Rulebook Remix Slides
Grade 8 ESL • WIDA Level 4
No-Prep Speaking Task
Rulebook Remix
Debate a campus rule, defend your stance with evidence, and negotiate a smart compromise.
Quick Warm-Up Question
If you could change one school rule tomorrow, what would you change—and why?
Partner or Trio Discussion Goal: Complex Sentences + Academic Connectors
How It Works: 3 Steps
Partner Protocol
1
Pick & Prep
Choose 1 campus dilemma. One partner takes FOR, the other takes AGAINST. Jot 2 quick reasons.
2
Debate & Counter
Share your claim with an example. Listen closely, then ask 1 follow-up question or counter respectfully.
3
Remix the Rule
Drop your sides and negotiate a fair compromise that solves both partners' concerns.
Trio Option: Partner C acts as the Moderator—asking follow-up questions and helping write the final remix.
Level 4 Language Toolkit
Connect & Justify
State & Support
- From my perspective, we should... because...
- For instance, when students... it leads to...
Counter & Question
- Although I see your point about..., on the other hand...
- How would you respond if...?
Build Consensus
- To balance both sides, what if we implement...?
- As a result, everyone benefits because...
Power Verbs: implement • prioritize • impact • restrict • balance • perspective
Model Dialogue
Topic: Should school start at 9:30 AM?
Notice the Connectors
Partner A (FOR)
"From my perspective, a 9:30 AM start would impact learning positively because teens need more sleep. For instance, rested students focus better in first period."
Partner B (AGAINST + Question)
"Although sleep matters, on the other hand, ending school at 4:30 PM leaves less time for sports and jobs. How would we balance after-school activities?"
Our Rulebook Remix (Compromise)
"To balance both sides, we propose an 8:45 AM start and shorter passing periods, so students get extra rest without ending too late."
Goal: Speak in complete, connected thoughts—not one-word answers!
Your Turn: Choose a Dilemma
10-Minute Round
Option 1
Phones at Lunch
Should phones be allowed during lunch, or kept away all day?
Option 2
No-Homework Weekdays
Should schools ban homework and use in-class workshops instead?
Option 3
4-Day School Week
Should middle school switch to four longer days (Mon–Thu)?
Option 4
Student-Choice Fridays
Should students choose their own learning topics every Friday?
2 Min
Pick & Prep
3 Min
Debate & Counter
2 Min
Write Remix
3 Min
Class Share-Out
Rulebook Remix Activity
Grade 8 ESL • WIDA Level 4 Speaking
Rulebook Remix
Name: ________________________
Date: __________ Partner: ______________
How It Works
1. Pick & Prep: Choose 1 dilemma below. Pick opposite sides (FOR vs. AGAINST) and jot 2 quick reasons on Page 2.
2. Debate & Counter: Present your stance using Level 4 connectors. Ask your partner 1 follow-up question.
3. Remix & Share: Drop your sides and negotiate a fair compromise rule together.
1 Choose One Campus Dilemma (Circle Your Choice)
Use the idea sparks to get started
A. Phones at Lunch Tech Policy
Should students be allowed to use phones during lunch, or keep them away all day?
FOR: Break time, checking messages from family
AGAINST: Less face-to-face talk, cyberbullying risk
B. No-Homework Weekdays Academics
Should schools ban homework and replace it with in-class practice workshops?
FOR: Less stress, time for family & activities
AGAINST: Independent practice builds mastery
C. 4-Day School Week Schedule
Should middle school switch to four slightly longer days (Monday–Thursday)?
FOR: 3-day weekends for rest, clubs, or tutoring
AGAINST: Longer days cause fatigue, childcare issues
D. Student-Choice Fridays Curriculum
Should students choose their own learning topics and projects every Friday?
FOR: Higher motivation, builds real-world skills
AGAINST: Harder to cover required state standards
Level 4 Language Toolkit (Use at Least 2 Connectors!) Speak in complete sentences
State & Support
- • From my perspective, we should ___ because ___.
- • For instance, when students ___, it leads to ___.
Counter & Question
- • Although I see your point about ___, on the other hand ___.
- • How would you respond if ___?
Build Consensus
- • To balance both sides, what if we implement ___?
- • As a result, everyone benefits because ___.
Power Verbs: implement • prioritize • impact • restrict • balance • perspective
Rulebook Remix — Speaking Notes
Jot short bullet points—do NOT write a full script!
2 Quick Prep (2 Minutes)
Topic Letter: _____ | My Side (circle): FOR / AGAINST
List 2 reasons or real-life examples to defend your side, plus 1 connector you plan to use:
3 Listen, Question & Remix (5 Minutes)
A. What was your partner's strongest point or example?
B. Our Rulebook Remix (Write your compromise policy in 2–3 sentences to share with the class):
Step 4: Quick Speaking Check-In
Check the boxes you completed
I used at least 2 Level 4 connectors (e.g., although, for instance).
I asked or answered a follow-up question respectfully.
We negotiated a fair compromise that balances both sides.