Evidence Files: Main Idea

Subject: Reading Comprehension & Analysis

Agent:

Date:

Briefing:

Analyze the following case files. For each passage, identify the main idea (the central point the author is making) and the supporting details that provide evidence. Use the "So What?" test to confirm your findings.

CASE 01: HISTORY

The Silk Road Pulse

The Silk Road was not a single paved highway, but a vast network of trade routes stretching from China to the Mediterranean Sea. While its name suggests only the trade of luxurious fabrics, it was far more significant as a conduit for culture. Along these rugged paths, Buddhist monks traveled alongside spice merchants, and revolutionary technologies like papermaking and gunpowder flowed into Europe. This massive exchange of ideas, languages, and religions fundamentally reshaped the civilizations of both the East and the West, creating a more interconnected world long before the age of the internet.

1. Which statement best expresses the main idea of the passage?

The Silk Road was a dangerous network of roads used primarily by silk merchants.

The Silk Road was most influential as a bridge for cultural and technological exchange.

Chinese gunpowder was the most important item traded along the Silk Road.

Buddhist monks were the primary travelers responsible for maintaining the routes.

CASE 02: BIOGRAPHY

The Voice of Malala

Growing up in the Swat Valley of Pakistan, Malala Yousafzai refused to be silenced when the Taliban banned girls from attending school. Even after surviving a targeted attack at age fifteen, her resolve only strengthened. She didn't just fight for her own seat in the classroom; she became a global symbol for the right to education. Through her speeches at the United Nations and her Nobel Peace Prize recognition, Malala has turned a personal tragedy into a worldwide movement, proving that one person’s courage can challenge systemic oppression on a global scale.

2. What is the author's primary purpose in writing this paragraph?

To describe the geography and political climate of the Swat Valley in Pakistan.

To explain the specific rules the Taliban implemented regarding female education.

To highlight how Malala's bravery transformed her into a global advocate for education.

To list the various awards Malala has won since becoming famous.

CASE 03: CURRENT EVENTS

The Silicon Scholar

Artificial Intelligence is rapidly entering the modern classroom, sparking intense debate among educators. Some teachers embrace AI as a revolutionary tool that can personalize learning, providing instant feedback to students and automating administrative tasks. However, critics worry about the erosion of critical thinking skills and the potential for academic dishonesty. As schools navigate this new frontier, the focus is shifting from whether to use AI to how to use it ethically and effectively to enhance, rather than replace, the human element of teaching.

3. Which detail from the text best supports the idea that AI in schools is a controversial topic?

AI can provide instant feedback to students on their work.

The debate centers on both the benefits of personalized learning and the risks to critical thinking.

AI is capable of automating many administrative tasks for teachers.

The human element of teaching can never be fully replaced by machines.

CASE 04: FICTION

The Dusty Palette

Elias stared at the half-finished canvas leaning against his bedroom wall. Six months ago, he wouldn't have gone a day without picking up a brush, the smell of linseed oil a constant companion. Now, the bristles of his favorite brushes were stiff and dry, and the tubes of cobalt blue and cadmium red were buried under a stack of basketball magazines. He reached out to touch the canvas, then pulled his hand back, realizing that the spark that once kept him awake until dawn had simply moved elsewhere. He grabbed his sneakers and headed for the park, leaving the silent studio behind.

4. What is the implicit main idea of this story?

Elias is a talented artist who has run out of painting supplies.

Basketball is a much more difficult sport to master than painting.

Elias is experiencing a natural shift in his interests and passions.

The smell of oil paint can be overwhelming for some young artists.

Evidence Report: Justify your answer for Case 04. Which specific details from the text led you to your conclusion?

Main Idea Masterclass

Insight Investigation Slides

Passage Power Worksheet

Detective Map Organizers

Paragraph Pulse Activity

Investigation Key

Similar Lessons

Theme Weaver

vivianbelarmino

Journal Journey

vivianbelarmino

Bridge to Mastery

Nicole

Press Pass

Trudy

Persuasion Powerhouse

Danielle Burham

Reading Strategy Teacher Goals

Brenda Coombs

Logical Linkers

Donna Nelson

The Character Compass

Janine Williams

The Character Compass

Janine Williams

Voices of Change Makers

anriettepienaar

DGE Foundations

Nicole

The Art of the Rebuttal

Mary Rayburn

Gauntlet of Logic

Mary Rayburn

Crown on Trial

Christopher Boynick

Ink and Imagination

Kayle Jordan

The Hero Crisis

cedaniels

Structure Architects

Michelle Doyle

Nightmare King Quest

cedaniels