min)
WE DO • Guided Practice
• Part 3 Blind Checklist Debrief (WE DO): Have students test Samples A, B, and C against Section 3 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet before discussing:
– Sample [A] (Needs Work): Echoes the 85% drop without explaining why trash reduction matters.
– Sample [B] (Needs Work): Vague assertion ("bad for the school" ) with zero HOW/WHY link.
– Sample [C] (Strong — Best): Explains toxic microplastic prevention and ecosystem protection.
– Class/Partner Rewrite Exemplar (Fixing A or B): "This 85% drop proves bans work because removing plastic waste stops non-biodegradable trash from polluting local waterways."
• Part 4 Multiple Explanations Drill (WE DO): Guide students to see how the 40% salary fact supports apprenticeships via Angle 1 (Financial debt prevention) vs. Angle 2 (Career job stability).
4
Scoring Part 5 Dual Evidence Independent Assessment (8 Pts) (15 Min)
YOU DO • Independent
Allow students to reference Section 3 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet for connective reasoning stems and self-check criteria. Evaluate reasoning for both evidence pieces on Campus Shade Trees using this 8-point rubric:
Evidence 1: Temperature (4 pts): • 2 pts: Explains HOW/WHY 25°F reduction matters (cooling hot asphalt prevents heat exhaustion during recess/gym).
• 2 pts: Explicitly links this cooling outcome back to why districts should invest in tree planting.
Evidence 2: Air Quality (4 pts): • 2 pts: Explains HOW/WHY filtering 48 lbs of pollution matters (clean air protects asthmatic students from breathing emergencies).
• 2 pts: Explicitly links health protection back to the district tree investment claim.
Exemplar Dual Student Reasoning (8/8 Points):
• Evidence 1 Reasoning: "This temperature data is vital because extreme asphalt heat creates dangerous courtyard heat islands. Shading pathways drops surface temperatures, ensuring teenagers can walk between classes and participate in outdoor physical education without risking heat cramps."
• Evidence 2 Reasoning: "This air quality finding directly confirms that tree canopies serve as biological air filters. Removing forty-eight pounds of vehicle exhaust prevents toxic airborne particles from triggering student asthma attacks, proving tree investments protect daily student health."
Record final student score (0–8 pts) on Curriculum Overview Roster (Column: W3 L6 Sheet). Target: 7–8 pts
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 6 Teacher Guide Page 2 of 2
Evidence Support Formative Check - Week 3 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 Formative Check
Evidence Support Formative Check
Target: I can explain how and why my evidence supports my claim.
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Score: ______ / 8 pts
Directions: In Part 1, analyze strong vs. weak reasoning. In Part 2, read the text snippet and write connective reasoning statements for two different pieces of evidence.
Part 1: Analyzing Strong vs. Weak Reasoning
Total: 2 pts (1 pt each)
1. Claim: "High schools should install electric vehicle charging stations." Worth: 1 pt
Evidence: "EV charging stations reduce campus vehicle emissions by 40%." Which option represents Strong Reasoning that explains the connection?
[A] This data is vital because cutting emissions removes toxic exhaust, protecting students from asthma.
[B] This proves stations are needed because emissions drop by 40% on campus.
2. Claim: "High schools should ban weekend homework." Worth: 1 pt
Why is: "This shows homework is bad because students hate doing homework on weekends" an example of Weak Reasoning ?
[A] It echoes a generic emotion instead of explaining HOW rest prevents exhaustion and improves learning.
[B] It provides too much scientific medical data about teen sleep restructuring.
Part 2: Write Reasoning for Two Different Pieces of Evidence
Total: 6 pts (3 pts each)
Reading Snippet: Urban High School Tree Canopies
"Infrared monitors recorded that campus shade trees lowered asphalt ground heat by 25°F. Furthermore, mature trees absorbed 48 pounds of toxic pollution per tree, resulting in 30% fewer asthma emergencies."
Claim: "School districts should invest in planting shade trees across urban high school campuses."
Task A: Write Reasoning for Evidence 1 (25°F Heat Drop): Worth: 3 pts
Explain HOW & WHY cooling asphalt ground heat supports the tree investment claim:
Task B: Write Reasoning for Evidence 2 (48 lbs Pollution & 30% Fewer Asthma Visits): Worth: 3 pts
Explain HOW & WHY filtering toxic air pollution supports the tree investment claim:
Checklist:
[ ] Part 1 MC (2 pts) [ ] Evidence 1 Reasoning (3 pts) [ ] Evidence 2 Reasoning (3 pts)
Exceeds (7–8 pts) Accurate MC answers; writes original, non-circular reasoning for both facts explaining HOW and WHY they prove the claim.
Proficient (6 pts) Both MC items correct; reasoning explains the real-world connection for both evidence pieces with minimal echo.
Developing (<6 pts) Echoes or repeats the numbers without explanation; confuses evidence with reasoning; needs targeted reteaching.
Evidence Support Instructional Slides UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 3 • Lesson 6 Student Sheet Companion Deck
Lesson 6 Master Presentation
How Does Evidence Support Claims?
The 3 Core Think-Aloud Questions
Learning Target: "I can explain how and why my evidence supports my claim."
Part 1 (I DO) The 3 Questions
Part 2 (I/WE) Expansion Formula
Part 3–4 (WE DO) Samples & Angles
Part 5 (YOU DO) Dual Evidence (8 Pts)
Welcome • Today's Plan & Question of the Day Warm-Up
💬 Question of the Day:
"What is one thing in everyday life (like a phone, a pair of shoes, or a class) that has two completely different benefits depending on who you ask?"
Coming Up Today:
• Learn the 3 Core Think-Aloud Questions (Part 1) & Sentence Expansion (Part 2)
• Evaluate 3 reasoning samples on plastic bottles & brainstorm 2 angles for one fact (Parts 3–4)
• Write reasoning for two pieces of evidence on campus shade trees (Part 5 • 8 Pts)
Share your answer with a partner before we start Part 1!
Part 1: The 3 Core Think-Aloud Questions
I DO Page 1
Whenever You Introduce Evidence, Ask Yourself:
Question 1: What? "What does this evidence tell me?"
State the literal fact or number in your own words.
Question 2: Why? "Why is this evidence important?"
Explain the real-world consequence or human impact.
Question 3: How? "How does it support my claim?"
Bridge the consequence directly back to your stance.
Teacher Model (Page 1): "Schools should fund free breakfast." + "Nurse visits for stomachaches fell 45%."
Follow the Teacher Model in Part 1 on Page 1 of your activity packet!
Part 2: The 3-Step Sentence Expansion Formula
I DO WE DO
1. Specific Words
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain the direct outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded): "Trees help cities." → "Urban shade trees cool down concrete neighborhoods during summer heatwaves, for example lowering sidewalk temperatures near bus stops so commuters stay safe."
WE DO • Your Turn on Page 1: Expand "Shade trees make school campuses cooler."
Write your expanded sentence in the Part 2 box on Page 1!
Part 3: Evaluate Reasoning Samples, Discuss & Rewrite
WE DO Page 2
Claim: High schools should prohibit single-use plastic water bottles. | Evidence: Hydration stations caused an 85% drop in campus plastic trash.
Sample [A]: "This proves schools should ban bottles because having an 85% drop in trash means there is way less trash on campus."
Sample [B]: "This proves schools should ban bottles because plastic water bottles are bad for the school and students."
Sample [C]: "This data is vital because eliminating plastic bottles prevents toxic microplastics from contaminating soil, proving bans protect ecosystems."
Check each with Section 3, discuss which is best & what is missing, then rewrite A or B on Page 2!
Part 4: Generate Multiple Possible Explanations
WE DO Page 2
Claim & Evidence:
"High schools should expand technical vocational apprenticeships." • Evidence: "Graduates of apprenticeship programs earn starting salaries 40% higher than non-certified peers."
Angle 1: Financial Independence & Debt
How does a 40% higher starting salary help young adults avoid loans and support themselves?
Angle 2: Career Confidence & Job Security
How does earning an industry certification protect young workers in the job market?
Brainstorm both explanation angles in Part 4 on Page 2!
Part 5: Independent Practice • Dual Evidence Text
YOU DO Page 3
Paragraph 1:
"City high school campuses covered in dark asphalt trap sun heat like giant heat islands, pushing outdoor temperatures over 100°F. When school districts planted shade trees along school pathways, temperature sensors showed that tree shade lowered ground asphalt heat by up to 25°F during summer heatwaves."
Paragraph 2:
"In addition to cooling schoolyards, city environmental data showed that mature campus trees filter out over 48 pounds of toxic smoke and dust pollution per tree every year. School nurses reported that students with asthma had 30% fewer breathing emergencies during outdoor gym classes."
Provided Claim: "City school districts should invest in planting shade trees across all urban high school campuses."
Read both paragraphs carefully on Page 3 before writing your reasoning!
Part 5: Independent Assessment • 8-Point Rubric
YOU DO Page 3
Evidence 1: Temperature (4 Pts)
• 2 pts: Explains HOW and WHY the 25°F drop matters.
• 2 pts: Connects directly to the shade tree claim.
Evidence 2: Air Quality (4 Pts)
• 2 pts: Explains HOW and WHY filtering 48 lbs of pollution matters.
• 2 pts: Connects directly to the shade tree claim.
Use Section 3 stems on your Reference Sheet and ask: What does it tell me? Why is it important? How does it support my claim?
Next Week: Moving Beyond Repeating Evidence & Diagnosing Reasoning Flaws!
Developing Reasoning Activity Sheet 4.1 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 7
Developing Reasoning Activity Sheet
Moving Beyond Repeating Evidence • Developing & Strengthening Explanations
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Learning Target:
"I can develop reasoning that clearly explains the connection between my evidence and claim."
Part 1: Repeating Evidence vs. Explaining Evidence
📌 Section 3 I DO
Many students think they are writing reasoning when they are really just repeating their evidence. Compare the two:
Repeating Evidence (The Echo Trap):
"This proves schools need gardens because data shows students in garden clubs ate 30% more fresh vegetables."
❌ Problem: Repeats the 30% stat without adding any new explanation!
Explaining Evidence (Quality Connection):
"This data is vital because harvesting food builds lifelong dietary habits, ensuring teenagers choose nutritious meals over processed snacks."
✓ Strength: Explains WHY eating 30% more vegetables matters to health!
What is Missing in Weak Examples?
• Missing the real-world impact
• Missing the how/why step
• Missing the bridge to claim
Part 2
Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO (Model) WE DO (Turn)
The 3-Step Expansion Formula:
1. Specific Who / What
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain purpose or outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded):
Plain: "Good reasoning explains facts."
Expanded: "Strong academic reasoning explains why a text fact proves a claim, for example showing how lower bus fares help low-income students arrive at school on time."
WE DO • Your Turn: Apply the formula to expand this plain sentence:
Plain Sentence: "Repeating evidence is not good reasoning."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 7 Page 1 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 7
Expanding & Revising Reasoning
Evaluate Samples with Checklist • Discuss & Rewrite • Revising Weak Explanations
Lesson 4.1 • Page 2 of 3
Part 3: Evaluate Reasoning Samples, Discuss & Rewrite
📌 Section 3 WE DO
Use Section 3 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet to rate each sample, discuss as a class which is best and what is missing from the other two, then rewrite one weak sample:
[Claim]: High schools should delay start times until after 8:30 a.m.
[Evidence]: Medical data shows starting at 8:30 a.m. gave teens 45 minutes more sleep and cut tardiness by 25%.
Sample [A]: "This is important because school starts at 8:30 a.m. and students sleep 45 minutes more."
Explains HOW/WHY No Echoing Bridges to Claim
Quality: Strong Needs Work
Sample [B]: "This proves later start times are good because teenagers need sleep to do better in school."
Explains HOW/WHY No Echoing Bridges to Claim
Quality: Strong Needs Work
Sample [C]: "This finding is significant because sleeping forty-five minutes longer aligns with adolescent biological sleep clocks, allowing students to reach deep REM sleep which clears morning brain fog and ensures teenagers arrive alert for first-period algebra."
Explains HOW/WHY No Echoing Bridges to Claim
Quality: Strong Needs Work
Class Discussion — Best: [ A / B / C ] | Missing from the other two:
Partner / Class Rewrite — Choose ONE weak sample (A or B) and rewrite it to improve it:
Part 4: Identify What is Missing & Revise Weak Reasoning
📌 Section 3 WE DO
[Claim]: High schools should prohibit homework on weekends. | [Evidence]: Heavy weekend homework causes sleep deprivation and exhaustion.
Weak Reasoning: "This proves homework should be banned because students are exhausted and need sleep."
What is missing?
Your Revised Developed Reasoning (Add the missing learning outcome!):
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 7 Page 2 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 7
Practice Writing Developed Explanations
Transforming Basic Claims & Evidence into Full Analytical Reasoning
Lesson 4.1 • Page 3 of 3
Part 5: Practice Writing Developed Explanations
📌 Section 3 Stems YOU DO
For each scenario below, do NOT just repeat the evidence. Use a connective stem from Section 3 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet to detail HOW the action works and WHY it benefits students:
[Claim]: High schools should establish a policy banning single-use plastic water bottles.
[Evidence]: Audits showed water refill stations reduced campus plastic trash by 85% and saved families $210 per year.
Write Your Developed Reasoning (Explain the environmental and family financial benefits):
[Claim]: High schools should expand technical vocational apprenticeships.
[Evidence]: Certified apprentice graduates earn starting salaries 40% higher than non-certified peers.
Write Your Developed Reasoning (Explain how certified trade skills protect young adults):
Developed Reasoning Checklist (Section 3):
[ ] Adds new consequence [ ] Explains HOW/WHY [ ] Zero quote repetition
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 7 Page 3 of 3
Developing Reasoning Teacher Guide 4.1 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 7
Developing Reasoning Teacher Guide
Intro Script • Question of the Day • Gradual Release (I Do • We Do • You Do)
ELPA21 Level 3 HS
Lesson 7 Learning Target & Gradual Release: 45-Min (I Do • We Do • You Do)
"I can develop reasoning that clearly explains the connection between my evidence and claim."
Welcome, Intro Script & Question of the Day (3 Min) Slide 2
Intro Script (Read Aloud): "Welcome to Week 4! Last week you learned how to build reasoning using the 3 Core Questions. This week, we are making your reasoning stronger by escaping the 'Echo Trap'—repeating your evidence instead of explaining it. Today, we will compare echoing versus explaining, practice sentence expansion, evaluate three reasoning samples on school start times, fix a weak homework statement together, and write developed reasoning for two scenarios."
💬 Question of the Day (On Slide 2): "What is a time someone gave you a 'circular answer' (like 'because I said so' or 'because it is the rule')—and what did you actually want to know?"
1
Teaching Part 1: Repeating Evidence vs. Explaining It (8 Min)
I DO • Teacher Model
Step 1 (The Echo Trap): Explain to students: "Many writers fall into the 'Echo Trap.' They state a piece of evidence, and then their reasoning just says the exact same fact in different words! That is not reasoning—that is an echo!"
Step 2 (What is Missing?): Walk through the 3 missing elements: "Whenever you catch an echo, ask: What is missing? Is it the real-world impact? Is it the how/why step? Is it the bridge to the claim?"
📌 Reference Sheet Tip: Have students keep Section 3 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet on their desks to spot the "No Echoing" rule and use connective stems in Parts 3, 4, and 5.
2
Teaching Part 2: Sentence Expansion Protocol (7 Min)
I DO (Model) WE DO (Practice)
🖼️ Visual Anchor: Pull up a simple graphic or photo of a parrot / echo wave next to a bridge connecting two islands so students can contrast repeating vs. bridging.
💬 Anticipatory Questions: 1) If a friend says, "This movie is good because it's good," did they explain why? 2) What is the difference between repeating a fact and explaining what the fact means? 3) Why does a reader need you to build a bridge from the quote to your claim?
Student Practice Prompt (WE DO): "Repeating evidence is not good reasoning."
Exemplar Expansion: "Merely echoing text facts fails to provide persuasive academic reasoning, for example repeating statistical percentages without explaining what human benefit or community problem they prove."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 7 Teacher Guide Page 1 of 2
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 7
Expansion Modeling & Practice Facilitation
Step-by-Step Instructions for Parts 3 & 4 (We Do) and Part 5 (You Do)
Lesson 4.1 Guide • Page 2 of 2
3
Teaching Parts 3 & 4: Checklist Evaluation, Rewrite & Guided Revision (12 Min)
WE DO • Guided Practice
• Part 3 Blind Checklist Debrief (WE DO): Have students test Samples A, B, and C against Section 3 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet before discussing:
– Sample [A] (Needs Work — Echo): Repeats 8:30 a.m. and 45 minutes with zero biological or learning explanation.
– Sample [B] (Needs Work — Vague): Missing specific HOW/WHY ("to do better in school" is too generic).
– Sample [C] (Strong — Best): Explains adolescent sleep clocks, REM sleep, and readiness for first-period algebra.
– Partner/Class Rewrite Exemplar (Fixing A or B): "This evidence proves later start times work because 45 extra minutes of sleep prevents morning exhaustion, helping teens focus on morning quizzes."
Part 4 Revision Exemplar (WE DO — Weekend Homework):
"This finding is significant because two full rest days allow adolescent brains to recover from five days of intense academic pressure, ensuring teenagers return on Monday refreshed and cognitively prepared for new curriculum."
4
Teaching Part 5: Independent Practice on Developed Explanations (15 Min)
YOU DO • Independent
📌 Reference Sheet Tip: Encourage students to start each response using a stem from Section 3 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet (e.g., "This evidence proves... because..." ).
Task 1 (Plastic Bottle Ban) Exemplar:
"This data proves bottle bans are essential because reducing municipal waste by 85% removes non-biodegradable plastics from leaching toxic microchemicals into local soil, while keeping over two hundred dollars in family pockets annually."
Task 2 (Apprenticeships) Exemplar:
"This evidence demonstrates why vocational programs are vital because earning forty percent higher wages right out of high school provides young adults with immediate financial security without burdening their families with crippling college loans."
Lesson 7 Formative Checkpoints: Exit Assessment
Exceeds Identifies missing links in weak reasoning; rewrites statements adding vivid context and real-world outcomes with zero quote repetition.
Proficient Moves beyond repeating evidence; explains the real-world consequence and links back to the claim.
Developing Echoes evidence numbers/phrases; writes incomplete explanations; needs teacher prompt: "What happens after this fact?"
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 7 Teacher Guide Page 2 of 2
Developing Reasoning Instructional Slides UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 7 Student Sheet Companion Deck
Lesson 7 Master Presentation
Moving Beyond Repeating Evidence
Developing & Strengthening Reasoning
Learning Target: "I can develop reasoning that clearly explains the connection between my evidence and claim."
Part 1 (I DO) The Echo Trap
Part 2 (I/WE) Expansion Formula
Part 3–4 (WE DO) Samples & Revise
Part 5 (YOU DO) Developed Practice
Welcome • Today's Plan & Question of the Day Warm-Up
💬 Question of the Day:
"What is a time someone gave you a 'circular answer' (like 'because I said so' or 'because it is the rule')—and what did you actually want to know?"
Coming Up Today:
• Contrast Repeating vs. Explaining Evidence (Part 1) & Sentence Expansion (Part 2)
• Evaluate 3 reasoning samples on school start times & revise a weak homework statement (Parts 3–4)
• Write developed explanations for two new scenarios independently (Part 5)
Share your answer with a partner before we start Part 1!
Part 1: The Echo Trap vs. Quality Explanation
I DO Page 1
Stop Repeating Your Evidence in Different Words!
Repeating Evidence (The Echo Trap):
"This proves schools need gardens because data shows students in garden clubs ate 30% more fresh vegetables."
❌ Repeats the 30% stat without adding any new meaning!
Explaining Evidence (Quality Connection):
"This data is vital because harvesting food builds lifelong dietary habits, ensuring teenagers choose nutritious meals over processed snacks."
✓ Explains WHY eating 30% more vegetables matters to health!
What is missing in weak reasoning? 1. Real-world impact | 2. The how/why step | 3. The bridge to claim!
Keep Section 3 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet on your desk!
Part 2: Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO WE DO
1. Specific Words
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain the direct outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded): "Good reasoning explains facts." → "Strong academic reasoning explains why a text fact proves a claim, for example showing how lower bus fares help low-income students arrive at school on time."
WE DO • Your Turn on Page 1: Expand "Repeating evidence is not good reasoning."
Write your expanded sentence in the Part 2 box on Page 1!
Part 3: Evaluate Reasoning Samples, Discuss & Rewrite
WE DO Page 2
Claim: High schools should delay start times until after 8:30 a.m. | Evidence: Teens got 45 min more sleep and tardiness dropped 25%.
Sample [A]: "This is important because school starts at 8:30 a.m. and students sleep 45 minutes more."
Sample [B]: "This proves later start times are good because teenagers need sleep to do better in school."
Sample [C]: "This finding is significant because sleeping forty-five minutes longer aligns with adolescent biological sleep clocks, allowing students to reach deep REM sleep which clears morning brain fog and ensures teenagers arrive alert for first-period algebra."
Check each with Section 3, discuss which is best & what is missing, then rewrite A or B on Page 2!
Part 4: Identify What is Missing & Revise Weak Reasoning
WE DO Page 2
Claim & Evidence:
"High schools should prohibit homework on weekends." • Evidence: "Heavy weekend homework causes sleep deprivation and exhaustion."
Weak Reasoning: "This proves homework should be banned because students are exhausted and need sleep."
Your 2-Step Task on Page 2: 1) Identify what is missing. 2) Write your revised developed reasoning (add the missing learning outcome)!
Use a connective stem from Section 3 of your Reference Sheet!
Part 5: Independent Practice • Developed Explanations
YOU DO Page 3
Task 1: Plastic Bottle Bans
Claim: "High schools should establish a policy banning single-use plastic water bottles."
Evidence: "Audits showed water refill stations reduced campus plastic trash by 85% and saved families $210 per year."
→ Write your developed reasoning on Page 3!
Task 2: Vocational Apprenticeships
Claim: "High schools should expand technical vocational apprenticeships."
Evidence: "Certified apprentice graduates earn starting salaries 40% higher than non-certified peers."
→ Write your developed reasoning on Page 3!
Use Section 3 stems and avoid repeating the evidence!
Developed Reasoning Checklist Key Takeaway
Before You Finish Any Reasoning Statement, Check:
✓ Did I add a new consequence? (Zero quote repetition!)
✓ Did I explain HOW and WHY? (Showed the step-by-step connection.)
✓ Did I bridge to my claim? (Showed why this proves my overall stance.)
Next Lesson: Evaluating and Improving Reasoning—Ranking Responses from Weakest to Strongest!
Next: Lesson 8 will evaluate and rank student CER responses!
Evaluating Reasoning Activity Sheet 4.2 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 8
Evaluating Reasoning Activity Sheet
Evaluating & Improving Reasoning • Ranking CER Responses • Revising Flaws
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Learning Target:
"I can develop reasoning that clearly explains the connection between my evidence and claim."
Part 1: Diagnostic Guide • The Four Types of Reasoning
📌 Section 3 I DO
When evaluating student writing, reasoning usually falls into one of four distinct categories:
1. Repetitive (Echo)
Simply restates the evidence in slightly different words without adding any new explanation or real-world consequence.
2. Unclear (Vague)
Uses confusing, generic words ("this is good because things get better" ) that fail to trace how the change happens.
3. Unrelated
Brings up a completely off-topic idea that has no logical connection to the initial claim or evidence.
4. Strongly Connected
Clearly explains HOW the evidence works and WHY it directly proves the claim is correct.
Part 2
Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO (Model) WE DO (Turn)
The 3-Step Expansion Formula:
1. Specific Who / What
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain purpose or outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded):
Plain: "Electric buses are cleaner."
Expanded: "Zero-emission electric school buses protect neighborhood air quality, for example eliminating diesel exhaust fumes at morning bus stops so students with asthma breathe safely."
WE DO • Your Turn: Apply the formula to expand this plain sentence:
Plain Sentence: "Evaluating weak reasoning helps us write better."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 8 Page 1 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 8
Ranking & Diagnosing Reasoning
Analyze 4 CER Responses • Rank Weakest to Strongest • Identify Flaws
Lesson 4.2 • Page 2 of 3
Part 3: Analyze & Rank 4 CER Responses on Electric Buses
📌 Section 3 WE DO
All four students responded to the prompt: "Should school districts replace diesel buses with electric buses?" Use Section 3 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet to identify each reasoning category and rank them from #1 (Weakest) to #4 (Strongest) :
[Common Claim]: Districts should replace diesel buses with electric buses.
[Common Evidence]: Air quality studies confirmed electric buses eliminate diesel exhaust fumes, cutting bus stop particulate pollution by 40%.
Response [A]: Category: [ Repetitive / Unclear / Unrelated / Strongly Connected ]
"This shows districts should buy electric buses because bus stops had 40% less pollution when electric buses were driving around."
Response [B]: Category: [ Repetitive / Unclear / Unrelated / Strongly Connected ]
"This proves electric buses are necessary because school district yellow buses look really nice driving down neighborhood suburban streets."
Response [C]: Category: [ Repetitive / Unclear / Unrelated / Strongly Connected ]
"This finding is critical because cutting toxic diesel fumes protects developing student lungs, preventing severe asthma attacks among children waiting at morning stops."
Response [D]: Category: [ Repetitive / Unclear / Unrelated / Strongly Connected ]
"This is important because when things happen with air, it makes everything way better for everybody at the school."
Your Ranking from Weakest (#1) to Strongest (#4):
Rank #1 (Weakest): Letter: [ _____ ]
Unrelated Flaw
Rank #2: Letter: [ _____ ]
Unclear / Vague
Rank #3: Letter: [ _____ ]
Repetitive Echo
Rank #4 (Strongest): Letter: [ _____ ]
Strongly Connected
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 8 Page 2 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 8
Independent CER Revision & Reflection
Diagnose Flaws • Revise Weak Reasoning • Explain Your Improvements (8 Points)
YOU DO
Score: _____ / 8 pts
Part 4: Original Weak CER Response to Audit: 📌 Use Reference Sheet (Section 3 Stems)
"City governments should fund after-school community centers. City recreation records show after-school juvenile crime dropped by 32% in neighborhoods with community centers. This proves community centers work because when there are centers, crime drops 32% and things are good. "
Task A: Diagnose the Reasoning Flaw (2 pts): Worth: 2 pts
Which flaw is present above? Explain what is missing:
Task B: Write Your Revised, Strong CER Response (4 pts): Worth: 4 pts
Keep the Claim and Evidence. Replace the flawed bold sentence using a stem from Section 3 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet detailing HOW and WHY after-school programs keep teens safe:
Task C: Explain Your Revisions (2 pts): Worth: 2 pts
Explain why your new reasoning connects the 32% drop directly back to city funding:
Scoring Breakdown (8 pts Total): Target: 7–8 pts (Proficient)
Diagnosis (2 pts): Correctly identifies repetitive echo & vague wording.
Revision (4 pts): Explains HOW supervised recreation prevents crime (2 pts) and bridges to claim (2 pts).
Justification (2 pts): Explains how revision eliminates the circular flaw.
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 8 Page 3 of 3
Evaluating Reasoning Teacher Guide 4.2 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 8
Evaluating Reasoning Teacher Guide
Intro Script • Question of the Day • Gradual Release (I Do • We Do • You Do)
ELPA21 Level 3 HS
Lesson 8 Learning Target & Gradual Release: 45-Min (I Do • We Do • You Do)
"I can develop reasoning that clearly explains the connection between my evidence and claim."
Welcome, Intro Script & Question of the Day (3 Min) Slide 2
Intro Script (Read Aloud): "Welcome back! Yesterday we learned how to escape the Echo Trap. Today, you become the writing coach: we are going to diagnose the four types of reasoning—Repetitive, Unclear, Unrelated, and Strongly Connected. You will rank four student CER responses on electric school buses from weakest to strongest, and then independently audit, revise, and justify a weak response on community centers."
💬 Question of the Day (On Slide 2): "If you were judging a cooking show or a talent show, what is the biggest mistake a contestant could make that would make you give them a low score?"
1
Teaching Part 1: Diagnostic Reasoning Categories (8 Min)
I DO • Teacher Model
Walk students through the 4 categories on Page 1 alongside Section 3 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet :
1. Repetitive (Echo): Restates evidence in slightly different words without adding new meaning.
2. Unclear (Vague): Uses empty filler language ("things get better," "it is good" ).
3. Unrelated: Discusses a separate topic that does not prove the initial claim.
4. Strongly Connected: Clearly explains HOW and WHY the evidence validates the claim.
2
Teaching Part 2: Sentence Expansion Protocol (7 Min)
I DO (Model) WE DO (Practice)
🖼️ Visual Anchor: Pull up a photo of an editor or coach reviewing a rough draft or game film and circling one spot to improve.
💬 Anticipatory Questions: 1) How does watching game film or checking a rough draft help someone improve? 2) Why is it easier to spot a mistake in someone else's writing than in our own? 3) What is one clue that a reasoning sentence needs fixing?
Student Practice Prompt (WE DO): "Evaluating weak reasoning helps us write better."
Exemplar Expansion: "Diagnosing weak reasoning statements sharpens student argumentative writing, for example catching circular echo sentences and replacing them with vivid real-world explanations."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 8 Teacher Guide Page 1 of 2
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 8
Ranking Master Key & Revision Rubric
Step-by-Step Instructions for Part 3 (We Do) and Part 4 (You Do)
Lesson 4.2 Guide • Page 2 of 2
3
Teaching Part 3: Ranking 4 CER Responses Master Key (12 Min)
WE DO • Guided Practice
Rank #1 (Weakest): Response [B]
Flaw: Unrelated. Talks about yellow buses looking nice in suburbs; proves zero emission benefits!
Rank #2: Response [D]
Flaw: Unclear / Vague. Says "things happen with air and it's better for everybody" without naming anything specific.
Rank #3: Response [A]
Flaw: Repetitive. Repeats the 40% pollution drop without explaining why cleaner air protects student health.
Rank #4 (Strongest): Response [C]
Strength: Strongly connected. Explains how eliminating fumes prevents asthma attacks at morning bus stops.
4
Scoring Part 4 Independent CER Revision (8 Pts Total) (15 Min)
YOU DO • Independent
Allow students to use Section 3 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet to diagnose the flaw and choose a connective stem for Task B. Evaluate revisions on the Community Center Response using this 8-point rubric:
Task A: Diagnosis (2 pts): Accurately identifies the circular echo (repeats 32% drop) and vague filler wording ("things are good" ).
Task B: Revision (4 pts): Retains Claim & Evidence; writes a fully developed reasoning statement explaining HOW after-school programs keep teens engaged and safe (2 pts) and bridges back to claim (2 pts).
Task C: Justification (2 pts): Explains why the new reasoning eliminates the repetitive flaw and provides a logical connection.
Exemplar Full CER Student Revision (8/8 Points):
"City governments should fund after-school community centers. City recreation records show after-school juvenile crime dropped by 32% in neighborhoods with community centers. This evidence proves municipal funding is vital because supervised recreational programs give teenagers safe spaces and positive mentorship during peak unsupervised hours between 3:00 and 6:00 p.m., directly keeping young people away from dangerous street influences. "
Record final student score (0–8 pts) on Curriculum Overview Roster (Column: W4 L8 Sheet). Target: 7–8 pts
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 8 Teacher Guide Page 2 of 2
Reasoning Revision Formative Check - Week 4 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 Formative Check
Reasoning Revision Formative Check
Target: I can develop reasoning that clearly explains the connection between my evidence and claim.
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Score: ______ / 8 pts
Directions: In Part 1, diagnose reasoning flaws. In Part 2, audit the weak CER response, write an improved revision that clearly explains the connection, and justify your changes.
Part 1: Diagnosing Flaws in Reasoning
Total: 2 pts (1 pt each)
1. Claim: "High schools should provide free public bus passes." Worth: 1 pt
Evidence: "Free passes increased attendance by 18%." Reasoning: "This proves passes work because when students get free passes, attendance goes up 18%." Which flaw is present?
[A] Repetitive Echo: Repeats the 18% number without explaining why fare relief helps students attend.
[B] Strongly Connected: Clearly details how public transit budgets operate.
2. Claim: "Schools should install rooftop solar panels." Worth: 1 pt
Evidence: "Lincoln High saved $45,000 on electricity." Reasoning: "This proves solar works because sunlight is a natural resource created by nuclear fusion in outer space." Which flaw is present?
[A] Unrelated: Space science is interesting, but it fails to connect electric savings to school benefits.
[B] Repetitive Echo: Repeats the dollar savings twice.
Part 2: Audit & Revise a Weak CER Response
Total: 6 pts
Original Weak Student Response:
"High schools should build campus greenhouses. Studies show students who garden eat 30% more fresh vegetables. This shows greenhouses are good because eating 30% more vegetables is healthy and good for students. "
Task A: Diagnose the Flaw (2 pts): Explain what is missing from the bold reasoning
Task B: Write Your Developed Revision (3 pts): Keep Claim & Evidence; write strong connective reasoning
Task C: Explain Why Your Revision is Stronger (1 pt): Why does it eliminate the echo flaw?
Exceeds (7–8 pts) Accurate MC diagnoses; explains circular flaw; writes developed reasoning detailing dietary outcomes without echoing.
Proficient (6 pts) Both MC items correct; identifies repetitive flaw; writes a logical reasoning statement adding student benefits.
Developing (<6 pts) Repeats the 30% statistic in revision; fails to diagnose circular repetition; needs reteaching on the 4 flaws.
Evaluating Reasoning Instructional Slides UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 4 • Lesson 8 Student Sheet Companion Deck
Lesson 8 Master Presentation
Evaluating & Improving Reasoning
Ranking CER Responses & Fixing Flaws
Learning Target: "I can develop reasoning that clearly explains the connection between my evidence and claim."
Part 1 (I DO) The 4 Categories
Part 2 (I/WE) Expansion Formula
Part 3 (WE DO) Rank Responses
Part 4 (YOU DO) Revise Weak CER
Welcome • Today's Plan & Question of the Day Warm-Up
💬 Question of the Day:
"If you were judging a cooking show or a talent show, what is the biggest mistake a contestant could make that would make you give them a low score?"
Coming Up Today:
• Learn the 4 Categories of Student Reasoning (Part 1) & Sentence Expansion (Part 2)
• Analyze & rank 4 CER responses on electric school buses from weakest to strongest (Part 3)
• Independently audit, revise, and justify a weak CER response (Part 4 • 8 Pts)
Share your answer with a partner before we start Part 1!
Part 1: The 4 Categories of Student Reasoning
I DO Page 1
1. Repetitive (Echo)
Repeats evidence facts or numbers in slightly different words without adding any new meaning.
2. Unclear (Vague)
Uses generic filler words ("things get better," "it's good" ) that fail to explain how.
3. Unrelated
Discusses a totally off-topic idea that has zero logical connection to the initial claim.
4. Strongly Connected
Clearly explains HOW the evidence operates and WHY it proves the claim!
Keep Section 3 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet on your desk!
Part 2: Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO WE DO
1. Specific Words
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain the direct outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded): "Electric buses are cleaner." → "Zero-emission electric school buses protect neighborhood air quality, for example eliminating diesel exhaust fumes at morning bus stops so students with asthma breathe safely."
WE DO • Your Turn on Page 1: Expand "Evaluating weak reasoning helps us write better."
Write your expanded sentence in the Part 2 box on Page 1!
Part 3: Analyze & Rank 4 CER Responses on Electric Buses
WE DO Page 2
Response [A]: "This shows districts should buy electric buses because bus stops had 40% less pollution when electric buses were driving around."
Response [B]: "This proves electric buses are necessary because school district yellow buses look really nice driving down neighborhood suburban streets."
Response [C]: "This finding is critical because cutting toxic diesel fumes protects developing student lungs, preventing severe asthma attacks among children waiting at morning stops."
Response [D]: "This is important because when things happen with air, it makes everything way better for everybody at the school."
Identify each category (Repetitive, Unclear, Unrelated, Strongly Connected) and rank #1–#4 on Page 2!
Part 4: Audit & Revise a Weak CER Response
YOU DO Page 3
Original Weak CER Response to Audit:
"City governments should fund after-school community centers. City recreation records show after-school juvenile crime dropped by 32% in neighborhoods with community centers. This proves community centers work because when there are centers, crime drops 32% and things are good. "
Your 3 Tasks on Page 3: Task A: Diagnose the flaw | Task B: Write your revised CER | Task C: Explain your revisions!
Use Section 3 stems on your Reference Sheet for Task B!
Part 4: Independent Revision • 8-Point Rubric
YOU DO Page 3
Task A: Diagnosis (2 Pts) Identifies the reasoning flaw and what is missing.
Task B: Revision (4 Pts) Replaces flawed sentence with HOW & WHY explanation + bridge to claim.
Task C: Justification (2 Pts) Explains why your new reasoning eliminates the flaw.
Check your finished revision against Section 3 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet!
Next Week: Guided Application Workshop & Independent CER Capstone!
Guided Application Activity Sheet 5.1 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 9
Guided Application Activity Sheet
Guided CER Application • Peer Evaluation Checklist • Feedback Revision
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Learning Target:
"I can independently write a CER response with clear reasoning that connects my evidence to my claim."
Part 1: The Complete CER Framework Review
📌 Sections 1–3 I DO
Review the three core building blocks before writing today's response:
1. Claim
A clear, focused 1-sentence answer to the prompt that takes a firm position.
2. Evidence
A specific text detail, number, or quote cited with an attribution tag.
3. Reasoning
An explanation detailing HOW and WHY the evidence proves the claim.
Part 2
Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO (Model) WE DO (Turn)
The 3-Step Expansion Formula:
1. Specific Who / What
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain purpose or outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded):
Plain: "Peer feedback improves writing."
Expanded: "Structured peer feedback helps high school writers catch missing explanations, for example spotting where a partner repeated a statistic instead of explaining why it matters."
WE DO • Your Turn: Apply the formula to expand this plain sentence:
Plain Sentence: "Youth centers keep teens safe after school."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 9 Page 1 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 9
Reading & Draft Construction
Read Text • Plan Claim, Evidence & Reasoning • Put It All Together
Lesson 5.1 • Page 2 of 3
Part 3: Reading Text: Community Youth Centers & Mentorship WE DO
Paragraph 1: In many city neighborhoods, working parents cannot be home when high school lets out at 3:00 p.m. National youth safety studies show that over 60% of teen crime and accidents happen between 3:00 and 6:00 p.m., when teens are home alone without organized activities.
Paragraph 2: In cities that opened free community youth centers with sports teams, computer clubs, and tutors, teen arrests dropped by 32% over two years. High school graduation rates in those areas also rose by 14% because center tutors gave students daily homework help.
Prompt: "Should city governments fund free after-school community youth centers?"
📌 Sections 1–3 WE DO
Part 4A: Your Clear Quality Claim (Section 1):
Part 4B: Select & Quote Relevant Evidence (Section 2 Attribution Tag):
Part 5: Write Connective Reasoning (Section 3 Connective Stems):
Put It All Together: Complete CER Draft Paragraph WE DO • Draft
Combine your Claim (4A), Evidence (4B), and Reasoning (5) into one complete, connected paragraph below before peer review:
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 9 Page 2 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 9
Peer Review & Polished Revision
Peer Evaluation Checklist • Applying Feedback • Final Polished CER Draft
Lesson 5.1 • Page 3 of 3
Part 6: Peer Evaluation Using Reasoning Checklist WE DO • Partner
Trade papers with your partner (Partner: __________________). Evaluate their draft from Page 2 using your CER Quality Reference Sheet :
[ ] 1. Quality Claim: Clear full sentence? Answers the prompt? Takes a firm side?
[ ] 2. Relevant Evidence: Specific text data? Uses an attribution tag (According to... )?
[ ] 3. Connective Reasoning: Explains HOW and WHY? Bridges the fact back to the claim?
[ ] 4. Zero Echo Repetition: Does NOT just repeat the 32% stat? Adds real-world meaning?
Partner Feedback Advice: One thing to improve in the reasoning: ____________________________________________________
Part 7: Final Polished CER Revision YOU DO • Independent
Read your partner's feedback. Independently write your complete, polished CER response below with seamless connective reasoning:
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 9 Page 3 of 3
Guided Application Teacher Guide 5.1 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 9
Guided Application Teacher Guide
Intro Script • Question of the Day • Gradual Release (I Do • We Do • You Do)
ELPA21 Level 3 HS
Lesson 9 Learning Target & Gradual Release: 45-Min (I Do • We Do • You Do)
"I can independently write a CER response with clear reasoning that connects my evidence to my claim."
Welcome, Intro Script & Question of the Day (3 Min) Slide 2
Intro Script (Read Aloud): "Welcome to Week 5—our final week! You have built every single skill of a strong CER writer: Claims, Evidence, Reasoning, and Revision. Today is our Guided Application Workshop. We will review the complete CER framework, practice sentence expansion, read an article on community youth centers, draft a full CER paragraph, trade with a partner for peer feedback, and polish your final version."
💬 Question of the Day (On Slide 2): "If you could open a free after-school hangout spot for teens in your neighborhood, what is the #1 activity or feature it would have to have?"
1
Teaching Parts 1 & 2: CER Review & Expansion (8 Min)
I DO (Review/Model) WE DO (Turn)
Step 1 (I DO — CER Synthesis Review): Remind students to use all three sections of their CER Quality Reference Sheet to assemble a unified paragraph today.
🖼️ Visual Anchor: Pull up a photo of teenagers at an after-school community center playing basketball, doing homework with a tutor, or using computers.
💬 Anticipatory Questions: 1) What happens in a neighborhood between 3:00 and 6:00 p.m. when parents are still at work? 2) What activities make a youth center somewhere teens want to go? 3) How can mentors and tutors after school change a student's grades?
Part 2 Exemplar Expansion ("Youth centers keep teens safe after school."): "Neighborhood community youth centers protect adolescents during peak unsupervised hours, for example offering tutoring and sports leagues between 3:00 and 6:00 p.m. so teenagers avoid dangerous street activities."
2
Teaching Parts 3, 4 & 5: Reading, Planning & Draft Paragraph (14 Min)
WE DO • Guided Draft
Guide students through reading Community Youth Centers & Mentorship on Page 2, planning Parts 4A, 4B, and 5 using Sections 1–3 of their CER Quality Reference Sheet , and combining them into the Put It All Together: Complete CER Draft Paragraph box:
Exemplar Claim (Part 4A): "City governments should allocate municipal funding to establish free after-school community youth centers."
Exemplar Evidence (Part 4B): "According to juvenile justice data, cities with free community youth centers experienced a 32% drop in teen arrests and a 14% increase in graduation rates."
Exemplar Reasoning (Part 5): "This evidence demonstrates that youth centers protect both community safety and academic futures by providing structured sports and tutoring during peak unsupervised hours."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 9 Teacher Guide Page 1 of 2
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 9
Peer Review Protocol & Revision Facilitation
Step-by-Step Instructions for Part 6 (We Do) and Part 7 (You Do)
Lesson 5.1 Guide • Page 2 of 2
3
Teaching Part 6: Peer Review Using Reasoning Checklist (10 Min)
WE DO • Peer Partners
Pair students into writing partners. Direct them to trade packets and review their partner's Complete CER Draft from Page 2 using the 4 checklist items alongside their CER Quality Reference Sheet :
Reviewer Step 1 & 2: • Check for a clear claim that directly answers the question.
• Verify that evidence has an attribution tag (According to... ).
Reviewer Step 3 & 4: • Audit the reasoning: Does it explain HOW and WHY?
• Catch Echoes: Did the writer just repeat the 32% stat? If so, tell them to explain the human benefit!
4
Teaching Part 7: Final Polished CER Revision (10 Min)
YOU DO • Independent
Students retrieve their own papers and write their finalized, seamless CER response independently on Page 3.
Complete Exemplar Final Paragraph:
"City governments should establish free after-school community youth centers in urban neighborhoods. According to municipal youth safety records, neighborhoods with community centers recorded a 32% drop in juvenile crime and a 14% increase in graduation rates. This evidence proves that public funding for youth centers is an essential investment in adolescent wellbeing. Specifically, this works by providing structured recreation, academic tutoring, and trusted adult mentorship between 3:00 and 6:00 p.m., directly keeping teenagers away from dangerous unsupervised street environments while giving them the daily homework assistance needed to complete high school successfully."
Lesson 9 Formative Checkpoints: Workshop Assessment
Exceeds Integrates constructive peer feedback; writes complete CER paragraph with seamless transitions and deep, non-repetitive reasoning.
Proficient Completes peer review checklist; revises draft to eliminate obvious echoes and explain the connection.
Developing Ignores peer feedback; retains repetitive or circular reasoning; needs teacher conference before Lesson 10 Capstone.
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 9 Teacher Guide Page 2 of 2
Guided Application Instructional Slides UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 9 Student Sheet Companion Deck
Lesson 9 Master Presentation
Guided Application Workshop
Draft • Peer Review • Revise
Learning Target: "I can independently write a CER response with clear reasoning that connects my evidence to my claim."
Part 1–2 (I/WE) CER & Expansion
Part 3 (WE DO) Read New Text
Part 4–5 (WE DO) Draft CER
Part 6–7 (WE/YOU) Review & Polish
Welcome • Today's Plan & Question of the Day Warm-Up
💬 Question of the Day:
"If you could open a free after-school hangout spot for teens in your neighborhood, what is the #1 activity or feature it would have to have?"
Coming Up Today:
• Review the Complete CER Framework (Part 1) & Sentence Expansion (Part 2)
• Read about community youth centers and draft a complete CER paragraph (Parts 3–5)
• Trade with a partner for peer feedback and polish your final CER response (Parts 6–7)
Share your answer with a partner before we start Part 1!
Part 1: The Complete CER Framework Review
I DO Page 1
Assembling All Three Elements into One Cohesive Response:
1. Quality Claim
Clear, full-sentence stance answering the question. Focused on one main topic.
2. Text Evidence
Specific text data, statistics, or facts embedded with an attribution tag (According to... ).
3. Connective Reasoning
Explains HOW and WHY the evidence proves the claim, with zero quote repetition!
Keep all 3 sections of your CER Quality Reference Sheet on your desk!
Part 2: Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO WE DO
1. Specific Words
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain the direct outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded): "Peer feedback improves writing." → "Structured peer feedback helps high school writers catch missing explanations, for example spotting where a partner repeated a statistic instead of explaining why it matters."
WE DO • Your Turn on Page 1: Expand "Youth centers keep teens safe after school."
Write your expanded sentence in the Part 2 box on Page 1!
Part 3: Read New Text • Community Youth Centers
WE DO Page 2
Paragraph 1:
"In many city neighborhoods, working parents cannot be home when high school lets out at 3:00 p.m. National youth safety studies show that over 60% of teen crime and accidents happen between 3:00 and 6:00 p.m., when teens are home alone without organized activities."
Paragraph 2:
"In cities that opened free community youth centers with sports teams, computer clubs, and tutors, teen arrests dropped by 32% over two years. High school graduation rates in those areas also rose by 14% because center tutors gave students daily homework help."
Prompt: "Should city governments fund free after-school community youth centers?"
Read both paragraphs carefully on Page 2 before drafting your response!
Parts 4 & 5: Plan & Put It All Together
WE DO Page 2
Part 4A: Your Clear Quality Claim (Section 1):
State a clear, focused stance answering whether city governments should fund free youth centers.
Part 4B: Select & Quote Relevant Evidence (Section 2):
Choose specific data from the text and frame it with an attribution tag (According to... ).
Part 5: Write Connective Reasoning (Section 3):
Explain HOW and WHY your evidence proves your claim—without repeating the numbers!
Put It All Together: Combine 4A, 4B, and 5 into one complete CER draft paragraph at the bottom of Page 2!
Finish your complete draft paragraph on Page 2 before trading with your partner!
Part 6: Peer Review Using Reasoning Checklist
WE DO Page 3
Trade Packets with Your Partner & Check These 4 Items:
[ ] 1. Quality Claim
Clear complete sentence? Takes a firm stance answering the prompt?
[ ] 2. Relevant Evidence
Specific numbers from text? Uses attribution tag (According to... )?
[ ] 3. Connective Reasoning
Explains HOW and WHY? Bridges the fact back to the claim?
[ ] 4. Zero Echo Repetition
Did not just repeat the 32% stat? Adds real-world human meaning?
Give your partner one concrete piece of advice to improve their reasoning on Page 3!
Part 7: Final Polished CER Revision
YOU DO Page 3
Your Independent Revision Task:
1. Read your partner's checklist and feedback advice on Page 3.
2. Revise your CER draft to fix any echoes or missing connections.
3. Write your complete, polished CER paragraph in the Part 7 box!
Next Lesson: Independent Demonstration Capstone (Lesson 10)!
Write your final revised paragraph in Part 7 on Page 3!
Independent Demonstration Activity Sheet 5.2 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 10
Independent Demonstration Activity Sheet
Culminating CER Capstone • Independent Demonstration • Self-Evaluation
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Culminating Capstone Assessment: Independent Mastery
Learning Target: "I can independently write a CER response with clear reasoning that connects my evidence to my claim."
Part 1: Final Retrieval • The Three Elements of Mastery
📌 Sections 1–3 I DO
1. Quality Claim
• Clear & complete sentence.
• Focused on one stance.
• Directly answers prompt.
2. Relevant Evidence
• Specific facts / data.
• Directly connects to claim.
• Uses attribution tag.
3. Connective Reasoning
• Explains HOW & WHY.
• Real-world outcome.
• Zero quote repetition!
Part 2
Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO (Model) WE DO (Turn)
The 3-Step Expansion Formula:
1. Specific Who / What
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain purpose or outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded):
Plain: "Scholarships help students go to college."
Expanded: "Local micro-scholarships motivate high school students to earn higher grades , for example awarding $100 toward college savings when ninth graders pass all their core classes."
WE DO • Your Turn: Apply the formula to expand this plain sentence:
Plain Sentence: "Micro-scholarships motivate high school students."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 10 Page 1 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 10
Reading & CER Planning
Read Unfamiliar Text • Develop Your Claim • Select Strongest Evidence
Lesson 5.2 • Page 2 of 3
Part 3: Unfamiliar Reading Text: Micro-Scholarships & Student Motivation YOU DO
Paragraph 1: Many low-income high school students feel that college scholarships are only for top-ranked seniors with straight A's. To change this, several school districts teamed up with community groups to create "micro-scholarship" programs. These programs deposit small cash awards ($50 to $200) directly into college savings accounts whenever a student earns perfect attendance, brings up a grade, or finishes a science project.
Paragraph 2: Program studies showed that in schools offering micro-scholarships, ninth and tenth-grade class passing rates rose by 26%. In addition, 88% of students said they felt confident they could afford college, and college financial aid applications jumped by 34%.
Part 4 Prompt: "Should high schools establish micro-scholarship programs to motivate students?"
📌 Sections 1 & 2 YOU DO
Step 1: Develop Your Independent Quality Claim (Section 1 Checklist):
Step 2: Select & Quote Strongest Evidence with an Attribution Tag (Section 2 Checklist):
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 10 Page 2 of 3
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 10
Independent Demonstration Capstone
Write Complete CER Response • Self-Evaluate with Success Criteria (9 Points)
YOU DO
Score: _____ / 9 pts
Part 5: Complete CER Written Response
📌 Use Reference Sheet (Section 3 Stems)
Write your complete paragraph combining your Quality Claim, Cited Evidence, and Connective Reasoning (check against all 3 checklists on your CER Quality Reference Sheet ):
Part 6: Self-Evaluate Using Success Criteria Rubric (9 Pts Total) Target: 8–9 pts
[ ] Claim (2 pts) Clear full sentence answering prompt; focused on specific stance.
[ ] Evidence (2 pts) Relevant data cited from text with proper attribution tag.
[ ] Reasoning (3 pts) Explains HOW and WHY; adds real-world outcome; zero echo!
[ ] Cohesion (2 pts) Uses transition stems; includes concluding wrap-up sentence.
My Self-Scored Points: [ _____ / 9 pts ] Teacher Confirmed: [ _____ / 9 pts ]
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 10 Page 3 of 3
Independent Demonstration Teacher Guide 5.2 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 10
Independent Demonstration Teacher Guide
Intro Script • Question of the Day • Capstone Administration (I Do • We Do • You Do)
ELPA21 Level 3 HS
Culminating Capstone Assessment (Lesson 10): 45-Min (I Do • We Do • You Do)
Learning Target: "I can independently write a CER response with clear reasoning that connects my evidence to my claim."
Welcome, Intro Script & Question of the Day (3 Min) Slide 2
Intro Script (Read Aloud): "Welcome to Day 10—your Culminating CER Capstone! Over the past five weeks, you have learned how to write clear claims, cite specific text evidence, and build strong connective reasoning without falling into the echo trap. Today is your chance to show everything you know on your own: we will do a quick retrieval review and sentence expansion warm-up, then you will read a brand-new article on micro-scholarships, plan and write a complete CER response, and self-evaluate with our 9-point rubric."
💬 Question of the Day (On Slide 2): "What is one goal you have for after high school—and what is one small reward right now that would keep you motivated to reach it?"
1
Administration Protocol & Pacing (42 Min)
YOU DO • Capstone
1. Retrieval & Plan (10 Min): I Do / We Do: Review Part 1 & expand Part 2. You Do: Students read Page 2 and plan Claim & Evidence.
2. Independent Write (22 Min): You Do: Silent independent writing on Page 3. Synthesize Claim, Evidence with tag, and Connective Reasoning.
3. Self-Evaluation (10 Min): You Do: Students audit their own writing against the 9-point Success Criteria rubric and record their score.
📌 Reference Sheet EL Accommodation Note: Allow Level 3 English learners to keep their CER Quality Reference Sheet (Sections 1–3 checklists and sentence stems) on their desks during planning, writing, and self-evaluation.
2
Part 2: Sentence Expansion Modeling
I DO (Model) WE DO (Practice)
🖼️ Visual Anchor: Pull up a photo of a high school student celebrating a scholarship award or checking a college savings goal tracker.
💬 Anticipatory Questions: 1) Why do many ninth and tenth graders feel like college scholarships are out of reach? 2) If you could earn $50–$100 for college every time you passed a class, how would that affect your effort? 3) Why do small rewards right now motivate people more than a big reward years away?
Warm-Up Prompt (WE DO): "Micro-scholarships motivate high school students."
Exemplar Expansion: "Targeted college micro-scholarships powerfully motivate underrepresented high school students, for example depositing cash rewards into college accounts when ninth graders achieve perfect attendance or complete science projects."
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 10 Teacher Guide Page 1 of 2
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 10
Capstone Rubric & Final Summative Writing Guide
9-Point Activity Rubric + Teacher Reminder Script for Capstone CER Summative Assessment
YOU DO • Independent
Activity Sheet 5.2 Rubric (9 Points Total): Mastery Target: 8–9 pts
1. Quality Claim (2 pts): Clear, complete sentence answering the prompt with a focused, definitive stance (1 pt if informal/broad).
2. Relevant Text Evidence (2 pts): Cites specific data (26% pass rate increase or 34% financial aid jump) with an attribution tag (According to... ).
3. Connective Reasoning (3 pts): Explains both HOW and WHY; links cash incentives to motivation and college attainment; zero echo.
4. Cohesion & Clincher Sentence (2 pts): Uses seamless transition connectors and includes a strong concluding sentence wrapping up the argument.
Activity Sheet 5.2 Exemplar Response (9/9 Points):
"High school districts should partner with community groups to establish student micro-scholarship programs. According to program studies, high schools offering micro-scholarships saw ninth and tenth-grade class passing rates rise by 26% and college financial aid applications jump by 34%. This evidence demonstrates that micro-grants turn distant college dreams into immediate, achievable goals by rewarding daily academic milestones, which motivates teenagers to attend tutoring while giving low-income families hope for higher education. Therefore, investing in micro-scholarships empowers students to build successful academic futures."
📝 Final Summative Writing Administration (Media Literacy): Capstone Summative
Teacher Reminder Script (Read Aloud Before Students Begin): "For your final summative writing on Media Literacy, remember that you have practiced your CER work all five weeks—your Claim, Evidence, and Reasoning will be the most important piece here! At the same time, do not forget to introduce your topic at the beginning, use transitions and good, specific details throughout your writing, and create a strong conclusion at the end."
Media Literacy Evidence Bank (For Teacher Reference): Students can cite that 82% of teens could not tell real news from paid ads (Paragraph 1), or that a one-semester Media Literacy class led to a 64% increase in identifying reliable sources and 79% of students pausing to fact-check before sharing (Paragraph 2).
Record final score on Page 2 of Curriculum Overview Teacher Guide (Column: W5 L10 Sheet). Intervention Total: 39 Pts
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 10 Teacher Guide Page 2 of 2
Culminating Capstone Formative Check - Week 5 UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Culminating Capstone
Culminating Capstone Formative Check
Target: I can independently write a complete CER response with clear connective reasoning.
Name: ___________________________
Date: ____________ Period: _______
Score: ______ / 9 pts
Independent Capstone Task: Read the reading passage below silently on your own. Develop a quality claim, cite relevant evidence with an attribution tag, and write deep connective reasoning explaining HOW and WHY the evidence proves your claim.
Reading Passage: College Micro-Scholarships 2 Paragraphs
Many low-income high school students assume that college scholarships are reserved only for elite top-ranked seniors. To bridge this gap, several school districts partnered with community foundations to launch "micro-scholarship" programs that award small cash grants ($50 to $200) directly into college savings accounts each time a student achieves perfect attendance or completes STEM tutoring. Program data revealed that ninth-grade course passing rates increased by 26%, and college financial aid FAFSA completion jumped by 34%.
Prompt: "Should high schools establish micro-scholarship programs to motivate students?" 9 Points Total
1. Your Clear Quality Claim (2 pts): [Clear stance answering prompt]
2. Relevant Text Evidence with Attribution Tag (2 pts): [e.g., According to the text...]
3. Connective Reasoning (3 pts) & Concluding Wrap-Up Sentence (2 pts): [Explains HOW & WHY with zero quote repetition]
Capstone Success Criteria Rubric (9 pts Total): Mastery Target: 8–9 pts
Claim (2 pts): Clear, full sentence answering prompt.
Evidence (2 pts): Cited data with attribution tag.
Reasoning (3 pts): Explains HOW & WHY; zero echo.
Cohesion (2 pts): Smooth transition & clincher wrap-up.
Independent Demonstration Instructional Slides UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Lesson 10 Culminating Capstone
Lesson 10 Master Presentation
Independent Demonstration
CER Capstone Mastery
Learning Target: "I can independently write a CER response with clear reasoning that connects my evidence to my claim."
Part 1 (I DO) Final Retrieval
Part 2–3 (I/WE/YOU) Unfamiliar Text
Part 4–5 (YOU DO) Independent CER
Part 6 (YOU DO) 9-Pt Rubric
Welcome • Today's Plan & Question of the Day Warm-Up
💬 Question of the Day:
"What is one goal you have for after high school—and what is one small reward right now that would keep you motivated to reach it?"
Coming Up Today:
• Quick retrieval review of all 3 CER elements (Part 1) & Sentence Expansion (Part 2)
• Read an unfamiliar article on micro-scholarships and plan your Claim & Evidence (Parts 3–4)
• Independently write your complete CER paragraph and self-evaluate (Parts 5–6 • 9 Pts)
Share your answer with a partner before we start Part 1!
Part 1: Final Retrieval • The Three Elements of Mastery
I DO Page 1
Everything You Need for Today's Capstone:
1. Quality Claim
Clear full sentence stating a definitive stance on the prompt question.
✓ Answers question directly!
2. Text Evidence
Relevant data cited from text with an attribution tag (According to... ).
✓ Verifiable facts & figures!
3. Connective Reasoning
Explains HOW & WHY the evidence proves the claim, with zero quote repetition.
✓ Explains real-world impact!
Keep Sections 1–3 of your CER Quality Reference Sheet on your desk!
Part 2: Sentence Expansion • The 3-Step Formula
I DO WE DO
1. Specific Words
Upgrade plain nouns & verbs
2. Add Why / Purpose
Explain the direct outcome
3. Real Example
Use for example or such as
I DO • Model Example (Plain → Expanded): "Scholarships help students go to college." → "Local micro-scholarships motivate high school students to earn higher grades, for example awarding $100 toward college savings when ninth graders pass all their core classes."
WE DO • Your Turn on Page 1: Expand "Micro-scholarships motivate high school students."
Write your expanded sentence in the Part 2 box on Page 1!
Part 3: Unfamiliar Reading Text • Micro-Scholarships
YOU DO Page 2
Paragraph 1:
"Many low-income high school students feel that college scholarships are only for top-ranked seniors with straight A's. To change this, several school districts teamed up with community groups to create 'micro-scholarship' programs. These programs deposit small cash awards ($50 to $200) directly into college savings accounts whenever a student earns perfect attendance, brings up a grade, or finishes a science project."
Paragraph 2:
"Program studies showed that in schools offering micro-scholarships, ninth and tenth-grade class passing rates rose by 26% . In addition, 88% of students said they felt confident they could afford college, and college financial aid applications jumped by 34% ."
Prompt: Should high schools establish micro-scholarship programs to motivate students?
Read both paragraphs carefully on Page 2!
Part 4: Planning Your CER Response
YOU DO Page 2
Step 1: Develop Your Independent Quality Claim
Write a complete sentence that directly answers the prompt and takes a clear, focused side.
Check Section 1: Clear Answer • Focused Stance • Text-Supported
Step 2: Select & Quote Strongest Evidence with Attribution Tag
Choose the strongest fact or statistic from the reading and frame it with an attribution tag (According to... ).
Check Section 2: Relevant • Specific • Text-Based
Complete your planning steps on Page 2 before writing your paragraph on Page 3!
Part 5: Complete CER Written Response
YOU DO Page 3
Writing Instructions for Page 3:
• Claim: State your clear, focused stance.
• Evidence: Quote your text evidence with an attribution tag.
• Reasoning: Use Section 3 stems to explain HOW and WHY the evidence proves your claim (zero echo!).
• Cohesion: Add transition words and a strong concluding wrap-up sentence.
Write independently and silently on Page 3!
Write your full paragraph in Part 5 on Page 3!
Part 6: Success Criteria Rubric (9 Points Total)
YOU DO Page 3
2 Points Quality Claim Clear, focused full sentence
2 Points Text Evidence Specific data + attribution tag
3 Points Reasoning Explains HOW & WHY; zero echo
2 Points Cohesion Transitions & clincher wrap-up
Audit your own paragraph against these 4 standards and check your boxes on Page 3!
Congratulations on completing the 5-week CER Writing Intervention!
Capstone CER Summative Assessment UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Final Summative Writing
Capstone CER Summative Assessment
Name: _________________________
Date: __________________________
Directions:
Read the two-paragraph article below carefully. Then respond to the prompt question in a complete, polished written response. Your Claim, Evidence, and Reasoning (CER) are the core of your response—and be sure to introduce your topic, use transitions and specific details, and end with a strong conclusion . You may use your CER Quality Reference Sheet .
Media Literacy in High School
2-Paragraph Source Text
High school students spend an average of seven hours each day scrolling through social media feeds, short videos, and online news posts. However, a national Stanford education study found that 82% of teenagers could not tell the difference between a real news report and a paid advertisement disguised as an article. When young people share false health advice, edited photos, or misleading political posts without checking the source, rumors spread across school campuses within minutes.
In school districts that added a required one-semester Media Literacy class , students learned how to verify authors, cross-check statistics, and spot manipulated images. Following the course, participating high schools saw a 64% increase in students accurately identifying reliable sources on research projects, and 79% of students reported pausing to fact-check posts before sharing them online. Teachers also noted that classroom debates became more respectful because students backed up their opinions with verified facts instead of viral claims.
Summative Writing Prompt:
Should high schools require all students to complete a Media Literacy class before graduation?
Your Written Response (Continue onto Page 2): Topic Intro • Claim • Evidence • Reasoning • Transitions & Details • Conclusion
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Capstone CER Summative Assessment Page 1 of 2
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Final Summative Writing
Capstone CER Summative Assessment (Continued)
Page 2 of 2
Final Writer's Self-Check (Check Each Box Before Turning In):
[ ] Introduced the topic clearly
[ ] Stated a clear, focused Claim
[ ] Cited specific text Evidence
[ ] Explained HOW & WHY (Reasoning)
[ ] Used transitions & good details
[ ] Ended with a strong Conclusion
UHS - T3 - Writing 2 • Week 5 • Capstone CER Summative Assessment Page 2 of 2