Fleet Comparison Worksheet
Fleet Comparison
Family Vehicle Budgeting Challenge
Name: __________________________
Date: __________________________
Your Mission
Analyze the Apex Motors showroom flyers to record starting prices. Use your math skills to recommend the best vehicle for three families based on their budgets and needs.
Vehicle Price Index
| Vehicle Model | Vehicle Type | Starting MSRP |
|---|
| Toyota Camry | Sedan | |
| Honda CR-V | Compact SUV | |
| Chrysler Pacifica | Minivan | |
| Kia EV9 | Electric SUV | |
| Chevy Suburban | Full-Size SUV | |
| Mercedes Metris | Luxury Van | |
| Tesla Model X | Performance Electric | |
| Lexus LX 600 | Luxury SUV | |
Family Needs Assessment
1. The Miller Family (Budget: $40,000)
"We are a family of four looking for a fuel-efficient car. It needs to be easy to park."
Recommendation & Math:
2. The Rodriguez Family (Budget: $65,000)
"We have 6 kids and want to switch to an all-electric vehicle for weekend family trips."
Recommendation & Math:
3. The Thompson Group (Budget: $100,000)
"We need a vehicle for 8 people plus camping gear. Off-road capability is essential."
Recommendation & Math:
Final Comparison: Suburban vs. LX 600
Calculate the price difference between the Chevy Suburban and the Lexus LX 600. Why might a family choose the more expensive option? Justify your answer.
Fleet Comparison Answer Key
Answer Key
Fleet Comparison Activity
Vehicle Price Index Reference
| Visual | Vehicle Model | Starting MSRP |
|---|
| | |
| Toyota Camry | $30,245 | |
| | |
| Honda CR-V | $34,890 |
|
| Chrysler Pacifica | $44,550 |
|
| Kia EV9 | $56,700 |
|
| Chevy Suburban | $71,400 |
|
| Mercedes Metris | $83,200 |
|
| Tesla Model X | $91,990 |
|
| Lexus LX 600 | $93,915 |
Scenario Solutions
1. The Miller Family (Budget: $40,000)
Selection: Toyota Camry ($30,245)
Math: $40,000 - $30,245 = $9,755 remaining. Best efficiency and parking utility.
2. The Rodriguez Family (Budget: $65,000)
Selection: Kia EV9 ($56,700)
Math: $65,000 - $56,700 = $8,300 remaining. Fits 7 people and budget constraints.
3. The Thompson Group (Budget: $100,000)
Selection: Chevy Suburban ($71,400)
Math: $100,000 - $71,400 = $28,600 left. Maximum seats (9) and cargo space for gear.
Final Comparison Conclusion
Calculation: $93,915 - $71,400 = $22,515 difference.
Justification: Extra cost covers premium features (Lexus Safety+ 2.5, Mark Levinson audio) and luxury build quality versus the Chevy's higher seating utility.
