Sycamore Secret Worksheet
Indiana Academic Standards • Grade 4 ELA (4.RC.1 & 4.RL.2) Literary Analysis
Name:
Date:
Score:
Southern Indiana Historical Fiction
The Secret of Sycamore Creek
Grade 4 • Lexile: 740L
Reading Purpose: Pay close attention to how Maya and Leo react differently to danger, how the Indiana creek setting affects their actions, and what life lesson they learn.
[1] Sunlight filtered through the white-barked sycamore trees, casting dancing shadows across the rocky bed of Sycamore Creek. In southern Indiana, late October had painted the limestone bluffs in copper and gold. Ten-year-old Maya knelt beside a calm gravel bar, gently brushing wet sand from a star-shaped crinoid fossil with her magnifying glass.
[2] "Maya, hurry over here!" hollered her eight-year-old brother, Leo. He balanced recklessly on a wet, algae-covered rock ledge right above a swirling deep pool. "There's an old treasure chest carved under this sycamore root!" Maya carefully stood and crossed the dry stones. Wedged into the riverbank mud was a flat limestone block. Faint grooves formed numbers and an arrow: 1842 • SEC. 14 • ROAD SURV.
[3] "I’m going to pry it out!" Leo yelled, hoisting a heavy oak branch like a crowbar. "Wait, Leo," Maya cautioned, placing a steady hand on his shoulder. "This limestone is weathered and brittle. That rough branch will scrape away the pioneer marks or shatter the slab. Look above the ridge, too." Dark thunderclouds were rolling quickly from the west, and chilly wind rattled through the dry autumn leaves.
[4] Leo lowered the branch with a sigh. Maya quickly opened her canvas field bag, pulled out her notebook, and sketched the stone's carvings, noting its compass direction and distance from the bluff. Suddenly, Leo's sneaker slipped on the slick moss. With a sharp gasp, he dropped his flashlight into the swirling pool and tipped backward toward the deep water.
[5] Maya didn't panic. Bracing her feet against two dry limestone boulders, she thrust forward her sturdy hickory walking stick. "Grab the handle, Leo! Pull forward!" Leo locked both hands onto the wood, and Maya hauled him firmly onto the safe gravel bar. Shivering and wide-eyed, Leo looked at his soaked shoes, then at Maya's detailed sketch. "You saved me from a freezing plunge," he admitted. Maya zipped her notebook into her waterproof pouch and smiled. "Grandpa always says the woods reward the patient, not the hurried. Let's race the storm home."
First-Read Check: Context Clues & Detail
1. In paragraph 3, Maya notes the limestone is weathered. This means it is:
A) Painted recently by local park rangers
B) Worn down and weakened by natural elements
C) Heated up by hot summer sunshine
D) Buried beneath volcanic ash and dirt
2. What artifact did Maya and Leo actually find along the creek bank?
A) A historic 1842 road survey boundary marker
B) A locked wooden chest filled with gold coins
C) An old iron railroad spike from an abandoned train
D) A fossilized turtle shell wedged between tree roots
Indiana Academic Standards ELA • Grade 4 Literary Elements Page 1 of 2 • Continue to Analysis Questions
Reading Comprehension & Analysis
Literary Elements Investigation
Text: "The Secret of Sycamore Creek"
Directions: Use text evidence, character actions, and story details to complete each section below.
1. Character Contrast (Standard 4.RL.2.3)
Analyze traits through actions & dialogue
Maya Trait: Observant & Cautious
Describe one action Maya takes that proves she is cautious and prepared:
Leo Trait: Impulsive & Eager
Describe one action Leo takes that proves he acts quickly without thinking:
2. Setting & Story Problem (Standard 4.RL.2.3)
How do the southern Indiana setting (the slick limestone creek bed) and the approaching autumn storm increase the danger for the characters?
3. Plot Turning Point (Standard 4.RL.2.3)
Which event marks the climax (the moment of greatest tension and turning point) in the story?
A) Maya examining crinoid fossils on the gravel bar
B) Leo slipping on algae and Maya rescuing him with her walking stick
C) Leo reading the numbers carved into the limestone stone
D) Maya placing her field journal into a waterproof pouch
4. Determining Theme with Text Evidence (Standard 4.RL.2.2 & 4.RC.1)
Part A: What central theme or message does the author convey through Maya and Leo's adventure?
A) Children should avoid exploring nature without an adult.
B) Real treasures can only be found under ancient sycamore trees.
C) Patience, preparation, and careful observation keep people and history safe.
D) Moving quickly is the best way to accomplish outdoor tasks.
Part B: Quote or describe one detail from paragraph 4 or 5 that supports your choice in Part A, and explain how it supports the theme:
Indiana Academic Standards ELA • Grade 4 Literary Elements Worksheet Page 2 of 2 • End of Assessment
Sycamore Secret Answer Key
Teacher Reference & Scoring Guide • Indiana Standards 4.RC.1 & 4.RL.2 Answer Key
Sycamore Secret Answer Key
Total Possible Score: 16 Points
Worksheet Page 1: First-Read Quick Check (2 Points) 1 pt each
Item 1 (Context Clue): Correct: B
B) Worn down and weakened by natural elements. In paragraph 3, Maya cautions that the stone will shatter or crumble because wind and water have degraded it over time.
Item 2 (Story Detail): Correct: A
A) A historic 1842 road survey boundary marker. The markings read "1842 • SEC. 14 • ROAD SURV," proving it was an early Indiana road survey monument, not gold or an iron spike.
1. Character Contrast (Standard 4.RL.2.3 • 4 Points) 2 pts per character (1 pt action, 1 pt evidence)
Maya (Observant & Cautious):
Acceptable Student Evidence (Any one):
- She steps carefully across dry rocks instead of rushing over wet ledges [¶3].
- She warns Leo that the limestone will break and suggests sketching it safely [¶3-4].
- She notices approaching storm clouds and stays calm when rescuing Leo [¶3, 5].
- She packs a waterproof pouch and uses her sturdy hickory stick to save Leo [¶5].
Leo (Impulsive & Eager):
Acceptable Student Evidence (Any one):
- He balances recklessly on a wet, algae-coated rock ledge over deep water [¶2].
- He immediately grabs a heavy oak branch trying to pry out the stone slab [¶3].
- He ignores the oncoming thunderstorm because he wants to take the stone home [¶3-4].
- He moves hurriedly, slips on moss, drops his light, and falls backward [¶4].
2. Setting & Story Problem (Standard 4.RL.2.3 • 3 Points) Rubric: 3 = Full explanation with 2 setting factors; 2 = Partial; 1 = Minimal
Exemplar Student Response:
"The slick algae and wet limestone ledges make the creek physically hazardous, causing Leo to slip and almost fall into the deep water pool. At the same time, the fast-approaching autumn thunderstorm and cold wind create urgency and time pressure, forcing Maya to make quick, sensible decisions to sketch the stone and get them home safely."
Key Criteria to Award Full Credit: Student must mention both the physical terrain (slick limestone/deep pool) AND weather conditions (oncoming storm/cold wind/time limit).
3. Plot Turning Point / Climax (Standard 4.RL.2.3 • 2 Points) 2 pts (Multiple Choice)
Correct: B
B) Leo slipping on algae and Maya rescuing him with her walking stick. This is the climax because it represents the highest point of danger and tension, resolving Leo's dangerous behavior and changing his perspective on Maya's cautious method.
4. Determining Theme with Text Evidence (Standards 4.RL.2.2 & 4.RC.1 • 5 Points) Part A: 2 pts • Part B: 3 pts
Part A (Central Theme): Correct: C
C) Patience, preparation, and careful observation keep people and history safe. Maya's patience preserves the stone and saves Leo, while rushing almost destroys the marker and causes injury.
Part B Exemplar & Evidence:
Direct Quote / Detail: Maya reminds Leo, "Grandpa always says the woods reward the patient, never the hurried" [¶5], or Leo stating Maya "got all the clues without breaking anything" [¶5].
Explanation: This proves that taking time to sketch and prepare is far more successful than rushing recklessly.
Grading Scale: 15-16 pts (Exceeds / A) 13-14 pts (Proficient / B) 11-12 pts (Approaching / C) ≤ 10 pts (Needs Support / D-F)
Indiana Grade 4 ELA • Sycamore Creek Answer Key
