Left Foot Bandit Worksheet
Oak Street Detective Club
Name:
Date:
CASE FILE #402
The Left Foot Bandit
An Oak Street Mystery by Lenny
Maya was the neighborhood's self-appointed chief detective, and Oak Street was her beat. Usually, her cases were small—finding Mrs. Gable’s lost calico cat or tracking down the owner of a forgotten bicycle. But on Tuesday morning, Oak Street woke up to a true mystery: every single resident was missing their left shoe. Not pairs—just the left shoes.
Maya sat on her front porch, magnifying glass in hand, examining her own bare left foot. Her favorite blue sneaker was gone. Across the street, Mr. Henderson was hopping around his yard in a single black leather loafer. "This is a highly selective thief," Maya noted, jotting a clue in her notebook. She began her investigation on the garden path behind Mrs. Gable's house. There, pressed into the damp soil, was a tiny, hand-shaped footprint with five slender fingers. Beside it lay a shiny silver button.
Suddenly, a rustling sound came from the towering elm tree in the center of the park. Maya crept quietly and peered up into the leafy green branches, where a flash of grey fur scurried past. High in the fork of the elm tree sat a large, messy nest built from twigs, leaves, and a blue sneaker, a black loafer, and a red rainboot! Maya grinned. The thief wasn't a criminal at all—it was Barnaby, the mischievous neighborhood raccoon, trying to insulate his family’s nest from the upcoming autumn chill.
Instead of calling animal control, Maya gathered her neighbors and asked them to donate their old, warm towels and blankets, which they piled at the base of the tree. By the next morning, Barnaby had happily swapped the bulky shoes for the soft blankets. Maya returned every shoe to its rightful owner, closing her most successful case yet.
Detective's Word Spotlight
Expand your vocabulary to help solve the mystery!
selective (adj.): careful in choosing
insulated (adj.): padded to keep warm
Page 1 of 2 • Continue to Case Questions on Next Page
Case Investigation Worksheet
Level: 4th Grade
Comprehension Challenge
Answer the following questions based on the story "The Left Foot Bandit."
1. What specific items were disappearing from the residents of Oak Street?
A) Shiny silver buttons B) Blue sneakers only C) All types of left shoes D) Twigs and dry leaves
2. Which piece of evidence first suggested to Maya that the thief was not a human?
A) A shiny silver button in the mud B) A tiny five-fingered footprint C) A blue sneaker left in an elm tree D) Hearing rustling inside a hedge
3. Based on how the word insulated is used in the story, why did Barnaby want the shoes?
A) To wear them while playing B) To hide them from the neighbors C) To keep his winter nest warm D) To trade them for silver buttons
4. How does Maya show she is a caring and thoughtful detective in her solution?
5. What might have happened to Barnaby if Maya had reported the thief to animal control instead of solving the mystery herself?
Page 2 of 2 • Case Closed!
Left Foot Bandit Answer Key
Teacher Reference & Discussion Guide
ANSWER KEY
CASE FILE #402 • TEACHER EDITION
The Left Foot Bandit
Core Reading Skills: Inference, Vocabulary in Context, Evaluative Thinking
Maya was the neighborhood's self-appointed chief detective, and Oak Street was her beat. Usually, her cases were small—finding Mrs. Gable’s lost calico cat or tracking down the owner of a forgotten bicycle. But on Tuesday morning, Oak Street woke up to a true mystery: every single resident was missing their left shoe. Not pairs—just the left shoes.
Maya sat on her front porch, magnifying glass in hand, examining her own bare left foot. Her favorite blue sneaker was gone. Across the street, Mr. Henderson was hopping around his yard in a single black leather loafer. "This is a highly selective thief," Maya noted, jotting a clue in her notebook. She began her investigation on the garden path behind Mrs. Gable's house. There, pressed into the damp soil, was a tiny, hand-shaped footprint with five slender fingers. Beside it lay a shiny silver button.
Suddenly, a rustling sound came from the towering elm tree in the center of the park. Maya crept quietly and peered up into the leafy green branches, where a flash of grey fur scurried past. High in the fork of the elm tree sat a large, messy nest built from twigs, leaves, and a blue sneaker, a black loafer, and a red rainboot! Maya grinned. The thief wasn't a criminal at all—it was Barnaby, the mischievous neighborhood raccoon, trying to insulate his family’s nest from the upcoming autumn chill.
Instead of calling animal control, Maya gathered her neighbors and asked them to donate their old, warm towels and blankets, which they piled at the base of the tree. By the next morning, Barnaby had happily swapped the bulky shoes for the soft blankets. Maya returned every shoe to its rightful owner, closing her most successful case yet.
Before Reading
Ask students: "What kind of clues do detectives look for?" Define selective and insulated.
During Reading
Pause after paragraph 2: "What animal makes a tiny, hand-shaped footprint?" Have them predict who the 'bandit' is.
Key Themes
Discuss empathy, creative conflict resolution, and human-wildlife cohabitation in urban spaces.
Lexile Measure: 710L
Target Audience: Grade 4 readers
selective (adj.): careful in choosing
insulated (adj.): padded to keep warm
Page 1 of 2 • Teacher Guide Key
Case Answers
TEACHER SCORING GUIDE
Comprehension Challenge — Answers
Scoring Rubric: 1 point per question (total 5 points).
