Book Fair Challenge Worksheet
Book Fair Challenge
2nd Grade Math Problem Solving
Name: ________________________
Date: ____________
The Book Fair Problem
Mrs. Smith: 46 books Mr. Jones: 28 books
Mrs. Smith's second grade class collected 46 books for the school book fair. Mr. Jones's second grade class collected 28 books. Mr. Jones's class wants to collect more books so that their total is closer to Mrs. Smith's class. They do not have to collect exactly the same number of books, but they want to get as close as possible without having more books than Mrs. Smith's class.
Number Line Helper Start at 28. Do not go past 46!
28 2930313233343536373839404142434445 46 4748
1. How many more books could Mr. Jones's class collect?
Use pictures, numbers, or words to show your thinking.
Mr. Jones's class could collect more books.
2. Find at least three different possible answers.
Check that each total is 46 or less!
Answer 1
28 + =
more books
Answer 2
28 + =
more books
Answer 3
28 + =
more books
Book Fair Challenge Answer Key
Book Fair Challenge
Teacher Answer Key & Solution Strategies
Answer Key
Core Math Idea
Mr. Jones's class starts with 28 books and wants to get as close as possible to 46 books without going over. Since \(46 - 28 = 18\), the greatest number of books they can collect is 18 more books (which ties Mrs. Smith's class at 46). Any whole number from 1 to 18 keeps their total at 46 or less.
1. How many more books could Mr. Jones's class collect?
Closest Possible Answer (without going over): 18 more books (28 + 18 = 46)
Sample 2nd Grade Strategies
Strategy A: Make a Ten (Counting Up)
Start at 28. Add 2 to get to 30.
Add 10 to get to 40, then 6 to get to 46.
2 + 10 + 6 = 18 more books
Strategy B: Subtract to Find the Gap
Take 28 away from 46:
46 - 20 = 26, then 26 - 8 = 18
18 more books
2. Find at least three different possible answers.
Any three numbers from 1–18 are valid; 16, 17, 18 are closest.
Sample Answer 1
Matches Mrs. Smith's class without going over.
28 + 18 = 46
18 more books
Sample Answer 2
Just 1 book away from Mrs. Smith's class.
28 + 17 = 45
17 more books
Sample Answer 3
Gets very close (2 books away from 46).
28 + 16 = 44
16 more books
What to Look For in Student Work
- Valid Range: Accept any addition where the new total is 46 or less (1 to 18 more books), and encourage students to explain why 16, 17, or 18 are "closest."
- Watch Out For Going Over: If a student writes 19 (47) or 20 (48), prompt them to check the rule: "without having more books than Mrs. Smith's class."
- Counting-On Errors: Students who count on from 28 sometimes include 28 as "1" (getting 19 instead of 18). Have them trace hops on the number line helper.